Before moving to Michigan, the couple lived in Issaquah, Washington. Before Washington, the couple lived in Jacksonville, Florida.
The criminal records of Jennifer and James Crumbley show both were convicted of drunken driving for an offense in Florida on the same day. Court records indicate they each pleaded no contest and were sentenced to probation, additional fees and fines, plus the revocation of their licenses for six months.
James Crumbley also has faced repeated charges in Florida for driving with a suspended license.
Jennifer Crumbley was charged with writing a worthless check in Florida.
Court filings indicate James Crumbley was in arrears for several thousand dollars in out-of-state child support for two different women, both in Duval County near Jacksonville, Florida. A filing from last month involved more than $1,721 in overdue support payments dating back to June 2005 for a daughter born in 1997. A separate complaint filed in June 2017 claimed $7,617 in arrears for his financial support of a son born in August 2003.
Both stated that support payment plans had been approved and ordered by courts in Florida and Michigan, but court records gave no indication if James Crumbley ever lived up to the agreements.
