I think I'd second that!
Your analogy with fishermen using the lightest tackle to land an over sized fish is a good one and I have used it myself.
I think some of the threads can go off in all directions based on the interpretation of the question.
Your suggestion that a 30+ caliber is the better choice for most larger game is imminently sensible. The problem with being sensible is that this thread probably won't go too far and won't provide the entertainment some others do.
Now, if you had asked what was the best .30 caliber for that single rifle choice, then we would still be replying to this one into next year.
AGW
