.... If the best your god can come up with is a system where Hitler gets the same punishment in the afterlife as a guy who just ate meat on a Friday then your god is either a monster or an idiot and I think that I will hold out for a better deity.
And what if Hitler accepted Jesus as his saviour just before be PPK'ed himself - that would place in heaven right now, and would make some conversations up there somewhat uncomfortable, but who's to judge?