Neither are more accurate if you don't test and practice with them.
That being said - some people are spooky on turning turrets and having them return to zero - Jeff_O is ______ retentive / compulsive on it - and not in good way.
So if you don't trust turret turning - just say no.
Trust is mistated - it's really how much you trust yourself to hit using the method at hand - again practice.
I'm not mad so don't take this wrong, but a) why are you saying I'm ______ anal retentive about this, and b) why is it not a GOOD thing to be extra... retentive, lol about an endeavor where the devil most certainly does lurk in the details?
*I* would have said I'm not "retentive" ENOUGH with my LR loading/shooting practices.
Also, trust starts at the gear level and flows from there. You won't developed trust in your ability to hit, without reliable gear, because you won't be hitting.