Originally Posted by wreckster84
A close friend who frequently fly fishes in northern New Mexico has only ever carried bear spray for the chance encounter with bears. Just this weekend he asked for my help in selecting a handgun, which is his only consideration given the need for portability and handiness while fishing. First of all, he's not a gun guy so he will need some instruction and practice (don't we all?).

Having read plenty on various forums and online articles, here would be my guidance:
  • Stainless 4" DA revolver in either .44M or .45LC (w/ Ruger-only hardcast/+P loads).
  • S&W 629, 625, 625MG or Redhawk should work fine
  • Blue guns would also work but just thinking maintenance would be less in and around water/rain.


Availability wise, .44 Magnums seem to be more plentiful and slightly cheaper than equivalent .45LC DA.
Since he does not reload, he could buy bear loads from Underwood or Buffalo Bore if using .45LC.
Factory .44M solids should be fine.

I'm sure there are many opinions so I'll just ask, are there other recommendations to consider? Is .357M a viable alternative?

Be careful about who answers about griz protection when you listen to people that don't live or fish griz country.

I have lived with griz all my life, killed 2 and seen dozens.

I carry what ever I have with me and bear spray to season the carcass.

Intentionally in griz country, I will carry a Smith and Wesson 686 Plus. Any gun you have on your person, you had better be proficient with it and be able to deploy it in a fraction of a second.

Is there a better choice in handguns? Yes, there is not a single "Best" gun out there, but you do need to be able to hit small targets when you are $hitting your pants, or you may become bear crap...

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]