Just picked up a bottle of Col Taylor BiB today and a bottle of Pikesville Rye.
The Taylor is always a standout after it breathes, and I hear really good things about Pikesville but I've never had it.
$40 & $51 respectively where I am. Not bargain stuff as the OP was asking for, but I consider the Taylor a bargain for $40. Needed the rye for an event in 2 weeks or I probably would have bought another bottle of HW Double Rye....
I think you'll like the Pikesville. It's a barely legal rye at 51% rye and is very bourbon like in it's flavor and very pleasant. It was my favorite rye until I tried the Rare Breed Rye.
