I own them both. I would take the EW Winchester ( spider web stock ) every time. No cheapy plastic magazine that's prone to cracking if dropped. This last season my Tikka loaded magazine( 3 rounds ) got dropped in hunting camp on hard ground. Cracked like an egg. No glue known to man will bond that plastic back together. Tried to use Duck tape on it but the extra thickness of the tape would not allow the magazine to fit in the magazine well. Ended being a single shot for the hunt. The EW has the massive positive claw extractor .My EW is in 264 mag & is an absolute tac driver with the Barnes 120gr TSX. Sub 1/2". Solid box magazine with a FLUSH fitting FLOOR PLATE..No magazine protruding down right where you need to hold the rifle. .No need to buy expensive extra magazines.I will take the Winchester hands down. No more Tikka's for me...
