Home
Posted By: Ken Howell Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.
I am. When I don't act like it, I still am, by the grace of God. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. smile
Trick question.
Only way.
Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


When you eventually get to the Pearly Gates, you had better hope that JC is not wearing a taqiyah!
Posted By: viking Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
Count me and mine in.
Sadly, this is bound to happen...

Quote
Matthew 7:21-23

New King James Version (NKJV)
I Never Knew You

21 �Not everyone who says to Me, �Lord, Lord,� shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father in heaven. 22 Many will say to Me in that day, �Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?� 23 And then I will declare to them, �I never knew you; depart from Me, you who practice lawlessness!�



When really, the way to Heaven according to Jesus himself is this....

Quote
John 17:3

King James Version (KJV)

3 And this is life eternal, that they might know thee the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom thou hast sent.



Relationship. It's all about relationship.



Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there?


Jesus answered, "Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God."

Jesus answered and said unto him, "Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God."
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


When you eventually get to the Pearly Gates, you had better hope that JC is not wearing a taqiyah!


For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God;
Only thru Grace.
Originally Posted by amax155
Only thru Grace.

And obedience.
I"try"to obey because I'm saved,not to be saved.

The greatest thing I ever learned is that my salvation isn't based on me.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith�and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast. Eph 2:8-9
"Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends. Ye are my friends, if ye do whatsoever I command you." (John 15:13�14)
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


That is why we get along so well.
A young priest told the Pope:" Father, I have good news and bad news."

The Pope asked for the good news first.

"Jesus has returned to Earth!"

"And the bad", asked the Pope?

"He landed in Salt Lake City"!

grin
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
"Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends. Ye are my friends, if ye do whatsoever I command you." (John 15:13�14)


Three verses later."These things I command you,that you love one another."(John 15:17)

No arguement from me that we should keep the commandments,but my salvation is based on my faith in Jesus's sacrifice for me,not in my obediance.
Posted By: EricM Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/11/13
[Linked Image]
two elderly gentlemen were sitting around chatting -

the older of the 2 - pushing 90 yrs of age , looks over at the other guy and calmly proclaims.

"I do not know when my time will come but i'm getting afraid that all my freinds that have passed away and have gone to be with our Lord in Heaven , may be starting to wonder."

the other gentalman looks over and asks- " Wonder what?"

he proclaims - "If I don't show up pretty soon - I'm sure they will all think ,I went the other way! "

Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by amax155
Only thru Grace.

And obedience.



what you mean works won't get me in?

ML
Originally Posted by EricM
[Linked Image]


Oh man! Ain't that the truth!?
What difference does it make?

When you eventually get to the Pearly Gates, you had better hope that JC is not wearing a taqiyah! [/quote]

No problem, a matter of faith!
Quote

Originally Posted By: Ken Howell
Originally Posted By: amax155
Only thru Grace.

And obedience.



what you mean works won't get me in?



Apostle Paul wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"So then, my beloved, just as you have always obeyed not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your salvation with fear and trembling;"
Philippians 2:12

Apostle John wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments; and His commandments are not burdensome." 1 John 5:3

Apostle Paul wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"If any one thinks he is a prophet or spiritual, let him recognize that the things which I write to you are the Lord's commandments." 1 Corinthians 14:37

What Part of The New Testament is it we don't have to obey because we are under Grace?
I don't think he was making that point, Ringman.

I think he was saying that Grace is WHY we were saved. I don't think he'd argue with what is expected of us once that Grace is extended to us...
Loaded post.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote

Originally Posted By: Ken Howell
Originally Posted By: amax155
Only thru Grace.

And obedience.



what you mean works won't get me in?



Apostle Paul wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"So then, my beloved, just as you have always obeyed not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your salvation with fear and trembling;"
Philippians 2:12

Apostle John wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments; and His commandments are not burdensome." 1 John 5:3

Apostle Paul wrote by the Holy Spirit:
"If any one thinks he is a prophet or spiritual, let him recognize that the things which I write to you are the Lord's commandments." 1 Corinthians 14:37

What Part of The New Testament is it we don't have to obey because we are under Grace?


Do you obey Matthew 6:6 ??
If Kenny is saved, I'll happily spend an eternity in hell.

I like those odds.
I've been a christian for 31 years. I'm glad I did and not going back. It's great being a christian and is much different than what the world portrays us .
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.
Those in Christ's sheepfold are Christians. Those outside of it are not. The Good Shepherd knows his own.
All of these posts by Christians are very true. However, we must also look at what Jesus said about those non-believers who inhabit most churches.

Mt 7:22 Many will say to me on that day, �Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?�
23 Then I will tell them plainly, �I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!�

They're the ones who depended on their works to get into heaven instead of Jesus' grace. They've never put their faith totally in Christ to save them. To repeat a scripture in an earlier post:
Eph 2:8-9 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith�and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast.

You MUST depend on grace for salvation. Those who ignore this passage in Ephesians and try to work their way in are the ones who will bitterly cry out "Lord Lord".
Originally Posted by Rock Chuck
All of these posts by Christians are very true. However, we must also look at what Jesus said about those non-believers who inhabit most churches.

Mt 7:22 Many will say to me on that day, �Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?�
23 Then I will tell them plainly, �I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!�

They're the ones who depended on their works to get into heaven instead of Jesus' grace. They've never put their faith totally in Christ to save them. To repeat a scripture in an earlier post:
Eph 2:8-9 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith�and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast.

You MUST depend on grace for salvation. Those who ignore this passage in Ephesians and try to work their way in are the ones who will bitterly cry out "Lord Lord".
Yes, the willing doing of good works (e.g., helping the needy, etc.) is a mark of sanctification, not the means of acquiring it.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


He already decided and paid for it with blood.
Originally Posted by ironeagle_84
Loaded post.

yep,..ticking time bomb...
A former friend of mine heard that one sign of genius is a plethora of projects left unfinished, so he began a plethora of projects that he intended to leave unfinished.

That never impressed me as a sign of genius.
Originally Posted by Fireball2
I am. When I don't act like it, I still am, by the grace of God. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. smile


As ashamed as I am, this is me. I need to be a better example, but our countries condition makes it very difficult for me.
KEN good post.
I will not quote the good book but I think that I might be ok.

Hope a lot of others are as well.



Happily, a member of Our Lord's original church. Delighted to be Catholic.

And, Yup, WORKS. Faith and Works are inseparable grin

Blessings,

Steve

I am not and I am perfectly content.
All I know is that as a human, I'm a sinner. I pray a lot for forgiveness and some day that the grace of God bestowed upon me at my baptism will allow to enter the eternal kingdom.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
A former friend of mine heard that one sign of genius is a plethora of projects left unfinished, so he began a plethora of projects that he intended to leave unfinished.

That never impressed me as a sign of genius.
Well said.
Im a christian and proud of it.
Originally Posted by AggieDog
Im a christian and proud of it.
Pride cometh before the fall. grin
I've studied a variety of worldviews. After lots of careful thinking, I have concluded that the Christian worldview is the one that best explains the readily observable facts about the universe in which we live. So of course I'm a Christian. For me, its not just blind faith. I arrived at my faith for very good, rational reasons. What I find incomprehensible is why someone would want Christianity to be false.

Originally Posted by Steelhead
If Kenny is saved, I'll happily spend an eternity in hell.

I like those odds.


Count me in.

"you go to heaven for the climate, hell for the company"
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Rock Chuck
All of these posts by Christians are very true. However, we must also look at what Jesus said about those non-believers who inhabit most churches.

Mt 7:22 Many will say to me on that day, �Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?�
23 Then I will tell them plainly, �I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!�

They're the ones who depended on their works to get into heaven instead of Jesus' grace. They've never put their faith totally in Christ to save them. To repeat a scripture in an earlier post:
Eph 2:8-9 For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith�and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast.

You MUST depend on grace for salvation. Those who ignore this passage in Ephesians and try to work their way in are the ones who will bitterly cry out "Lord Lord".

100%
Posted By: BrentD Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
To fundamental Jews and Muslims I probably am.

To fundamental evangelicals, I definitely not.

To me, I don't spend too much time thinking about it, much less worrying about it.
Get educated, Rancho. There is no company in hell.
The old west Texas high school principal who came in with a nickel size melanoma on his lip didn't worry about it either, but he was a christian. Now he is "healed" - of everything.
Originally Posted by achadwick
What I find incomprehensible is why someone would want Christianity to be false.


The only reason I can think of why someone would want Christianity to be false is because they think they'd give up too much fun stuff to "be a Christian". That's certainly what I used to think.
Never been able to convey what is gained. Maybe that should be a new thread topic- "What is gained by being a believer?"
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


When you eventually get to the Pearly Gates, you had better hope that JC is not wearing a taqiyah!


Or..
[Linked Image]
So start a new thread, Fireball. I give you my $0.02.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Fireball2
Originally Posted by achadwick
What I find incomprehensible is why someone would want Christianity to be false.


The only reason I can think of why someone would want Christianity to be false is because they think they'd give up too much fun stuff to "be a Christian". That's certainly what I used to think.
Never been able to covey what is gained. Maybe that should be a new thread topic- "What is gained by being a believer?"
This is why
John 3:19-21 And this is the condemnation, that the light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil. 20 For everyone practicing evil hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed. 21 But he who does the truth comes to the light, that his deeds may be clearly seen, that they have been done in God.�
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
while i like the esoteric, mystical events of a god impregnating a virgin, then the crucifixation, death and resurrection as wonderful events to energize the masses, what i really like is the Teachings of Jesus. in his example he never married, or had kids, or refrained from eating out of other's gardens.

Christians are a diverse lot, that's pretty much a military certainty.

Posted By: Dess Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
By the Grace of God I'm saved.
Posted By: PAMac Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
If i say yes..... Will i be persecuted????????
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Gus
while i like the esoteric, mystical events of a god impregnating a virgin, then the crucifixation, death and resurrection as wonderful events to energize the masses, what i really like is the Teachings of Jesus. in his example he never married, or had kids, or refrained from eating out of other's gardens.




Hebrews 10:29-31 Of how much worse punishment, do you suppose, will he be thought worthy who has trampled the Son of God underfoot, counted the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified a common thing, and insulted the Spirit of grace? 30 For we know Him who said, �Vengeance is Mine, I will repay,� says the Lord. And again, �The Lord will judge His people.� 31 It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.
Originally Posted by Fireball2
Never been able to covey what is gained. Maybe that should be a new thread topic- "What is gained by being a believer?"


I am so torn. I prayed last night that I be more Christian today.

Okay, I will.

Good luck.
Christians tell the truth. Everlasting life, Firefly 2.
I said I would be MORE Christian...not a perfect Christian.
If humans were ruling life, two weeks after the meek inherited the earth, the sonsabitches'd have it back.

edited to add �

� and ya'd hafta be one of the most thoroughly rottenest sonsabitches to be anywhere near the front of the line.
Posted By: efw Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
The older I get (and the more I wallow in, recognize, mourn my own sin) the more I come to appreciate the fact that many I expect to see in the New Heavens & New Earth will not be there, and that many I don't expect to see, will be.

God's grace and the work of His HS in calling His people unto Himself is far greater than my imagination and I am increasingly comforted by that fact.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
I struggled with my faith(Catholic) until a few years ago when I decided I wanted no part in any version of man's God.


I'll try to be the most honest and trustworthy person I can, help others when possible and be there for family and friends in need.


If that somehow dooms me to an eternity of hell....,well,...God can go [bleep] himself.
Originally Posted by Gus
while i like the esoteric, mystical events of a god impregnating a virgin, then the crucifixation, death and resurrection as wonderful events to energize the masses, what i really like is the Teachings of Jesus. in his example he never married, or had kids, or refrained from eating out of other's gardens.

Christians are a diverse lot, that's pretty much a military certainty.

Without the virgin birth, crucifixion, and resurrection, the teachings of Jesus are meaningless. If you don't believe in the resurrection, you're not a Christian at all so his teachings are worthless to you.

Romans 10:9 That if you confess with your mouth, "Jesus is Lord," and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.
Originally Posted by Malloy805
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


When you eventually get to the Pearly Gates, you had better hope that JC is not wearing a taqiyah!


Or..
[Linked Image]


Or..is funny
Originally Posted by ltppowell
I said I would be MORE Christian...not a perfect Christian.


If you meant that you want to be more Christ-like, then I agree. However, if you meant you want to be more saved, then I don't agree. There are no degrees of salvation. It's either all or nothing.
Originally Posted by rrroae
I struggled with my faith(Catholic) until a few years ago when I decided I wanted no part in any version of man's God.


I'll try to be the most honest and trustworthy person I can, help others when possible and be there for family and friends in need.


If that somehow dooms me to an eternity of hell....,well,...God can go [bleep] himself.


Okay with me. Not the God part, but your decisions, whatever they may be.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
As are your decisions or anyone else's.
Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..
Posted By: efw Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Same must go for heaven, earth, & God's people then? You didn't mention that?
Originally Posted by achadwick
Originally Posted by ltppowell
I said I would be MORE Christian...not a perfect Christian.


If you meant that you want to be more Christ-like, then I agree. However, if you meant you want to be more saved, then I don't agree. There are no degrees of salvation. It's either all or nothing.


I reckon it was worded wrong. Angelic would probably be a better term.
Posted By: efw Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by rrroae
I struggled with my faith(Catholic) until a few years ago when I decided I wanted no part in any version of man's God.


I'll try to be the most honest and trustworthy person I can, help others when possible and be there for family and friends in need.


If that somehow dooms me to an eternity of hell....,well,...God can go [bleep] himself.


I am sorry you have been so displeased with what you have seen in The Church. I certainly understand for I have seen hypocrisy not only in the institutions which claim Christ's name but in my own heart.

I must point out and with all due respect that your own practice is a version of man's god... Just yours rather than that of Church tradition or Holy Scripture or whatever...
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Rock Chuck
Originally Posted by Gus
while i like the esoteric, mystical events of a god impregnating a virgin, then the crucifixation, death and resurrection as wonderful events to energize the masses, what i really like is the Teachings of Jesus. in his example he never married, or had kids, or refrained from eating out of other's gardens.

Christians are a diverse lot, that's pretty much a military certainty.

Without the virgin birth, crucifixion, and resurrection, the teachings of Jesus are meaningless. If you don't believe in the resurrection, you're not a Christian at all so his teachings are worthless to you.

Romans 10:9 That if you confess with your mouth, "Jesus is Lord," and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.


i think this is the point that you and i fundamentally diverge from each other. and i pray you're not wrong, much as you pray i'm not wrong?

so, the Teachings of Jesus. that's all we have. all the other Majickal stuff is just that. ya know a mere human can't kilt a god, don't you? a human killing a god. get real. let's continue to be friends and in support of us other, but let's wake up. Majic is majic. we humans are organic beings with a conscious content or potential.
2 stranded DNA only allows so much understanding. 2-4 to 12 DNA stands of DNA allows a further understanding.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..

�And they shall go forth and look
Upon the corpses of the men
Who have transgressed against Me.
For their worm does not die,
And their fire is not quenched.Isaiah 66
I am....and I ask Gods help to continually make me a better one.

I AM NOT perfect though.....even if my wife tells me I am. grin
grin
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by achadwick
Originally Posted by ltppowell
I said I would be MORE Christian...not a perfect Christian.


If you meant that you want to be more Christ-like, then I agree. However, if you meant you want to be more saved, then I don't agree. There are no degrees of salvation. It's either all or nothing.


I reckon it was worded wrong. Angelic would probably be a better term.


I've always pictued you with little wings,playing a harp,so I'd say your doing well!

Don't know about angelic, but you've always struck me as a pretty good guy,for whatever thats worth.
Thanks. I say angelic, 'cause sometimes you have to reconcile the fact that you can be hard and still be a servant of God.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.




Neither do I.



I believe there is something greater out there but I'm not going to let man and his common theme of fear make me believe his version.


If I'm wrong, I've accepted the consequences.
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Do you believe in God's infinite love but not in eternal damnation?
Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by efw
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Same must go for heaven, earth, & God's people then? You didn't mention that?

Don't want to be accused of being a Bible thumper but to be fair.
Luke 21:33
so it was a trick question

Believe vs. who's going to up vs. down

Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by GeoW
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Do you believe in God's infinite love but not in eternal damnation?
in a sense to be seperated from God would be eternal so I believe in both in that sense but hell is for a time and will be destroyed at some point.
I'm saying hell is not eternal because nothing of satan is eternal.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.




Neither do I.



I believe there is something greater out there but I'm not going to let man and his common theme of fear make me believe his version.


If I'm wrong, I've accepted the consequences.


Nothing wrong with that, it's probably close to the truth... whatever the truth is... no man can claim to know for sure... and there's nothing wrong with that either.

Kent
Originally Posted by Tom264
Originally Posted by efw
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Same must go for heaven, earth, & God's people then? You didn't mention that?

Don't want to be accused of being a Bible thumper but to be fair.
Luke 21:33

Might be getting you "Heaven" and "heavens" mixed up...
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Thanks. I say angelic, 'cause sometimes you have to reconcile the fact that you can be hard and still be a servant of God.


Yep. If you study up on angels you will find they are never mentioned as feminine or having wings. There was a reason the first thing the angel told the shepherds was "Fear not".
Originally Posted by GeoW
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Do you believe in God's infinite love but not in eternal damnation?
Being dead forever is eternal damnation, according to Dr Arnold Murray of Shepards Chapel.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.
I'd like to meet you some day Mr. Howell. You seem to be a man of great integrity and that's something I have a great deal of admiration for. May God Bless You and your family.
Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
Originally Posted by Tom264
Originally Posted by efw
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Same must go for heaven, earth, & God's people then? You didn't mention that?

Don't want to be accused of being a Bible thumper but to be fair.
Luke 21:33

Might be getting you "Heaven" and "heavens" mixed up...
no I'm not......
Originally Posted by Tom264
all things created have to have an end
Our souls were created, yet we're to believe they are immortal.
I have, he is. Make the trip, it is worth it.
Originally Posted by Tom264

I'm saying hell is not eternal because nothing of satan is eternal.
Keep in mind the difference between eternal (of which only God is) and immortal, of which are the angels and our souls.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


Not, but wish I were.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by krp
....

Nothing wrong with that, it's probably close to the truth... whatever the truth is... no man can claim to know for sure... and there's nothing wrong with that either.

Kent




To be clear, I have nothing against anyone who believes in a specific higher being and I really hope they find the eternal salvation they're looking for. Whatever it may be.


I've just chosen a different path. Right or wrong.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
Originally Posted by GeoW
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Do you believe in God's infinite love but not in eternal damnation?
in a sense to be seperated from God would be eternal so I believe in both in that sense but hell is for a time and will be destroyed at some point.
I'm saying hell is not eternal because nothing of satan is eternal.
His torment will... �Then He will also say to those on the left hand, �Depart from Me, you cursed, into the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels: Mat 25:41
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.




Neither do I.



I believe there is something greater out there but I'm not going to let man and his common theme of fear make me believe his version.


If I'm wrong, I've accepted the consequences.


We're basically on the same page. IMHO, a man's religous beliefs are the most personal thing in the world. Your actions mean everything... your words nothing...unless your words discourage somebody else from doing the right thing. I am way too small to judge.
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.


Neither do I.

I believe there is something greater out there but I'm not going to let man and his common theme of fear make me believe his version.

If I'm wrong, I've accepted the consequences.


Fair enough. But what if God has tried to communicate to us so we would know him. What would that communication look like?
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....IMHO, a man's religous beliefs are the most personal thing in the world. Your actions mean everything... your words nothing...unless your words discourage somebody else from doing the right thing. I am way too small to judge.




I respect that tremendously.
Originally Posted by Scott F
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Thanks. I say angelic, 'cause sometimes you have to reconcile the fact that you can be hard and still be a servant of God.


Yep. If you study up on angels you will find they are never mentioned as feminine or having wings. There was a reason the first thing the angel told the shepherds was "Fear not".
Scott, some angels were described as having wings, e.g., "Above it stood the seraphims: each one had six wings ..." Isaiah 6:2
Originally Posted by Barkoff


Not, but wish I were.


Easy thing to fix.
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by krp
....

Nothing wrong with that, it's probably close to the truth... whatever the truth is... no man can claim to know for sure... and there's nothing wrong with that either.

Kent




To be clear, I have nothing against anyone who believes in a specific higher being and I really hope they find the eternal salvation they're looking for. Whatever it may be.


I've just chosen a different path. Right or wrong.


Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?
"Too small to judge." Is a fundamentally crappy philosophy.
Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
I think I'm going to go ahead and bow out of this thread.
I am not going to change anyone's mind...certainly not trying to
I don't know why I let myself get sucked into these religious threads.....
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
Originally Posted by GeoW
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


Do you believe in God's infinite love but not in eternal damnation?
in a sense to be seperated from God would be eternal so I believe in both in that sense but hell is for a time and will be destroyed at some point.
I'm saying hell is not eternal because nothing of satan is eternal.


Luke 21:33 States, Heaven and earth shall pass away: but my words shall not pass away.

That in and of itself leads me to believe that Hell, is perhaps forever.
Originally Posted by achadwick
"Too small to judge." Is a fundamentally crappy philosophy.


Okay...you judge other people. It's not my gig.
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news.

When the lecturer said "Where we now stand will be under the sea in a billion years," a man in the audience jumped to his feet �

"How soon?" he asked in a quivery voice.

"A billion years."

"Whew!" the man sat down. "I thought you said in a million years."
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..

�And they shall go forth and look
Upon the corpses of the men
Who have transgressed against Me.
For their worm does not die,
And their fire is not quenched.Isaiah 66


If God's gift to man is eternal life.....then those who fail to accept that gift do die.

Or, so I was taught in Sabbath School.
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Tom264
I think I'm going to go ahead and bow out of this thread.
I am not going to change anyone's mind...certainly not trying to
I don't know why I let myself get sucked into these religious threads.....


Tom, you are a great participant. I have much to learn from people such as yourself. I can tell you are no stranger to the Word. smile
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....

Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?




That's what my heart tells me.


But I'm rolling the dice just as much as anyone else.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Amazing !

The expressed belief that God created mankind;
- wants mankind to be close to Him, for eternity;
- has given the simple means for achieving that closeness, and;
- has given clear instructions for living as He wishes

- then brings about such degrees of contention, disagreement, rancor, anger, and frustration among His creatures;

- and causes us to create denominations, rituals, hoops and hurdles across the simple path to Him.

Such foolishness must be proof of something about mankind. How could even the smartest and most experienced among us begin to think that we could define "man's God" (in whatever variations we could muster)?

How could we begin to think that our human reasoning and decisions about His nature, and whether or not we accept or reject what He offers, would affect Him and His plan in any way - except to disappoint Him when we do not draw near?

Some of us argue so well and mightily. However, no matter how many of whatever we think can reside on the head of any theological pin, His truth seems too simple for many of us to grasp. Even given that simplicity, some of us have to proclaim loudly our rejection and provide our "facts" about why we reject His offering - as if He does not know, and as if he cares, why we reject Him.

Thus, in my humble view, the role of faith as determinant. Keep the Faith.

All I want to know is if Christ made His first appearance 40 years ago would we all be wearing little electric chairs on chains around our necks?


Glad it was 2000+ years ago. A cross looks much better than an electric above the bed. It would make it tough on vampires too, as anything can be made into a cross. Imagine trying to put together a few mini-electric chairs to keep the count away...
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by achadwick
"Too small to judge." Is a fundamentally crappy philosophy.


Okay...you judge other people. It's not my gig.


This is, itself, a judgement. Your argument is self-refuting.
Originally Posted by CCCC
Amazing !

The expressed belief that God created mankind;
- wants mankind to be close to Him, for eternity;
- has given the simple means for achieving that closeness, and;
- has given clear instructions for living as He wishes

- then brings about such degrees of contention, disagreement, rancor, anger, and frustration among His creatures;

- and causes us to create denominations, rituals, hoops and hurdles across the simple path to Him.

Such foolishness must be proof of something about mankind. How could even the smartest and most experienced among us begin to think that we could define "man's God" (in whatever variations we could muster)?

How could we begin to think that our human reasoning and decisions about His nature, and whether or not we accept or reject what He offers, would affect Him and His plan in any way - except to disappoint Him when we do not draw near?

Some of us argue so well and mightily. However, no matter how many of whatever we think can reside on the head of any theological pin, His truth seems too simple for many of us to grasp. Even given that simplicity, some of us have to proclaim loudly our rejection and provide our "facts" about why we reject His offering - as if He does not know, and as if he cares, why we reject Him.

Thus, in my humble view, the role of faith as determinant. Keep the Faith.



Well said my friend, very well said.
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....

Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?




That's what my heart tells me.


But I'm rolling the dice just as much as anyone else.


If God has attempted to communicate to us then there is no roll of the dice. It is possible to know the truth.
Faith is important. I'm confident that more than a few have made it to the good place without giving a damn about what other people tell them to do.
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....

Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?




That's what my heart tells me.


But I'm rolling the dice just as much as anyone else.
probably more than those who believe through faith and submit to the Word, actually. Faith in the Word (Jesus) and the Truth (Jesus) ensures hope is not in vain. Jesus is the Word and the Truth will set you free (from death).

You can listen to your heart (flesh) or He who made it.
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by achadwick
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....

Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?




That's what my heart tells me.


But I'm rolling the dice just as much as anyone else.


If God has attempted to communicate to us then there is no roll of the dice. It is possible to know the truth.


If one knows and understands right from wrong, good from bad then regardless of the choices he chooses to make, God had indeed attempted to and accomplished communication.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Idaho_Shooter
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..

�And they shall go forth and look
Upon the corpses of the men
Who have transgressed against Me.
For their worm does not die,
And their fire is not quenched.Isaiah 66


If God's gift to man is eternal life.....then those who fail to accept that gift do die.

Or, so I was taught in Sabbath School.
We will all die physically but not spiritually. The bible teachs that we will all be judged and our souls live forever either in Heaven (with God) or hell (seperation from God).

Mat 25:31 �When the Son of Man comes in His glory, and all the holy angels with Him, then He will sit on the throne of His glory. 32 All the nations will be gathered before Him, and He will separate them one from another, as a shepherd divides his sheep from the goats. 33 And He will set the sheep on His right hand, but the goats on the left. 34 Then the King will say to those on His right hand, �Come, you blessed of My Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world:

41 �Then He will also say to those on the left hand, �Depart from Me, you cursed, into the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels:
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
.....

Doesn't sound like a different path to me. It just sounds like you trust "Him" or "It" more than people. Shiit, ain't that the way it's supposed to be?




That's what my heart tells me.


But I'm rolling the dice just as much as anyone else.


No one has to accept another man's version of God... or even the manmade name God... understanding that what comes after this life is undefinable in language kinda puts it in perspective.

Kent
Actions speak louder than words. I'm afraid that many people don't realize that we ain't the only one's watching.
Posted By: LBP Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
The Thief on the Cross was not saved by works, neither are we...
Originally Posted by Tom264
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..

Jude 1:7 In a similar way, Sodom and Gomorrah and the surrounding towns gave themselves up to sexual immorality and perversion. They serve as an example of those who suffer the punishment of eternal fire.

What part of 'eternal' is so hard to understand?
God created angels and they are eternal.
God created man and we are eternal, in heaven or hell.
Sure we are.
Originally Posted by Tom264
I think I'm going to go ahead and bow out of this thread.
I am not going to change anyone's mind...certainly not trying to
I don't know why I let myself get sucked into these religious threads.....


I don't think anyone can be talked into faith. Those without faith will need more than another point of view.
Shut up, heathen.
They need to pray for the blessing of faith.
Originally Posted by rrroae
I have nothing against anyone who believes in a specific higher being and I really hope they find the eternal salvation they're looking for. Whatever it may be.

I've just chosen a different path. Right or wrong.

Excellent point, well worthy of � and entitled to � others' respect!

God won't like your decision � it's not one of His druthers � but He'll respect it.

He'd prefer to have you with Him, but He gave you free will to opt for the other course, so He'll honor your choice. He wants you to be with Him only if you want to be with Him. He gives us complete freedom to choose, as long as we're willing to take the consequences. He's not going to shanghai you. He could, but He won't. He runs no divine draft board.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by CCCC
Amazing !

The expressed belief that God created mankind;
- wants mankind to be close to Him, for eternity;
- has given the simple means for achieving that closeness, and;
- has given clear instructions for living as He wishes

- then brings about such degrees of contention, disagreement, rancor, anger, and frustration among His creatures;

- and causes us to create denominations, rituals, hoops and hurdles across the simple path to Him.

Such foolishness must be proof of something about mankind. How could even the smartest and most experienced among us begin to think that we could define "man's God" (in whatever variations we could muster)?

How could we begin to think that our human reasoning and decisions about His nature, and whether or not we accept or reject what He offers, would affect Him and His plan in any way - except to disappoint Him when we do not draw near?

Some of us argue so well and mightily. However, no matter how many of whatever we think can reside on the head of any theological pin, His truth seems too simple for many of us to grasp. Even given that simplicity, some of us have to proclaim loudly our rejection and provide our "facts" about why we reject His offering - as if He does not know, and as if he cares, why we reject Him.

Thus, in my humble view, the role of faith as determinant. Keep the Faith.

Hebrews 11:6
But without faith it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is, and that He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him.
I'll throw the wrench... the most Christian people I know wouldn't get caught talking about religion with the hard core holy rollers. I wouldn't either, 'cept I told God that I would do my part, and I know helping those that struggle with faith is the right thing to do.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Barkoff
Originally Posted by Tom264
I think I'm going to go ahead and bow out of this thread.
I am not going to change anyone's mind...certainly not trying to
I don't know why I let myself get sucked into these religious threads.....


I don't think anyone can be talked into faith. Those without faith will need more than another point of view.
1 Cor 12:3 No one can say that Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit.
I am a Christian.
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.

Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.

No He just brought the truth. John 14:6
Jesus said to him, �I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.
Yea, we are sheep and lean not on our own understanding, the way Zero voters did.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
.......

God won't like your decision � it's not one of His druthers � but He'll respect it.

He'd prefer to have you with Him, but He gave you free will to opt for the other course, so He'll honor your choice. He wants you to be with Him only if you want to be with Him. He gives us complete freedom to choose, as long as we're willing to take the consequences. He's not going to shanghai you. He could, but He won't. He runs no divine draft board.




But Ken, in my way I am with him. Just because I chose not to define who God is from what others tell me doesn't mean I don't believe in him(undefined) or think about him and sometimes ask him for guidance.



I truly believe in something greater than myself and as odd as my relationship with him might seem to some of you, that's the way I've chosen.
God defined who He is, not us.
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.

No He just brought the truth. John 14:6
Jesus said to him, �I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.


No one goes to God expect through Christ, but Christ is God, so you can't get to God without going through God?

Spewing scripture is funny stuff.
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by ltppowell
Originally Posted by rrroae
As are your decisions or anyone else's.


I don't think we're far off in these things, other than I find it hard to believe it's an accident.




Neither do I.


I believe there is something greater out there but I'm not going to let man and his common theme of fear make me believe his version.


If I'm wrong, I've accepted the consequences.



frown My pond was also slow to fill. My prayer is that someday soon yours will also fill. GW
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
.......

God won't like your decision � it's not one of His druthers � but He'll respect it.

He'd prefer to have you with Him, but He gave you free will to opt for the other course, so He'll honor your choice. He wants you to be with Him only if you want to be with Him. He gives us complete freedom to choose, as long as we're willing to take the consequences. He's not going to shanghai you. He could, but He won't. He runs no divine draft board.




But Ken, in my way I am with him. Just because I chose not to define who God is from what others tell me doesn't mean I don't believe in him(undefined) or think about him and sometimes ask him for guidance.



I truly believe in something greater than myself and as odd as my relationship with him might seem to some of you, that's the way I've chosen.

rrroae, quite listening to others then and ask God to reveal Himself to you.
Hebrews 11:6 He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by eyeball
God defined who He is, not us.





And man told us the definition.



If God talks to me, I'll believe what he has to say. Not so much when man does it.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.

No He just brought the truth. John 14:6
Jesus said to him, �I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.


No one goes to God expect through Christ, but Christ is God, so you can't get to God without going through God?

Spewing scripture is funny stuff.
Father, Son, Holy Spirit... The TRINITY!
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.



Speak of the Devil.
Posted By: rrroae Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Good night fellas.


Whatever you believe, I hope it brings you happiness, comfort and fulfillment.
Originally Posted by LBP
The Thief on the Cross was not saved by works, neither are we...
Good point. He was saved merely by a statement of faith in Jesus being who he claimed to be.
Bigbuck215

Quote
Do you obey Matthew 6:6 ??


Your question reminds me of when I spent some time with a couple guys who were preparing a seminar. At the end of the second day I mentioned, "I want the men in every place to pray lifting holy hands without wrath and doubting."

They both began to attack. I didn't react in any kind of negative way and tried to answer their questions. The next day we got back together and one of the guys told me, "Yesterday I didn't ask you the correct question."
"What is the correct question?" I asked.
"The correct question is, Do I ever lift my hands when I pray?" he informed with penitence.

Are you asking because you are hoping to inspire me to love and good deeds?
Likewise...don't forget to thank whoever for whatever. smile
Frankly, does anybody think some would get pissed of at a person for being a Christian, or for having an attitude?
It's usually hypocrisy.
Quote
We will all die physically but not spiritually. The bible teachs that we will all be judged and our souls live forever either in Heaven (with God) or hell (seperation from God).


And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.

The bible doesn't "teach" you anything, it merely makes you believe what somebody else wants you to believe. If you want to go that route, fine. By all means, have at it. But PLEASE don't tell me that I'm damned in eternity, or that I somehow haven't been sufficiently enlightened, or that you'll pray for me (expend those energies on somebody who believes that it will somehow do them some good, as I promise you that you are wasting your breath directing any of it in my direction).

Prove to me that any of it has happened, currently happens, or will happen. Until then, I'm in the isn't camp, and perfectly content.

And just to be clear, you never hear me starting a topic by telling them that they are doomed, or that they are less worthy because they don't choose to be a sheep, or that they are stupid for believing, or anything else. But yes, I'm getting quite sick of it always happening in the opposite direction. Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Barkoff
Originally Posted by Tom264
I think I'm going to go ahead and bow out of this thread.
I am not going to change anyone's mind...certainly not trying to
I don't know why I let myself get sucked into these religious threads.....


I don't think anyone can be talked into faith. Those without faith will need more than another point of view.
1 Cor 12:3 No one can say that Jesus is Lord except by the Holy Spirit.
This is a matter of a failure of the English language to convey the meaning of the original language. The word used for "say" means more like "sincerely say." Con artists, for example, can easily say that Jesus is Lord, but not do so by the Holy Spirit. Jesus himself said that many will even cast out devils by his name, but they are not of his fold and will be turned away.
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Looks like Christ took away original thought with original sin.

No He just brought the truth. John 14:6
Jesus said to him, �I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.


No one goes to God expect through Christ, but Christ is God, so you can't get to God without going through God?

Spewing scripture is funny stuff.
He said, "No one comes to the Father except through me."
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by ColdBore
Quote
We will all die physically but not spiritually. The bible teachs that we will all be judged and our souls live forever either in Heaven (with God) or hell (seperation from God).


And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.

The bible doesn't "teach" you anything, it merely makes you believe what somebody else wants you to believe. If you want to go that route, fine. By all means, have at it. But PLEASE don't tell me that I'm damned in eternity, or that I somehow haven't been sufficiently enlightened, or that you'll pray for me (expend those energies on somebody who believes that it will somehow do them some good, as I promise you that you are wasting your breath directing any of it in my direction).

Prove to me that any of it has happened, currently happens, or will happen. Until then, I'm in the isn't camp, and perfectly content.

And just to be clear, you never hear me starting a topic by telling them that they are doomed, or that they are less worthy because they don't choose to be a sheep, or that they are stupid for believing, or anything else. But yes, I'm getting quite sick of it always happening in the opposite direction. Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.
1 Cor 1:18 For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God.
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
.......

God won't like your decision � it's not one of His druthers � but He'll respect it.

He'd prefer to have you with Him, but He gave you free will to opt for the other course, so He'll honor your choice. He wants you to be with Him only if you want to be with Him. He gives us complete freedom to choose, as long as we're willing to take the consequences. He's not going to shanghai you. He could, but He won't. He runs no divine draft board.




But Ken, in my way I am with him. Just because I chose not to define who God is from what others tell me doesn't mean I don't believe in him(undefined) or think about him and sometimes ask him for guidance.



I truly believe in something greater than myself and as odd as my relationship with him might seem to some of you, that's the way I've chosen.


Perhaps Great Architect of the Universe?
For those who struggle with the "obedience" requirement of salvation, consider these three passages:


1 John 5:2-3

2 By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God, and keep his commandments.
3 For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments and his commandments are not grievous.


1 Cor 16:22

If any man love not the Lord Jesus Christ, let him be Anath'ema, Maranath'a.

Heb 5:8-9
8 though he were a Son, yet learned he obedience by the things which he suffered;
9 and being made perfect, he became the author of eternal salvation unto all them that obey him;
Posted By: dano76 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Howdy all, I normally don't post because I type slow. Anywho, this is a fascinating thread and I enjoy seeing everyone's joy at accepting The Lords Grace. I'm a Christian and it took me years to wrap my mind around the concept that I don't get to God by any action I do, but by accepting His offer of Grace and having a loving relationship with Him. Turning away from sin and the pleasures of the world(drunkeness, porn, drugs) seem like a big deal but when you're free from them you feel so much better. Some are saying they believe in God but want to just be good and trust in themselves, just believing won't do it, the devil and demons believe in God but they won't be in heaven. Our works are filthy rags compared to the perfection of God( the original Greek translation for those rags are menstrual rags by the way) it is the sacrifice and grace that cover our sins and allow us to be save
Originally Posted by Ringman
� I mentioned, "I want the men in every place to pray lifting holy hands without wrath and doubting." �

Four preachers stood talking about this 'n' that and eventually got onto the matter of the best position to pray in.

"There's a reason," the first said, "that we call our knee caps our 'prayer bones.' Kneeling is the way to pray!"

"The Bible speaks often," the second said, "of falling on one's face before the Lord. That's absolute humility! So I can't think of a more appropriate way to pray."

"He's our Father," said the third, "and we're His children. I'm sure that He'd like nothing better than for us to lift our faces and hands to Him, His children looking up to Him as we pray."

The fourth said nothing until one of the others prodded him to offer his opinion.

"Well, I never given it much thought," he said, "but lookin' back, I think I done some o' my best prayin' when I was hangin' upside-down from a windmill."
Originally Posted by rrroae
Originally Posted by eyeball
God defined who He is, not us.





And man told us the definition.



If God talks to me, I'll believe what he has to say. Not so much when man does it.
He gave us a book, His message to you and me, so we would know the truth, and not have to listen to others or lean on our own understanding- it's called the Bible. His message is the same to all of us. What have you put forth for Him to give you your own message? He gave His son and offers you everlasting life for you to listen to His.
Originally Posted by PAMac
If i say yes..... Will i be persecuted????????


If I say no, will I be condemmed?
Originally Posted by ColdBore
Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.


As this is open forum, and reading this is your choice, why does it bother you so much?
Quote
This is not directed at anyone in particular but those of you that think hell is eternal are gravely mistaken, all things created have to have an end and hell is created therefore will have an end.......don't know when or how long but when that happens Satan and his followers will cease to exist.

Sorry for the bad news..


"And I saw the beast (the Antichrist) and the kings of the earth and their armies, assembled to make war against Him (Jesus) Who sat upon the horse, and against His army. And the beast was seized and with him the false prophet who performed signs in his presence, by which he deceived those who had received the mark of the beast and those who worshiped his image; and these two were thrown alive into the lake of fire which burns with brimstone."Revelation 19:19-20
"And the devil who deceived them was thrown into the lake of fire and brimstone, where the beast and the false prophet are also; and they well be tormented day and night forever and ever. And the sea gave up the dead which were in it, and death and Hades gave up the dead which were in them; and they were judged, everyone according to their deeds. And death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. This is the second death, the lake of fire. And if anyone's name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire." Revelation 20:10,13-15

"'Then He will also say to those on His left, "Depart from Me, accused one, into the eternal fire which has been prepared for the devil and his angels;" and these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.'" Matthew 25:41, 46

Which "eternal" does not mean eternal?

Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by OrangeOkie
For those who struggle with the "obedience" requirement of salvation, consider these three passages:


1 John 5:2-3

2 By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God, and keep his commandments.
3 For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments and his commandments are not grievous.


1 Cor 16:22

If any man love not the Lord Jesus Christ, let him be Anath'ema, Maranath'a.

Heb 5:8-9
8 though he were a Son, yet learned he obedience by the things which he suffered;
9 and being made perfect, he became the author of eternal salvation unto all them that obey him;
Lets start with the first one but read it all in context.

New King James Version (NKJV)

5 Whoever believes that Jesus is the Christ is born of God, and everyone who loves Him who begot also loves him who is begotten of Him. 2 By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God and keep His commandments. 3 For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments. And His commandments are not burdensome. 4 For whatever is born of God overcomes the world. And this is the victory that has overcome the world�our faith. 5 Who is he who overcomes the world, but he who believes that Jesus is the Son of God?
Believing (faith) is what saves. Works are the proof that you are saved.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by LBP
The Thief on the Cross was not saved by works, neither are we...
Good point. He was saved merely by a statement of faith in Jesus being who he claimed to be.


I would like to interject that "works" are not acts of obedience to the commands of Jesus. For example, when Peter commanded the household of Cornelius to be baptized (Acts 10:48) that was a clear "condition" of salvation, just like it was on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:38.)

It is unremitted sin that separates us from God and eternal life. When we walk in the light, as He is in the light, we have fellowship one with another and the blood of Jesus Christ His son cleanseth us from all sin. (1 John 1:7)

Baptism (of John the Baptist or Christ) has always been "for the remission of sins." (Mark 1:4 John baptized in the wilderness and preached the baptism of repentance for the remission of sins.)

So was the thief on the cross a baptized believer? (Mt 3:4-6 And the same John had his raiment of camel�s hair, and a leather girdle about his loins; and his meat was locusts and wild honey.
5 Then there went out to him Jerusalem and all Judea and all the region round about the Jordan.
6 And they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins.)

Based on this passage, one could objectively conclude there is a better chance that the thief was a baptized believer than not, and was counted among the vast majority of Jews who were baptized of John, for the remission of sins, than the few (Pharisees and lawyers) who rejected the counsel of God against themselves, not being baptized of John. (Luke 7:30.)
Was the thief possibly baptized by the fire?
Quote
Good point. He was saved merely by a statement of faith in Jesus being who he claimed to be.


"If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart the God raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved; for with the heart man believes, resulting in righteousness, and with the mouth he confesses, resulting in salvation." Romans 10:9-10

Hopefully you saw belief results in righteousness. But doing, that is confessing, results in salvation. The thief on the cross preached to the other thief; consistent with "work out your salvation". It is all God's Word.
OrangeOkie,

You made a great post!
Originally Posted by eyeball
Was the thief possibly baptized by the fire?


The thief died before the "baptism with fire," which was the "axe" that was laid at the root of Pharasitical Judaism . . . when the Mosaic economy was finally and completely destroyed in AD 70 with the destruction of the temple at Jerusalem.
Posted By: LBP Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Good point. He was saved merely by a statement of faith in Jesus being who he claimed to be.


"If you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart the God raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved; for with the heart man believes, resulting in righteousness, and with the mouth he confesses, resulting in salvation." Romans 10:9-10

Hopefully you saw belief results in righteousness. But doing, that is confessing, results in salvation. The thief on the cross preached to the other thief; consistent with "work out your salvation". It is all God's Word.


+1
Posted By: 700LH Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
[Linked Image]
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by OrangeOkie
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by LBP
The Thief on the Cross was not saved by works, neither are we...
Good point. He was saved merely by a statement of faith in Jesus being who he claimed to be.


I would like to interject that "works" are not acts of obedience to the commands of Jesus. For example, when Peter commanded the household of Cornelius to be baptized (Acts 10:48) that was a clear "condition" of salvation, just like it was on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:38.)

It is unremitted sin that separates us from God and eternal life. When we walk in the light, as He is in the light, we have fellowship one with another and the blood of Jesus Christ His son cleanseth us from all sin. (1 John 1:7)

Baptism (of John the Baptist or Christ) has always been "for the remission of sins." (Mark 1:4 John baptized in the wilderness and preached the baptism of repentance for the remission of sins.)

So was the thief on the cross a baptized believer? (Mt 3:4-6 And the same John had his raiment of camel�s hair, and a leather girdle about his loins; and his meat was locusts and wild honey.
5 Then there went out to him Jerusalem and all Judea and all the region round about the Jordan.
6 And they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins.)

Based on this passage, one could objectively conclude there is a better chance that the thief was a baptized believer than not, and was counted among the vast majority of Jews who were baptized of John, for the remission of sins, than the few (Pharisees and lawyers) who rejected the counsel of God against themselves, not being baptized of John. (Luke 7:30.)


Thats some fancy figuring to get that thief baptized.
Please read what it says not what you have been taught it says!

Eph 2:4 But God, who is rich in mercy, because of His great love with which He loved us, 5 even when we were dead in trespasses, made us alive together with Christ by grace you have been saved, 6 and raised us up together, and made us sit together in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus, 7 that in the ages to come He might show the exceeding riches of His grace in His kindness toward us in Christ Jesus. 8 For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God, 9 not of works, lest anyone should boast. 10 For we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand that we should walk in them.
BY GRACE THROUGH FAITH, works are an out growth of our love for Christ.
Originally Posted by ColdBore

And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.


If I understand you correctly, you are saying that the only things that exist are those that can be seen, touched and felt. By that standard, then logic and mathematics don't exist. Neither do the whole range of human emotions. Also, in your universe I myself don't exist because you can't see or verify me. Let me suggest that your view is insufficient to explain the readily observable facts. There are many things that exist but that can no be seen, touched, or felt.

Originally Posted by ColdBore

The bible doesn't "teach" you anything, it merely makes you believe what somebody else wants you to believe. If you want to go that route, fine. By all means, have at it. But PLEASE don't tell me that I'm damned in eternity, or that I somehow haven't been sufficiently enlightened, or that you'll pray for me (expend those energies on somebody who believes that it will somehow do them some good, as I promise you that you are wasting your breath directing any of it in my direction).



Christians are not telling you that you are damned. God is.

Originally Posted by ColdBore


Prove to me that any of it has happened, currently happens, or will happen. Until then, I'm in the isn't camp, and perfectly content.



Fair enough. This is your choice, one that results from your own faith. But what are you going to tell God when you stand before him on the judgement day? That he doesn't exist? That will be a tough sell. grin

Originally Posted by ColdBore


And just to be clear, you never hear me starting a topic by telling them that they are doomed, or that they are less worthy because they don't choose to be a sheep, or that they are stupid for believing, or anything else. But yes, I'm getting quite sick of it always happening in the opposite direction. Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.


Christians are under orders to preach the gospel and to make disciples. Why would you expect us to willfully disobey our Lord and Savior?
"Learn first what you must believe, then go to the Bible to find it there." (Hugo of St Victor, 12th Century)

180� WRONG!
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Example! Not sure what you mean.
ColdB., so you know the heart and blood are real because you can see them. I guess that which made the heart and that which makes it beat is not real, since you can't see that force.
Originally Posted by Dons99


Thats some fancy figuring to get that thief baptized.
Please read what it says not what you have been taught it says!


Quote: 5 Then there went out to him Jerusalem and all Judea and all the region round about the Jordan.
6 And they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins.

I can objectively conclude there is a better chance the thief was baptized than not. The only reason i bring this point to light is because I often hear people say (definitively) the thief was not baptized of John for the remission of his sins. There is no objective evidence he was NOT baptized. The statement above indicates he probably was if he was from Jerusalem, Judea, or the region round about the Jordan River.

Do you have objective (Scriptural) evidence he was not baptized my friend?

BTW . . . "obedience" (ie. praying, being baptized, believing in Jesus, etc.) to God's commands are not "works."
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by OrangeOkie
Originally Posted by Dons99


Thats some fancy figuring to get that thief baptized.
Please read what it says not what you have been taught it says!


Quote: 5 Then there went out to him Jerusalem and all Judea and all the region round about the Jordan.
6 And they were baptized by him in the Jordan, confessing their sins.

I can objectively conclude there is a better chance the thief was baptized than not. The only reason i bring this point to light is because I often hear people say (definitively) the thief was not baptized of John for the remission of his sins. There is no objective evidence he was NOT baptized. The statement above indicates he probably was if he was from Jerusalem, Judea, or the region round about the Jordan River.

Do you have objective (Scriptural) evidence he was not

BTW . . . "obedience" (ie. praying, being baptized, believing in Jesus, etc.) to God's commands are not "works."


No evidence for or against.

On works maybe we have a communication problem.
Originally Posted by Dons99
Example! Not sure what you mean.

All right � there are many. Here's an easy one �

For years, "Christianity" has taught us that Jesus's words in John 15:13 ("Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends") mean that Jesus sacrificed Himself for the salvation of all mankind. For everyone.

But if I'd go to the Bible first, and read John 15:14 as well as John 15:13, I'd see quite emphatically otherwise ("Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends. Ye are my friends, if ye do whatsoever I command you.") Two verses, comprised in one utterance, the second invariably omitted from the officially decreed " � what you must believe � ."

The second verse isn't nearly as universal and as glory-promising as the first. It's much narrower, much stricter, so it isn't what the soul-hunters like to include in their bait. It's worlds easier to regard Jesus as a grantor of nice favors than it is to contemplate Him as a Lord Who expects to be obeyed.

So, in my opinion and in my approach to responsible exegesis, the much more appropriate procedure, 180� from Hugo's edict, is to (a) go to the Bible (b) to learn what to believe.
So very well put!

I am
Posted By: tbear Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Are all the American Indians, Eskimos, & various aboriginals who never knew Jesus excluded? Are the followers of Mohammad & Buddha excluded who lived in accordance with their religion? I once attended a large church in Virginia where I live as a guest that has world wide missions to spread the word of Christ. I'm sure there are other churches of the same belief in the South. The sermon that day was that their particular church was the only path to Heaven. All other Christian religions were condemed to eternal damnation as well as Muslims,etc.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Ken, amen to that
I am Knighted and Sworn to uphold the Cross.

Anyone else here with me?
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by AggieDog
Im a christian and proud of it.
Pride cometh before the fall. grin


Actually "Pride [goeth] before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall."
Originally Posted by Steelhead
All I want to know is if Christ made His first appearance 40 years ago would we all be wearing little electric chairs on chains around our necks?


Glad it was 2000+ years ago. A cross looks much better than an electric above the bed. It would make it tough on vampires too, as anything can be made into a cross. Imagine trying to put together a few mini-electric chairs to keep the count away...


laugh

I find you to be condescending and irreverent a lot of the time. That's not always a bad thing though. Jesus, Himself, was irreverent and condescending a lot of the time as well. That's why the religious leaders of the day hated him to their core.

This post cracked me up as I tried to envision it! I think it would have been far neater if a firing squad had been used. Then I could say that carrying a gun was a part of my religious freedom grin

Originally Posted by Ken Howell
How many ways into the kingdom of God are there?


There are two ways.
Originally Posted by tbear
Are all the American Indians, Eskimos, & various aboriginals who never knew Jesus excluded? Are the followers of Mohammad & Buddha excluded who lived in accordance with their religion? I once attended a large church in Virginia where I live as a guest that has world wide missions to spread the word of Christ. I'm sure there are other churches of the same belief in the South. The sermon that day was that their particular church was the only path to Heaven. All other Christian religions were condemed to eternal damnation as well as Muslims,etc.
Jesus said that all who knock at the door will have it opened to them. Anyone of any religion or society who truly seeks God will find him. We aren't told how God does it, just that he does.
"Without the virgin birth, crucifixion, and resurrection, the teachings of Jesus are meaningless. If you don't believe in the resurrection, you're not a Christian at all so his teachings are worthless to you." Rockchuck.

The "teachings" of Jesus contain many "pearls of wisdom" that can help anybody live a more contented life right here on earth.

The "truth" is just as true, no matter WHO speaks it.

Christianity introduces a man to a supernatural power that will enable him to fundamentally change himself.

Not "change his ways", but "change himself".

Apart from that Power, he is stuck with being what he is.

Which brings to mind a question; Were you a "know it all" BEFORE you became a Christian? grin
Originally Posted by eyeball
Was the thief possibly baptized by the fire?
The term "baptism by fire" historically refers to martyrdom. He was not a martyr, since we are to assume that his execution was just, i.e., he was, after all, a criminal who had committed a capital offense as defined by the state. He wasn't being executed for his proclamation of faith.
Originally Posted by Dons99

Thats some fancy figuring to get that thief baptized.
Even according to Catholicism, the thief on the cross didn't require baptism, as no one required baptism till after the resurrection of Jesus. Righteous folks who died before that were gathered in a place termed "paradise." Jesus saw the thief in paradise that very day when he released him, and all others there, so that they could ascend to heaven.
Originally Posted by Dons99
Example! Not sure what you mean.
He means he doesn't take his instruction from churchmen, but only from the word directly.
Originally Posted by tbear
Are all the American Indians, Eskimos, & various aboriginals who never knew Jesus excluded? Are the followers of Mohammad & Buddha excluded who lived in accordance with their religion?
God is fully capable of seeing to it that his own are either born in a region where the truth is preached, or that a preacher be sent to where one wasn't before, or that a person from said region transport himself to one where the truth is in fact preached. Therefore your argument doesn't hold water since it requires a God who's incapable of providing the means of salvation to certain populations due to mere geography.

Remember also that narrow is the road that leads to life, and few there are who go that way, so the notion of vast numbers not having access to the Gospel doesn't seem so strange, as God knows ahead of time who are his own and who are not. The vast majority are not, and the message is entirely wasted on them to start with.
I believe on Christ, I am saved by his blood, I worship him. I try to do Gods work and try to walk with him. I am not successful at that, then again nobody really is.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
The only baptism that is real is the baptism(immersion) of the Holy Spirit, which can't be defined in that worldly term or a contained in a worldly gesture.

Folks throughout history have felt that 'something', without a religion to define it and excepted without fanfare.

They are the lucky ones not having to debate bullchit...

�Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these"

Kent
Quote
Are all the American Indians, Eskimos, & various aboriginals who never knew Jesus excluded? Are the followers of Mohammad & Buddha excluded who lived in accordance with their religion? I once attended a large church in Virginia where I live as a guest that has world wide missions to spread the word of Christ. I'm sure there are other churches of the same belief in the South. The sermon that day was that their particular church was the only path to Heaven. All other Christian religions were condemed to eternal damnation as well as Muslims,etc


We see in God's Word there is no other name than Jesus for salvation. Jesus clearly states He is the only Way to the Father. There are lots of stories of Jesus appearing to modern people informing them that He is the way.
Quote
The only baptism that is real is the baptism(immersion) of the Holy Spirit, which can't be defined in that worldly term or a contained in a worldly gesture.

Folks throughout history have felt that 'something', without a religion to define it and excepted without fanfare.

They are the lucky ones not having to debate bullchit...

�Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these"

Kent


You will see in Acts 10 after the Holy Spirit fell on a group of Gentiles that Apostle Peter ordered them to be baptized in water. This was in response an angel telling someone Apostle Peter would tell them ALL the Words of eternal life.
Originally Posted by ColdBore
Quote
We will all die physically but not spiritually. The bible teachs that we will all be judged and our souls live forever either in Heaven (with God) or hell (seperation from God).


And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.

The bible doesn't "teach" you anything, it merely makes you believe what somebody else wants you to believe. If you want to go that route, fine. By all means, have at it. But PLEASE don't tell me that I'm damned in eternity, or that I somehow haven't been sufficiently enlightened, or that you'll pray for me (expend those energies on somebody who believes that it will somehow do them some good, as I promise you that you are wasting your breath directing any of it in my direction).

Prove to me that any of it has happened, currently happens, or will happen. Until then, I'm in the isn't camp, and perfectly content.

And just to be clear, you never hear me starting a topic by telling them that they are doomed, or that they are less worthy because they don't choose to be a sheep, or that they are stupid for believing, or anything else. But yes, I'm getting quite sick of it always happening in the opposite direction. Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.


I'm a christian, but I agree with your last paragraph.

We had one of these threads one time that resulted in a half-dozen conversions and two volunteers for missions in the Congo. I'm sure "we" did, but I missed it.

The main problem with lots [not all, by any means] of folks trying to get somebody else started on "the road to salvation" is that they try to start 'em from a place where they ain't.

It seems like they are afraid a man may find the "wrong" God, all the while claiming that there is only one God.

If a man has NEVER looked up at the night sky and wondered;"Who then made all this?", he is certainly in a small minority of the human race.

If he can get his head around the idea of a "creation without a Creator" and stick to that conviction with never a doubt of any size, then I reckon he was condemned to eternal ignorance from birth.

The idea of an ENTITY that was capable of "making all that was made", and yet "outsourced" the function of communicating with ITS creatures to other creatures just like them is ridiculous as far as I'm concerned.

Now, if that ENTITY was well and truly dead, then IT would require ITS creatures to spread ITS message, and they would probably write a bunch of stuff down in a book and preach from it.

But... being alive and eternal, Jesus initiated the conversation with each human when He put that question of "creation"in his mind.

THAT is where we ALL must start from in my opinion.

THEN, at some point in our journey, that book starts to make sense.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
The only baptism that is real is the baptism(immersion) of the Holy Spirit, which can't be defined in that worldly term or a contained in a worldly gesture.

Folks throughout history have felt that 'something', without a religion to define it and excepted without fanfare.

They are the lucky ones not having to debate bullchit...

�Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these"

Kent


You will see in Acts 10 after the Holy Spirit fell on a group of Gentiles that Apostle Peter ordered them to be baptized in water. This was in response an angel telling someone Apostle Peter would tell them ALL the Words of eternal life.


I don't define my faith through Paul.

Kent
Posted By: JPro Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
I have not read this entire thread, but I honestly do believe and I call myself a Christian. I also have noticed that among those who don't believe, those that I consider "good folks" still live by mainly Christian values and principles. There are likely quite a few people on this forum who are not Christians, but we wouldn't know it if we went solely by their actions. A large problem with today's society is the decline of those Christian-based values among the general population, both believers and non-believers.
Originally Posted by JPro
A large problem with today's society is the decline of those Christian-based values among the general population, both believers and non-believers.
Ain't that the truth. And it was intentionally engineered.
"I don't define my faith through Paul.

Kent"

Well put.
Originally Posted by achadwick
If I understand you correctly, you are saying that the only things that exist are those that can be seen, touched and felt. By that standard, then logic and mathematics don't exist. Neither do the whole range of human emotions. Also, in your universe I myself don't exist because you can't see or verify me. Let me suggest that your view is insufficient to explain the readily observable facts. There are many things that exist but that can no be seen, touched, or felt.


Wrong.

I can set two apples on a table. I see two. Then I can set two more on the table, and now I see four. And I can reach out and touch them. That is addition.

And I can't verify you?? Really?? That's the kind of argument that you want to use to show the superiority of being an all-knowing christian? I may not be able to see or touch you from here, but you are merely a few hours plane ride away. That has to be one of the weakest counters I've run across. Embarrassing actually.

Emotions? I can see smiles, I can touch tears.

Let ME suggest that YOU are a gullible fool for falling for all that you do, simply on somebody's word.

Quote
Christians are not telling you that you are damned. God is.


Really? Ask him to type it on here himself. HIM, not one of you, "on his behalf", or "doing his work". Have him send it to me via registered mail, with a verified return address, and postmarked heaven. Till then, "he" isn't telling me anything. But lots of you are.

Quote
Fair enough. This is your choice, one that results from your own faith. But what are you going to tell God when you stand before him on the judgement day? That he doesn't exist? That will be a tough sell. grin


I'm not going to tell him a thing. Cause I'll be DEAD and gone. My "spirit" isn't going to any gate, and nobody will be "there" to ask me any questions. Tough sell? A salesman that is dead trying to sell something to somebody who doesn't exist? Yeah, you win that round, it might be hard to get that one done.

Quote
Christians are under orders to preach the gospel and to make disciples. Why would you expect us to willfully disobey our Lord and Savior?


My orders come in written form. Laws are on the books. Military regulations are on the books. When somebody with the authority to do so tells me that I have to do one of those things, I can go find the reference, and also see the penalty. I don't like paying fines or sitting in jail, so I make my decisions based on that. Real rules, with real consequences, that I can feel. Yours? Not so much. And before anybody even bothers, no, I am not one bit concerned about "but what if".

God would be so disappointed in you if he knew that you were the best he had to put forth his arguments.
Is the Universe - which you can see - an effect without a cause?
I am. and there's only ONE way. Jesus said he was THE way. Not a way.
Now you've done it ColdBore, you've outed yourself and made the Campfire prayer list.... grin



Originally Posted by curdog4570
Is the Universe - which you can see - an effect without a cause?


The Universe, aka God's creation, is much greater than any of our ancestors every imagined, the same is likely true of God. wink

At the very least, God's gift is life, is there more?

Originally Posted by dano76
Howdy all, I normally don't post because I type slow. Anywho, this is a fascinating thread and I enjoy seeing everyone's joy at accepting The Lords Grace. I'm a Christian and it took me years to wrap my mind around the concept that I don't get to God by any action I do, but by accepting His offer of Grace and having a loving relationship with Him. Turning away from sin and the pleasures of the world(drunkeness, porn, drugs) seem like a big deal but when you're free from them you feel so much better. Some are saying they believe in God but want to just be good and trust in themselves, just believing won't do it, the devil and demons believe in God but they won't be in heaven. Our works are filthy rags compared to the perfection of God( the original Greek translation for those rags are menstrual rags by the way) it is the sacrifice and grace that cover our sins and allow us to be save


You may not post much but when you do it is worth reading.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by ColdBore
And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.
Much of that seems true, but please show where/how medical science demostrates that there is no more "spirit" after physical death.


Quote
Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.
Show me a fleeting thought, show me a yearning, show me a pain, show me an empathetic feeling, show me - - -. Does the fact that one cannot "show" those in finite form mean that they do not exist? Hardly. Do you you have a soul? Really!? If you feel, or believe, that you do not have a soul, it is understandable that you would not believe that your "spirit" will live on after your body rots. If, on the other hand, you believe that you do have a soul, how do you know that? Has medical science demonstrated it to you?


Quote
The bible doesn't "teach" you anything, it merely makes you believe what somebody else wants you to believe.
One cannot speak for others on this point, but the Bible does not make me believe anything - nor does it make me do anything. The Bible is the Word of God - it is ours to study, or not study. It is ours to believe, or not believe. God has given mankind a lot of free will - His Word does not make us do anything at all - we have choices to make. According to God's Word, those choices determine our future - for eternity. I have yet to see where medical science has spoken definitively about our future for eternity.


Quote
Stop preaching and being subtly passive aggressive in your constant attempts at "enlightening those who aren't able to see the way to salvation", you're not doing yourselves any favors.
The above questions and analyses are neither preaching nor constant on my part. They may seem somewhat passive, but they are not subtle - and one can only hope that they can be enlightening. There is no effort here to convince you of anything - no plea or encoragement for you to do anything, except maybe to be more open in some way. Any agression in these matters must be be left to God. In addressing God's plan for the salvation of mankind, no Christian can be doing himself a favor. Any such favor would be to God.

This is not an easy conversation, but I hope that you will be able to see the comments in the positive spirit intended, and hope it is in some way helpful.
CCCC............ any none believer who finds something objectionable in your post is likely trying to put himself beyond the reach of God.

Trying to escape from something which does not exist puts a man in strange company. grin
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?
I can't answer that question on the grounds I would be judging people which if your a christian you shouldn't do.
But - the question contains part of the answer provided you assume what a Christian is.

That's where opinions seem to differ

I'm still wondering why Ken won't touch one of my posts with a 10 foot pole - I'm not trying to be sarcastic
1 Timothy 6:4

he is puffed up with conceit and understands nothing. He has an unhealthy craving for controversy and for quarrels about words, which produce envy, dissension, slander, evil suspicions,

2 Timothy 2:23

Don�t have anything to do with foolish and stupid arguments, because you know they produce quarrels.

Titus 3:9

But avoid foolish controversies, genealogies, dissensions, and quarrels about the law, for they are unprofitable and worthless.
Posted By: GeoW Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
ColdBore, I am a true believer that you will receive your registered mail in due time. I hope you are are ready to sign for it.

G
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


Ask Him................. He's alive, you know.

Being convinced of a Risen Christ relieves me of any responsibility to answer stupid questions on His behalf.
If He is risen then that answers the question, thanks!
1. I don't know which question you refer to, but it makes no difference since I judge people's actions and words all the time.

2.I can't answer for Ken. Ask him......he's alive, you know.

3. Gonna be off line awhile. CCCC has my proxy vote. grin
Quote
Much of that seems true, but please show where/how medical science demostrates that there is no more "spirit" after physical death.



Medical science doesn�t need to prove a negative. The burden of proof is always on the person making the assertive claim. There�s no evidence for a soul for or against.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by billhilly
Quote
ColdBore: medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit"

Quote
CCCC: Much of that seems true, but please show where/how medical science demonstrates that there is no more "spirit" after physical death.



Medical science doesn�t need to prove a negative. The burden of proof is always on the person making the assertive claim. There�s no evidence for a soul for or against.


billhilly, Let it be clear - no assertion on my part - merely asked the gentleman to show where/how his assertive claim has been demonstrated.
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


Ask Him................. He's alive, you know.

Being convinced of a Risen Christ relieves me of any responsibility to answer stupid questions on His behalf.


Don't give up hope you old goat. Wife and I are going to church on Palm Sunday and Easter.
It never ceases to amaze me how so many people think their beliefs are the only acceptable belief. I gave up on organized religion years ago. I was raised by a devout mother (who incidentally was a Sunday school teacher for 30 years) but she failed to accept that maybe I could think for myself. She tried so hard to get me to accept what she believed that eventually it drove me away from religion.

I believe my life follows what is accepted to be a "good" life if the word "religion" isn't brought into the discussion. I believe that when I die I am gone. If others think otherwise it is not my intent or place to try and dissuade them. I think it is presumptuous for others to think they know so much better than I what I should do or believe in.

The only thing this thread brings to me is the rigidity of thought some people hold.

All the best to everyone no matter what their orientation.

Jim
Originally Posted by CCCC
Originally Posted by billhilly
Quote
ColdBore: medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit"

Quote
CCCC: Much of that seems true, but please show where/how medical science demonstrates that there is no more "spirit" after physical death.



Medical science doesn�t need to prove a negative. The burden of proof is always on the person making the assertive claim. There�s no evidence for a soul for or against.


billhilly, Let it be clear - no assertion on my part - merely asked the gentleman to show where/how his assertive claim has been demonstrated.


Fair enough. In the absence of evidence, it is reasonable to withhold belief. Like unicorns for instance. I don�t believe they exist but concede it is possible someone may come back from the jungles of Borneo or someplace with hard evidence of them. Until that happens, I will continue to believe they do not exist.
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


I say yes. Matthew 11:28 whistle
Here are some words from the New Testament that convinced me to put on Christ.

Through him we have also obtained access by faith into this grace in which we stand, and we rejoice in hope of the glory of God. - Romans 5:2

So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ. - Rom 10:17

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life. - John 3:16

Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit. - Acts 2:38

...if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved. - Romans 10:9-10

Whoever believes and is baptized will be saved, but whoever does not believe will be condemned. - Mark 16:16

...and you will be hated by all for my name's sake. But the one who endures to the end will be saved. - Matthew 10:22
Quote

Originally Posted By: Ringman
Quote:
The only baptism that is real is the baptism(immersion) of the Holy Spirit, which can't be defined in that worldly term or a contained in a worldly gesture.

Folks throughout history have felt that 'something', without a religion to define it and excepted without fanfare.

They are the lucky ones not having to debate bullchit...

�Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these"

Kent


You will see in Acts 10 after the Holy Spirit fell on a group of Gentiles that Apostle Peter ordered them to be baptized in water. This was in response an angel telling someone Apostle Peter would tell them ALL the Words of eternal life.


I don't define my faith through Paul.


Apostle Peter and Apostle Paul are not the same guy. Never the less both were instructed by Jesus and inspired by the Holy Spirit in what they wrote.
Quote
The only thing this thread brings to me is the rigidity of thought some people hold.


You want us to believe you don't have "rigidity of thought"?
Originally Posted by Spotshooter
� I'm still wondering why Ken won't touch one of my posts with a 10 foot pole - I'm not trying to be sarcastic

For a very simple reason �

Your posts just happen to be among the bale of so many others that I'm not commenting on.

See? I'm just not answering a lot of posts � just keeping my thoughts to myself, mostly.

Not interested in endlessly debating every little bone of contention. Never got any thrill out of watching BBs bounce off boulders.

I read the thread often but answer or contribute very few posts (when I feel that I can contribute something that'll edify somebody who'll receive it).

In general, I let everyone who's committed to an opinion enjoy it to his own heart's content, without feeling that I hafta urge 'im to accept my knowledge or opinion.

Human minds do not decide or declare God's existence, ways, or works � neither by questioning nor by ridicule. Most certainly not by ridicule nor by ridiculous questions that arise from rejection or rebellion.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Ringman

Apostle Peter and Apostle Paul are not the same guy.


Well there's a revelation... and acts wasn't written by Peter.

Originally Posted by Ringman

Never the less both were instructed by Jesus and inspired by the Holy Spirit in what they wrote.


Peter was instructed by Jesus... many have been inspired by the Holy spirit in what they wrote.

How many Dogmas you willing to recognize?

Kent
Originally Posted by Ken Howell


Not interested in endlessly debating every little bone of contention. Never got any thrill out of watching BBs bounce off boulders.

I read the thread often but answer or contribute very few posts (when I feel that I can contribute something that'll edify somebody who'll receive it).

In general, I let everyone who's committed to an opinion enjoy it to his own heart's content, without feeling that I hafta urge 'im to accept my knowledge or opinion.

Human minds do not decide or declare God's existence, ways, or works � neither by questioning nor by ridicule. Most certainly not by ridicule nor by ridiculous questions that arise from rejection or rebellion.


Exactly the way I feel. Kind of interesting that some find so much fault with us for not arguing.
This is from a letter written by one Sebastian Castellio to the then Duke of Wurtemburg.

�If you, illustrious Prince, had informed your subjects that you were coming to visit them at an unnamed time, and had requested them to be prepared in white garments to meet you at your coming, what would you do if on arrival you should find that, instead of robing themselves in white, they had spent their time in violent debate about your person � some insisting that you were in France; others that you were in Spain; some declaring that you would come on horseback, others that you could come by chariot; some holding that you would come with great pomp and others that you would come without any train or following? And what especially would you say if they debated not only with words, but with blows of fist and sword strokes, and if some succeeded in killing and destroying others who differed from them?

�He will come on horseback.� �No, he will not; it will be by chariot.� �You lie.� �I do not; you are the liar.� �Take that� � a blow with a fist. �That that� � a sword-thrust through the body.

Prince, what would you think of such citizens? Christ asked us to put on the white robes of a pure and holy life; but what occupies our thoughts? We dispute not only the way to Christ, but of his relation to God the Father, of the Trinity, of predestination, of free will, of the nature of God, of the angels, of the condition of the soul after death � of a multitude of matters that are not essential to salvation; matters, moreover, which can never be known until our hearts are pure; for they are things which must be spiritually perceived�.


That was written in the 16th century, I see that not one thing has changed in the intervening 500 or more years, nor are they likely to change in the next 5000.
Sad but true.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
� Human minds do not decide or declare God's existence, ways, or works � neither by questioning nor by ridicule. Most certainly not by ridicule nor by ridiculous questions that arise from rejection or rebellion.

� nor by debate nor by majority vote.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


I say yes. Matthew 11:28 whistle


did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.
Adam & Eve may not have belly buttons, but they have most of the other toys you might want. I know this because they send me e-mails all the time.
Quote
Well there's a revelation... and acts wasn't written by Peter.


Where'd you get the idea I think Acts was written by Peter.

Quote
Peter was instructed by Jesus...


The way you wrote it suggests to me you don't think Apostle Paul was taught by Jesus. Am I correct?

Quote
How many Dogmas you willing to recognize?


All that I'm aware of and some I'm not.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
How many Dogmas you willing to recognize?

All that I'm aware of and some I'm not.

Including those that contradict each other?

Including those that contradict the Bible?
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/12/13
Originally Posted by billhilly
Fair enough. In the absence of evidence, it is reasonable to withhold belief. Like unicorns for instance. I don�t believe they exist but concede it is possible someone may come back from the jungles of Borneo or someplace with hard evidence of them. Until that happens, I will continue to believe they do not exist.
Fair enough, as well. Cannot disagree with that aspect - am OK with even total denial of unicorns. But, that fellow stated that medical science taught us something seminal about the "spirit". Often, when someone tells me what medical science has taught, I ask where, and how. Show me the evidence, for learning sake if for no other.
You�ll get no argument from me against asking for the evidence.
Again, if Kenny is saved I know my alternative is a better one.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Gus
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


I say yes. Matthew 11:28 whistle


did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.


That is totally untrue and ridiculous that neither Adam nor Eve had navels. How do you know? God made them in full and true human form, perfect in every way.

And of course Jesus had a naval. He was born of Mary and therefor had a naval. To write that Jesus did not have a naval is to deny his humanity. The bible teaches that Jesus was totally human and totally God.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd
Originally Posted by Gus
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


I say yes. Matthew 11:28 whistle


did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.


That is totally untrue and ridiculous that neither Adam nor Eve had navels. How do you know? God made them in full and true human form, perfect in every way.

And of course Jesus had a naval. He was born of Mary and therefor had a naval. To write that Jesus did not have a naval is to deny his humanity. The bible teaches that Jesus was totally human and totally God.

Come on guys (beleivers) does pearls & swine ring a bell?
Yep, it is ridiculous to assume that two people with three sons populating the earth with humans didn't have belly buttons.
Originally Posted by Gus
did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.


Let me see, you're saying that God could create Adam from a lump of clay and Eve from a rib of Adam, but He couldn't create them with belly buttons. Is that right?
Quote
Yep, it is ridiculous to assume that two people with three sons populating the earth with humans didn't have belly buttons.


Where did the three sons get there wives? Maybe there is a theologian here who can tell us.
Could be or maybe it's allegory contradicted by all available evidence.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Where did the three sons get there wives? Maybe there is a theologian here who can tell us.

"Our own curiosity (or unyielding obstinacy � KEH) often hinders us in the reading of the Scriptures, when we desire to understand (or ridicule � KEH) and discuss that which we should instead pass over [and move-on]." ( � Thomas � Kempis)
How the heck do you remember all that stuff?
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Yep, it is ridiculous to assume that two people with three sons populating the earth with humans didn't have belly buttons.


Where did the three sons get there wives? Maybe there is a theologian here who can tell us.


Not correct to assume that Adam and Eve only bore three sons, more likely since humans in those days lived much longer lives, of ten hundreds of years, that there were many children, both male and female.

God only reveals to us what we need to know concerning salvation through Jesus. All will eventually be revealed when we get to heaven. Faith man, Faith.
Originally Posted by eyeball
How the heck do you remember all that stuff?

� Write it down some place.
� Remember that I wrote it down some place.
� Try to remember where I wrote it down.
� Try to find where I wrote it down.
� Find (now 'n' then) where I wrote it down.
Un Real

(Or is that surreal?)
Really!!
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by eyeball
How the heck do you remember all that stuff?

� Write it down some place.
� Remember that I wrote it down some place.
� Try to remember where I wrote it down.
� Try to find where I wrote it down.
� Find (now 'n' then) where I wrote it down.


I have nearly the same system but mine looks like this.

� Write it down some place.
� Remember that I wrote it down some place.
� Try to remember where I wrote it down.
� Try to find where I wrote it down.
� Find (now 'n' then) where I wrote it down.
� If I find it either can't read my own writing or figure out my spelling or both.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Gus
did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.


Let me see, you're saying that God could create Adam from a lump of clay and Eve from a rib of Adam, but He couldn't create them with belly buttons. Is that right?


oh, he could, he could, if he wanted to? he could create Sasquatch, Chupacabra, and the Loch Ness Monster if he wanted to. he can do anything.

but, i'll match ya, and raise ya one, if that's ok? even if there wasn't a God, we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, Jesus, Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it, it's appeared on the road to travel with us at one time or another.

a lot of the old gods have been knocked in the head, and have been rolled down to the bottom of the ditch on side of the road. i hope my God and your God doesn't meet that fate. wink
Any sulfa drug you rx can kill someone by causing Stevens-Johnson's syndrome. I have thousands of things like that written down all over the place and couldn't find most of it on a bet.
10-4, Scott. I live there.
Not pointing at anyone specific here but as a general rule

- The more someone flaps their lips professing to be something the less I believe 'em

And that goes for myself as well
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Did Christ masturbate as a child, yes/no?


Ask Him................. He's alive, you know.

Being convinced of a Risen Christ relieves me of any responsibility to answer stupid questions on His behalf.


Don't give up hope you old goat. Wife and I are going to church on Palm Sunday and Easter.


Pears sent for the church.grin
Originally Posted by Gus
� we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, � , Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it �

And humans have for many centuries tried to do so.

But forming wishful or hostile opinions and theories re gods is a long way from creating actual gods. No one can create anything that'll be greater than himself in all regards.

I can't remember even one science-fiction fantasizer who ever created any of the critters and superheroes that he fantasized.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by Gus
� we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, � , Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it �

And humans have for many centuries tried to do so.

But forming wishful or hostile opinions and theories re gods is a long way from creating actual gods. No one can create anything that'll be greater than himself in all regards.

I can't remember even one science-fiction fantasizer who ever created any of the critters and superheroes that he fantasized.


Men have also be claiming to have found the true God for eon's, but some many of them then started applying God's laws with the minds of men

"...even if there wasn't a God, we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, Jesus, Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it, it's appeared on the road to travel with us at one time or another."

Doubt it. What you see in your examples is more likely a result of God creating a spiritual vacuum in man that can only be filled by Himself; those who don't come to him in truth simply seek another way to fill that vacuum. If there was no maker/God, there would be no need for man to 'invent' a god.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Ringman

Quote
Peter was instructed by Jesus...


The way you wrote it suggests to me you don't think Apostle Paul was taught by Jesus. Am I correct?



Literally, no... not like Peter.

Figuratively, every person who believes a God hears and answers them feels instructed.

Kent
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by Gus
� we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, � , Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it �

And humans have for many centuries tried to do so.

But forming wishful or hostile opinions and theories re gods is a long way from creating actual gods. No one can create anything that'll be greater than himself in all regards.

I can't remember even one science-fiction fantasizer who ever created any of the critters and superheroes that he fantasized.


Ken, i think you are totally on tract (track)?

it just amazes me when ordinary, lowly commoners can advance forth and kilt a God? we all know that's nearly impossible. don't we?
1 Timothy 6:4

he is puffed up with conceit and understands nothing. He has an unhealthy craving for controversy and for quarrels about words, which produce envy, dissension, slander, evil suspicions,

2 Timothy 2:23

Don�t have anything to do with foolish and stupid arguments, because you know they produce quarrels.

Titus 3:9

But avoid foolish controversies, genealogies, dissensions, and quarrels about the law, for they are unprofitable and worthless.
Originally Posted by boomtube
"...even if there wasn't a God, we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, Jesus, Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it, it's appeared on the road to travel with us at one time or another."

Doubt it. What you see in your examples is more likely a result of God creating a spiritual vacuum in man that can only be filled by Himself; those who don't come to him in truth simply seek another way to fill that vacuum. If there was no maker/God, there would be no need for man to 'invent' a god.

Please take note that in the above you aren't quoting me or responding to what I posted.
Originally Posted by boomtube
"...even if there wasn't a God, we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, Jesus, Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it, it's appeared on the road to travel with us at one time or another."

Doubt it. What you see in your examples is more likely a result of God creating a spiritual vacuum in man that can only be filled by Himself; those who don't come to him in truth simply seek another way to fill that vacuum. If there was no maker/God, there would be no need for man to 'invent' a god.
And some have- I know him as "Zero"
ref call's a foul on both sides -

In some circles having bad spelling is a foul (I'm part of the guilty)
In other circles focusing on the trimming, vs. the meat of a post is also a foul

So the two fouls cancel each other... Continue
Originally Posted by eyeball
Any sulfa drug you rx can kill someone by causing Stevens-Johnson's syndrome. I have thousands of things like that written down all over the place and couldn't find most of it on a bet.


You been smoking way too much "Wackey Weed"
Originally Posted by Gus
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Gus
did Jesus have a belly button?

we know that Adam & Eve did not.


Let me see, you're saying that God could create Adam from a lump of clay and Eve from a rib of Adam, but He couldn't create them with belly buttons. Is that right?


oh, he could, he could, if he wanted to? he could create Sasquatch, Chupacabra, and the Loch Ness Monster if he wanted to. he can do anything.

but, i'll match ya, and raise ya one, if that's ok? even if there wasn't a God, we humans would create one if we wanted one enough. Allah, Yahweh, Jesus, Buddha, Ra, Odin, you name it, it's appeared on the road to travel with us at one time or another.

a lot of the old gods have been knocked in the head, and have been rolled down to the bottom of the ditch on side of the road. i hope my God and your God doesn't meet that fate. wink


Not only that, but even if the God of the Bible is real some humans would create an explanation of how life and all they see came to be without God.

However, no one gets to know for sure, we all believe what we do about God by faith and faith alone. Christians acknowledge they believe by faith while the self deluded think they know something on the basis of evidence.

Personally I believe the gospel because it's like a key that fits a lock in my heart. It's the way the Almighty would select those who are suitable for eternity in His kingdom. All that's required is the ability to humble one's self before God and believe the foolishness of the message preached. If you can do that then God can perfect the rest of you.
Originally Posted by Dons99

Come on guys (beleivers) does pearls & swine ring a bell?


Got a crisp $50 says Satan will be butt [bleep] you whilst Kenny is cheering on.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99

Come on guys (beleivers) does pearls & swine ring a bell?


Got a crisp $50 says Satan will be butt [bleep] you whilst Kenny is cheering on.

But these speak evil of whatever they do not know; and whatever they know naturally, like brute beasts, in these things they corrupt themselves. Jude 10
Quote
Not correct to assume that Adam and Eve only bore three sons, more likely since humans in those days lived much longer lives, of ten hundreds of years, that there were many children, both male and female.


When Adam lived one hundred and thirty years he became the father of a son in his own likeness, according to his image,, and name him Seth. The the days of Adam after he becsme the father of Seth were eight hundred year, and he had sons and daughters. So all the days that Adam lived were nine hundred and thirty years, and he died." Genesis 5:3-5
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99

Come on guys (beleivers) does pearls & swine ring a bell?


Got a crisp $50 says Satan will be butt [bleep] you whilst Kenny is cheering on.

But these speak evil of whatever they do not know; and whatever they know naturally, like brute beasts, in these things they corrupt themselves. Jude 10


Blow me. Jude 69
Dear Lord, Please have mercy on the gnat in your hair, for he knows not... .Amen
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Originally Posted by Dons99

Come on guys (beleivers) does pearls & swine ring a bell?


Got a crisp $50 says Satan will be butt [bleep] you whilst Kenny is cheering on.

But these speak evil of whatever they do not know; and whatever they know naturally, like brute beasts, in these things they corrupt themselves. Jude 10


Blow me. Jude 69

Proverbs 18:7
A fool�s mouth is his destruction, And his lips are the snare of his soul.
Quote
Figuratively, every person who believes a God hears and answers them feels instructed.


I guess I must be messed up. I only know three people who claim to have actually heard the voice of God. That does not include me. I don't hear God. His instructions come to me from His Word, the Bible.
Frightenly, too true.
Dear God, save me from your followers.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Figuratively, every person who believes a God hears and answers them feels instructed.


I guess I must be messed up. I only know three people who claim to have actually heard the voice of God. That does not include me. I don't hear God. His instructions come to me from His Word, the Bible.
I'm pretty sure You live in Him.
I have been touched by His noodly appendage.

Cheese Be Upon Him, rAmen.
Originally Posted by eyeball
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Figuratively, every person who believes a God hears and answers them feels instructed.


I guess I must be messed up. I only know three people who claim to have actually heard the voice of God. That does not include me. I don't hear God. His instructions come to me from His Word, the Bible.
I'm pretty sure You live in Him.


I'm fairly certain you do too.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Figuratively, every person who believes a God hears and answers them feels instructed.


I guess I must be messed up. I only know three people who claim to have actually heard the voice of God. That does not include me. I don't hear God. His instructions come to me from His Word, the Bible.


You can't read for chit can you?... Voice... Paul and Peter aren't the same dude... Paul was taught by Jesus...

Kent
Originally Posted by Dons99
� Proverbs 18:7
A fool�s mouth is his destruction, And his lips are the snare of his soul.

And there's nothing else quite like this kind of a thread to lure 'em into blaring-forth the noise of their destruction as if they delight in it.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Dear God, save me from your followers.

Thats a great start, glad I could help!
Don't sweat it, I'm praying for your hell bent soul. I only hope you find the path. God has told me you are [bleep].
MacLorry,

Quote
All that's required is the ability to humble one's self before God and believe the foolishness of the message preached.



I have read this thread from the beginning and your sentence above has more to say than the vast majority of those who have posted. One must humble himself to come to the Lord. But how hard it is for us humans to think we don't have the answers.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by Dons99
� Proverbs 18:7
A fool�s mouth is his destruction, And his lips are the snare of his soul.

And there's nothing else quite like this kind of a thread to lure 'em into blaring-forth the noise of their destruction as if they delight in it.


It truly does bring out the hypocrites in force. Say hey to your kids you old [bleep].
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by Dons99
� Proverbs 18:7
A fool�s mouth is his destruction, And his lips are the snare of his soul.

And there's nothing else quite like this kind of a thread to lure 'em into blaring-forth the noise of their destruction as if they delight in it.
Like moths crawling into the lantern top on a lake at night, as you sit and catch crappie for a feast.

The power of Satan makes them no more than a moth drawn to the fire, unable to do more than follow their nose.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Steelhead
Don't sweat it, I'm praying for your hell bent soul. I only hope you find the path. God has told me you are [bleep].
Steel you're doing great, 2 prayers in just a matter minutes.
Heb 11:6 He is a rewarder of those who diligently seek Him.
eyeball,

Quote
I'm pretty sure You live in Him.


I wrote an essay called Jesus, the Formed God. It appears to be heretical at first, but it is one of my better works.


To help us understand more fully what Scripture is teaching about God and Jesus and us, we will look at an illustration. Several years ago, when one of the Soviet's cosmonauts returned from a few orbits around the earth, he told us that he had looked out of the porthole and did not see God. Corresponding to this a little girl received a set of new roller skates. She was so excited that she asked her mommy to help her put them on immediately. She happily took off on her maiden roll. Before she traversed the length of her own height, the skates traveled faster than her center of gravity and she sat down abruptly. Her bumped bottom received a bruise. In case you don't know what a visible bruise is, it is blood that escapes from its blood vessels and spreads out and shows under the skin. For the sake of this illustration we will pretend that the blood cells are intelligent and communicative. One got back into the blood stream. It informed those who would listen, "We have all heard of people. When I was out of our normal environment and in the open I looked about and did not see any people. They do not exist!" What does God say? Everything that is created is in Me and held together by Me!(Colossians 1:17, Jeremiah 23:23-24) Consequently no matter how far one travels on earth or from earth, while he is in time and space, he "is in Him".
AMEN
Posted By: 700LH Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by Dons99
� Proverbs 18:7
A fool�s mouth is his destruction, And his lips are the snare of his soul.

And there's nothing else quite like this kind of a thread to lure 'em into blaring-forth the noise of their destruction as if they delight in it.


And those but what spew and stir up, this kinda venomous thread, just for that purpose, and delight in it.
That sounds like the time worn Pantheistic argument that "God had to make the universe out of Himself since He was all that existed".

Quote
That sounds like the time worn Pantheistic argument that "God had to make the universe out of Himself since He was all that existed".


Your sentence is self contradicting. Pantheistic implies more than one. The God of the Bible is The Infinite One. Nothing can exist outside of infinite. Not knowledge, not energy, not space, not anything.
You should learn more about Pantheism if you are going to argue against it.

And I ain't in the mood to teach you.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
I now take solace in the fact he once told me I'm going to hell... on his record of reading stuff right...

I'm a shoo in to heaven for sure...

Kent
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
The only baptism that is real is the baptism(immersion) of the Holy Spirit, which can't be defined in that worldly term or a contained in a worldly gesture. . .


You will see in Acts 10 after the Holy Spirit fell on a group of Gentiles that Apostle Peter ordered them to be baptized in water. This was in response an angel telling someone Apostle Peter would tell them ALL the Words of eternal life.


Rightly stated Ring . . . let me add a bit on the conversion of Cornelius.

Acts 10:1-2 tells us that: There was a certain man in C�sarea called Cornelius, a centurion of the band called the Italian band,
2 A devout man, and one that feared God with all his house, which gave much alms to the people, and prayed to God alway.

Cornelius was considered a devout man, but he was lost, because the angel appeared unto him and told him to send for Peter who would tell him words that would lead to his salvation (Acts 11:13-14)

So like you say Ring, when Peter commanded them to be baptized in water (Acts 10:47-48), those were part of the words (gospel) whereby Cornelius and his household were to be saved.

When the Holy Spirit fell on Cornelius and his household (Gentiles) it had nothing to do with the remission of their sins, it was a sign to Peter and the other Jews who accompanied him that God accepts Gentiles. (Acts 11:17) Peter makes it clear that he had to think back all the way to the Day of Pentecost in Acts 2 to remember a time when the Spirit fell on a group of people (manifested by miraculous gifts) directly from heaven, and not through the laying on of the Apostles hands, which was the only way Spiritual gifts were imparted in the first century (Acts 8:15-18)

Also, it is the hearing and obedience to the gospel that is the power of God unto salvation (Rom 1:16 - For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek.) But Cornelius and his household had not yet heard the gospel when the Holy Spirit fell on them, for the Scripture says that Peter had only began to speak when the Spirit manifested itself (Acts 11:15)
[quote=Bull_Elk]All I know is that as a human, I'm a sinner. I pray a lot for forgiveness and some day that the grace of God bestowed upon me at my baptism will allow to enter the eternal kingdom. [/quote

Bull_elk I know what you mean as I'm a subscriber of Back Sliders Wine as well,and though

in the book of life I am not proud of the way I live . Guess it's time to try harder.

Bob
Originally Posted by Ringman
MacLorry,

Quote
All that's required is the ability to humble one's self before God and believe the foolishness of the message preached.



I have read this thread from the beginning and your sentence above has more to say than the vast majority of those who have posted. One must humble himself to come to the Lord. But how hard it is for us humans to think we don't have the answers.


I'm sure you'll recognize that what I wrote comes from 1 Corinthians 1:18-31. Perhaps every Christian can cite some scripture that sealed their faith and 1 Corinthians 1:18-31 is that for me. Not that it stands alone, but that it explained what I needed explained.
Posted By: tbear Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Your comment seems illogical to me. American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?
Posted By: ingwe Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by tbear
American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?


Odd that this came up. I asked a christian freind of mine that some years ago. He assured me that they all burnt in hell because they did not know Christ. Seemed happy with the answer too....


Same goes for those in foreign lands who have never been exposed to Christianity through no fault of their own...they are all going to hell too...


Uhhhhhhhhhhh......
Where did people go before there was Christ or Hell?
Posted By: ingwe Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Longbob
Where did people go before there was Christ or Hell?



Chicago....kinda the same thing as hell....
Good answer, but I am waiting on the Hades play.
Posted By: ingwe Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
I thought Hades was on the south side....
Ooops! It is early and I am not quite awake. Should have phrased that "Where did one's soul go before Christ died for our sins and before there was a Hell?"
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by Longbob
Where did people go before there was Christ or Hell?



Chicago....kinda the same thing as hell....


California, thats why they are so overpopulated grin
Posted By: ingwe Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
I think you're baiting me now.... wink
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by tbear
American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?


Odd that this came up. I asked a christian freind of mine that some years ago. He assured me that they all burnt in hell because they did not know Christ. Seemed happy with the answer too....


Same goes for those in foreign lands who have never been exposed to Christianity through no fault of their own...they are all going to hell too...


Uhhhhhhhhhhh......


Beyond God controlling where and when believing souls are sent you have to consider 1 Peter 4:6 "For this is the reason the gospel was preached even to those who are now dead, so that they might be judged according to men in regard to the body, but live according to God in regard to the spirit."

Consider also the Biblical principle of to whom more is given more is required. Those with the ability to read and have access to the Bible may be held to a higher standard that those who are unable to do so.
Originally Posted by ingwe
I think you're baiting me now.... wink


At least you gave an answer. And it was honest!
Originally Posted by tbear
Your comment seems illogical to me. American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?


I try not to get involved in these kind of discussions, but I have seen this question a lot from non-believers and haven't really seen anybody try to give you guys a genuine answer. I don't have all the answers, but I'd like to attempt to address this one, if I may...

My answer will come from my personal relationship with Him, rather than from a cerebral dogmatic approach...

Two things about God's Character come into play right off the bat. First, God is a just God and not some condescending judgmental jerk with a baseball bat waiting to clobber us for our sins and send us off into eternal damnation all while laughing. That's just not the God that I know.

Jesus is just. He will do the right thing. I believe this enough to trust Him with my eternity.

The second thing about God's Character is that He is compassionate. He loves us enough that He was willing to be mocked, beaten, and murdered just to provide a way for us to spend eternity with Him. There is no doubt in my mind that He had all people in mind when He did that.

That's the Jesus that I know. So, what has He said about any of that?

Originally Posted by John 3:17
"For God did not send the Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world might be saved through Him.


That kind of points to my first paragraph about the dude with the bat waiting to launch people into damnation. That's just not the God that I know...

Hebrews 12:2 tells us that the very reason He endured the cross was for the joy that was before Him. What joy!? It certainly wasn't the cross. Heaven maybe? Then why bother to leave in the first place? No, His joy is in us. He just plain loves us. Why? BEATS ME! I think He's a little crazy for loving me, personally, as I certainly don't do Him a whole lot of favors...

The Bible says that He has revealed Himself to everybody and that nobody has an excuse for ignoring or rejecting Him. We all are given the choice to acknowledge Him or not.

Originally Posted by Romans 1:19-20
For what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them. For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse.


He has revealed Himself to every man, woman, and child in two very clear ways. First, his eternal power and secondly, through His divine nature.

Most of us on the Campfire marvel at the works of nature and relish any chance we have to get out into it. Those works are Gods handiwork. Why do you think it's in our core to return to nature? It's where God created us. He made Adam from the dirt of the ground and IN the Garden of Eden. The wilderness is home for us...

Lastly, (and I could go on and on...) the last thing about God that I know to be true is that He's far more intelligent than we are. His was are above our ways and His thoughts are above our thoughts. So much so that the Bible says that His ways seem foolish to us. In many ways they do, but they never fail to yield amazing results.

He loved those American Indians, Eskimos, and many aboriginal people enough to die for them. He didn't just leave them to flounder. They may not have known Christianity (they're lucky in many ways there!laugh) but God said that He has revealed Himself to them.

Ultimately, where we spend eternity is our choice.

I hope that helps address your question, tbear. smile
For those who genuinely want to understand what happened to the dead before Jesus Christ, what happens to them now, and what will happen to them in the future there's a good article by W. Edward Bedore, Th.D. titled Hell, Sheol, Hades, Paradise, and the Grave
Originally Posted by Longbob
Ooops! It is early and I am not quite awake. Should have phrased that "Where did one's soul go before Christ died for our sins and before there was a Hell?"


Good question!

Hell was actually created before we were! It was never intended, by God, that people spend eternity there. The Bible is very clear that Hell was created to punish Lucifer (aka Satan) and his angels that waged war in Heaven. That was it's purpose.

Where did one's soul go before the redemption? My honest answer is that I don't know. That said, there are some references in Scripture of a place called "Abraham's Bosom" where souls would go. eek

Yeah, I don't know much more about that "place" than that, but as MacLorry pointed out, there is some indication that Jesus went someplace those three days that He was in the tomb, to gather up and take those souls with Him to Heaven...
Oh, and one more verse about all those tribes and Nations of people separated from "Christianity" by time and geography...

John was exiled for his faith and in exile He had a vision of Heaven. This is part of that vision...

Originally Posted by Revelation 7:9
After these things I looked, and behold, a great multitude which no one could count, from every nation and all tribes and peoples and tongues, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, clothed in white robes, and palm branches were in their hands;


They're there! smile

So yeah, He's just, compassionate, and His ways are above ours...
It's long, but check it out if you have the time. Hell, Sheol, Hades, Paradise, and the Grave
Interesting piece Mac. I can't say that I agree with all of it, but such is life, eh!? smile

I'm also certainly no authority on religion. I just have a relationship with God, and try to speak from the experiences that I garner from that.

Kind of like when Paul said "I know nothing, other than Christ, and Him crucified."

Some here might be able to make the point that unlike Paul, I should stop at the first comma! grin
Originally Posted by MacLorry
For those who genuinely want to understand what happened to the dead before Jesus Christ, what happens to them now, and what will happen to them in the future there's a good article by W. Edward Bedore, Th.D. titled Hell, Sheol, Hades, Paradise, and the Grave


Nice article of trying to explain a difficult question, but there are some major holes. For example, Abraham's bosom. Where did all the others before Abraham go?
Posted By: Tom264 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Longbob
Where did people go before there was Christ or Hell?

Said I wasn't going to post on this thread anymore but this is a softball question.

Before Jesus, shoot all the way back to the garden of Eden man had an established way....it was and always will be through the blood sacrifice.

Until Jesus it was animals, that's why Abel's sacrifice was a more excellent sacrifice over Cains...his was through fruits and vegetables.

Then when Jesus came it was through His blood.

And those 3 days when Jesus was in the tomb, his spirit was in hell preaching to the lost souls that never heard his name.

Nobody has an excuse!!!!

I'm out!
Originally Posted by Tom264
Originally Posted by Longbob
Where did people go before there was Christ or Hell?

Said I wasn't going to post on this thread anymore but this is a softball question.

Before Jesus, shoot all the way back to the garden of Eden man had an established way....it was and always will be through the blood sacrifice.

Until Jesus it was animals, that's why Abel's sacrifice was a more excellent sacrifice over Cains...his was through fruits and vegetables.

Then when Jesus came it was through His blood.

And those 3 days when Jesus was in the tomb, his spirit was in hell preaching to the lost souls that never heard his name.

Nobody has an excuse!!!!

I'm out!


For such a softball question you gave no answer with a destination.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Concerning Indians, pygmies, monks in a cave, jews, muslims, hindus... ect

God, JC, Holy spirit have a bunch of names in just the bible... and a bunch more they will answer to throughout history.

If there's just one God then that's who everyone has believed in... they just don't believe in someone elses version.

I was once told I wasn't a believer because I didn't capitalize the C in christ... and so it goes.

Jesus is inclusionary, he was also KISS in his small part of the bible... if you have ever felt you are part of something bigger than just yourself... you recognized and named God...

See ya there.

Kent
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
For those who genuinely want to understand what happened to the dead before Jesus Christ, what happens to them now, and what will happen to them in the future there's a good article by W. Edward Bedore, Th.D. titled Hell, Sheol, Hades, Paradise, and the Grave


Nice article of trying to explain a difficult question, but there are some major holes. For example, Abraham's bosom. Where did all the others before Abraham go?


From the article Abraham's bosom is just another name for Paradise which existed from the beginning within Hades until it was moved to heaven.
Maybe I can narrow it down a bit. No man has ever gotten into heaven before Jesus according to Jesus himself.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Where did all the others before Abraham go?


It's my understanding from reading the Bible that "Abraham's Bosom" was a gimmicky name applied to a place that existed long before Abraham...

Kind of like calling NYC, "The Big Apple"...
Originally Posted by Longbob
Maybe I can narrow it down a bit. No man has ever gotten into heaven before Jesus according to Jesus himself.


He didn't say "No man comes to the Father before me"

He said, "No man comes to the Father, except through me."

If He did what the Bible suggests, and went to the souls in "Abraham's Bosom" then they still got there through him.

Like I said though, I don't have every answer. I don't know how God does all His stuff, if I did, I'd be God, and nobody wants that! shocked
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
For those who genuinely want to understand what happened to the dead before Jesus Christ, what happens to them now, and what will happen to them in the future there's a good article by W. Edward Bedore, Th.D. titled Hell, Sheol, Hades, Paradise, and the Grave


Nice article of trying to explain a difficult question, but there are some major holes. For example, Abraham's bosom. Where did all the others before Abraham go?


From the article Abraham's bosom is just another name for Paradise which existed from the beginning within Hades until it was moved to heaven.


Paradise hmmm.... No one would have know about that section of Sheol if Jesus hadn't had brought it up to the thief beside him.

If you step back an look at what is happening then you may see how religion via the Bible (or book of your choosing) is the most vile and effective form of control that man has ever created. It is several levels worse than politics since it preys on a person's deepest most vulnerable fears.

The bipolar God of the Old Testament wasn't as effective in creating the followers so they got a little more clever and came up with a newer angle of more loving form of a higher power, Jesus. This did appeal to a far larger audience and still is today.

To keep that appeal going, the churches really have to downplay the BS, murder, genocide, slavery, sexism, and racism in the Bible and do their best to focus on the messages of good and eternal hope. Otherwise it would be difficult to extort the 10% tithing since most people can read and some even think for themselves.
Originally Posted by krp
Concerning Indians, pygmies, monks in a cave, jews, muslims, hindus... ect

God, JC, Holy spirit have a bunch of names in just the bible... and a bunch more they will answer to throughout history.

If there's just one God then that's who everyone has believed in... they just don't believe in someone elses version.

I was once told I wasn't a believer because I didn't capitalize the C in christ... and so it goes.

Jesus is inclusionary, he was also KISS in his small part of the bible... if you have ever felt you are part of something bigger than just yourself... you recognized and named God...

See ya there.

Kent


That's a very liberal view of religion as in it doesn't matter what you believe, all are saved. Atheists would agree that it doesn't matter what you believe, all return to oblivion.

But the Bible teaches... "And there is salvation in no one else; for there is no other name under heaven that has been given among men by which we must be saved." -- Acts 4:12

People who were never "given" the name may be judged by another standard, but there's no one like that on this thread.
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Longbob
Maybe I can narrow it down a bit. No man has ever gotten into heaven before Jesus according to Jesus himself.


He didn't say "No man comes to the Father before me"

He said, "No man comes to the Father, except through me."

If He did what the Bible suggests, and went to the souls in "Abraham's Bosom" then they still got there through him.

Like I said though, I don't have every answer. I don't know how God does all His stuff, if I did, I'd be God, and nobody wants that! shocked


No one has ever gone into heaven except the one who came from heaven--the Son of Man. John 3:13 NIV
Okay, it looks like crazy has come to town with the intent to stay. Time for me to exit, stage right.

Ron White was right...
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Longbob
Maybe I can narrow it down a bit. No man has ever gotten into heaven before Jesus according to Jesus himself.


He didn't say "No man comes to the Father before me"

He said, "No man comes to the Father, except through me."

If He did what the Bible suggests, and went to the souls in "Abraham's Bosom" then they still got there through him.

Like I said though, I don't have every answer. I don't know how God does all His stuff, if I did, I'd be God, and nobody wants that! shocked


No one has ever gone into heaven except the one who came from heaven--the Son of Man. John 3:13 NIV


Completely spoken in the past tense. I see no problem with that quote...

I see your purpose here now. It's not for discussion. No point in wasting my time with you. I wish you well, Longbob.
I realize you don't see a problem there. That is a microcosm of the greater problems with the Bible.

I have zero problems with one having faith in a higher being for whatever reason you choose like coping or general peace. Faith actually fascinates me. I cannot say that I wouldn't turn to Christ or something similar if I lost one of my children. Not sure how I would cope with that. A very close friend of mine lost her son and did exactly that. She had to think that he was in a better place otherwise she would have lost her mind (her words).

What perplexes me is that someone will quote me passages from a book that they are basing their deepest beliefs, but ignore the vile parts simultaneously.
Now we're back to a discussion. That, I can do.

You won't see me ignoring any of it, and I'll do my best to answer any questions or address any confusion you have in sincerity.

I see no problem with the verse you quoted because Jesus was speaking in the past tense. It, in no way, contradicts anything anybody has said on the topic.

No one has ever gone.... three very clear past tense words there...

Up until Jesus, nobody entered into Heaven. They were in "Abraham's Bosom" or whatever it was called.

Then, Jesus made a way for both them, and us. So, in fact, up to that point, "No one has ever gone into heaven except the one who came from heaven--the Son of Man."

Where is the confusion you have with this?
I'm sorry about your friends loss...

My parents lost a daughter 10 days before her 7th birthday before I was born.

That's a loss one never fully recovers from...

I can't imagine...

For me, it would likely have the opposite effect and cause a "crisis of faith".
Originally Posted by Longbob
Paradise hmmm.... No one would have know about that section of Sheol if Jesus hadn't had brought it up to the thief beside him.

If you step back an look at what is happening then you may see how religion via the Bible (or book of your choosing) is the most vile and effective form of control that man has ever created. It is several levels worse than politics since it preys on a person's deepest most vulnerable fears.

The bipolar God of the Old Testament wasn't as effective in creating the followers so they got a little more clever and came up with a newer angle of more loving form of a higher power, Jesus. This did appeal to a far larger audience and still is today.

To keep that appeal going, the churches really have to downplay the BS, murder, genocide, slavery, sexism, and racism in the Bible and do their best to focus on the messages of good and eternal hope. Otherwise it would be difficult to extort the 10% tithing since most people can read and some even think for themselves.


It all comes down to a simple question. Is God as described in the Bible real or not? If you don't believe God is real then the only purpose for your theory is to try to either convince yourself or others that the Bible is all a hoax perpetrated by men. In doing so you free yourself from all moral values you don't like, which is a powerful motivation.

I'm not going to try to convince you that God is real and the Bible is His inspired word. What I will argue is that you can't know if the God of the Bible is real or not. As a Christian I readily admit that I believe the Bible on the basis of faith and faith alone. What I will argue is that what you or anyone else believes about God is also based on faith and faith alone.

If I'm wrong I am most miserable among men as the Apostle Paul teaches, but if you are wrong, well enjoy this life.
Quote
You should learn more about Pantheism if you are going to argue against it.


Your statement reminds me that I was wrong. Thanks.

It reminded of Drs. Crick and Watson telling the world something to the effect that the DNA molecule is too complex to have arisen by evolution therefore spacemen brought it to this world. They called their theory "panspermia".
I really don't have a confusion with it. There is no real clarity of direction of your eternal being before the New Testament. There are parts that touch on it, but the writers realized that this needed to be addressed. They made it crystal clear that the singular path was the belief that Jesus died for your sins. No more no less.

That exposed the churches to a big problem of loss of power and control if they left it at that. All one has to do is to truly believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins. You could lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc...and you would share the same afterlife in Heaven with people like you that I consider very good people. Plus, there was no requirement to tithe. Heaven forbid!!!

Enter Pope Gregory I and the monetization of Purgatory. This was a great money maker for the Catholic church. Who in their right mind wouldn't want to get their loved ones unstuck from that place when it only cost money?
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
I'm sorry about your friends loss...

My parents lost a daughter 10 days before her 7th birthday before I was born.

That's a loss one never fully recovers from...

I can't imagine...

For me, it would likely have the opposite effect and cause a "crisis of faith".


Thank you.
I see real clarity of direction all throughout the Bible. Your history isn't entirely accurate, though some of your points are valid.

Quote
All one has to do is to truly believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins. You could lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc...and you would share the same afterlife in Heaven with people like you that I consider very good people. Plus, there was no requirement to tithe.


There has always been a requirement for repentance. That is, stop sinning and start obeying God. You couldn't lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc and share the same afterlife in Heaven with any person. You always had to repent.

It never was a thing to change a sinful act into a non-issue. Even Moses, though he had a relationship of faith with God and was forgiven, had to face his sin. God told him that he could never enter the promised land that he was taking the Israelites to.

The Bible talks about those people that were wrongfully killed as getting their justice. It talks about Judgement day being a day of weeping and gnashing of teeth. What it DOESN'T say is that that weeping and gnashing will be done only by those condemned to hell.

I fully believe, and can support with the Bible, that even those of us that have been forgiven of our sins, will have a lot of answering to do.

You're right about Pope Gregory I and Purgatory. No argument from me there.

The Old Testament certainly had the requirement of tithing, and the Jewish people that lived the Old Testament traditions certainly tithed. The New Testament has several mentions of tithing, and tithing in action. I don't know where you get that there was no requirement to tithe....

The great news (Gospel) is that Jesus can redeem even the most wretched amongst us. That there is hope for us all, but make no mistake, there is Justice for us all as well.

Lawyers joke that Justice is blind and carries a sword. Well, God has a sword too, and is just. The law is the law and not even the King is above the law.
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by tbear
American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?


Odd that this came up. I asked a christian freind of mine that some years ago. He assured me that they all burnt in hell because they did not know Christ. Seemed happy with the answer too....


Same goes for those in foreign lands who have never been exposed to Christianity through no fault of their own...they are all going to hell too...


Uhhhhhhhhhhh......


THAT answer never satisfied me, And God has NEVER revealed to me what ANYONE ELSE should believe , or do. But.... THIS is what took that question away for me:

What if, when Jesus said that He was the ONLY way to the Father, He was introducing Himself in the same way your garbageman or postman - whom you had never met - might introduce himself if he met you at a party, or in a bar, or someplace public? He might say that he had been hauling out your garbage, or delivering your mail, for years, but you never had seen him.

Jesus may have been saying;" This is my role. This has ALWAYS been my role. It's what I do, and have done, since the beginning of time. I'm not making a new rule, here, just introducing Myself and letting you know I'll still be in the same role after I leave and until I come back."

And....... I've never found any scripture that claims a person MUST know the agent who brings him to God.

God has always cleared away any confusion in my mind about me and Him. Sometimes He provides an answer and sometimes He just takes the question away.

He NEVER tells me about anyone else and Him.
There's a couple of question that have been bothering me for some time which probably don't have answers, but somebody touched on one a few pages back so I thought I'd bring them up. See if anybody wanted to take a stab at em.

The Bible teaches that God is the Alpha and Omega. He knows all and is omnipotent. It states many times that we are his creation and he knows everything about us. And since the Angels were his creation, he must know everything about them as well. The following verses come to mind.


Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations. Jeremiah 1:5

But even the very hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not therefore: ye are of more value than many sparrows. Luke 12:7

If this is true, then God must also know what his creation's choices and actions will be thru time, which leads me to my questions.

1) Why was Lucifer and his followers created in the first place.? God had to know when he created them that they would turn out to be bad apples. It doesn't make sense that an all powerful being would intentionally create something that he would later prove to bite him in the ass, so to speak, especially since he knows they will NEVER turn from the Dark Side and will eventually end up in Hell anyway.

2) When God created man, he implemented the animal sacrifice system that was the gold standard for generations. But at some "time" (and I don't fully understand this either) God determined that animal sacrifices weren't cutting it any longer, so he sacrificed his Son for our sins as the ultimate sacrifice. If God knew this would happen, why didn't God cut to the chase generations earlier with Jesus, like before Abraham, instead of making man go thru the animal sacrifice bit for so long.?

Originally Posted by Longbob
I realize you don't see a problem there. That is a microcosm of the greater problems with the Bible.

I have zero problems with one having faith in a higher being for whatever reason you choose like coping or general peace. Faith actually fascinates me. I cannot say that I wouldn't turn to Christ or something similar if I lost one of my children. Not sure how I would cope with that. A very close friend of mine lost her son and did exactly that. She had to think that he was in a better place otherwise she would have lost her mind (her words).

What perplexes me is that someone will quote me passages from a book that they are basing their deepest beliefs, but ignore the vile parts simultaneously.


Longbob
A lot of the old testement is difficult for me.I am still learning and getting to know God and it's been 17 years since I was saved.I won't say that any scripture is false but when only looked at on the surface it does sometimes give a false impression.All scripture must be interpreted with other scripture.It also must be interpreted according to the revealtion of that time frame.For instance when Jesus would say"You have heard it said,an eye for an eye,but I say unto you,love your enemies...." Then there is sometimes a chrisis of translation.If you continue in his word,you will know the truth,and the truth will make you free.

Given the small ammount of space and time available here,I can only say that to know God requires more than just a quick look.It also requires a relationship in which you can even ask God what he ment when he said.......It's a life long commitment.

I like your approach curdog! Of course it's possible to pick it apart by doing some Bible thumping, but you've really touched on something that was important for me to grasp.

I was VERY religious in my younger years. I mean, I made God my life. I would preach (seriously, at 16 I was preaching to seasoned Youth Leaders about doing youth ministry), I would evangelize (saw 600 teens come to Jesus one night near Buffalo), I mean I went all out.

God did a lot of pretty amazing things in that time.

I eventually was invited into full time ministry. If you have done any Bible reading, you'll notice that anytime somebody starts to follow Jesus, He does some house cleaning on their character. I discovered that my character was a mess. It was so bad in fact that I pulled a Jonah and ran from God. That's actually sort of how I ended up in the Army.

I learned that I was the biggest hypocrite ever! I would always preach about the difference between Religion and Relationship, but what I learned is that I had a religion and no relationship.

This made me really question if God, in fact, could actually be known. Was a relationship possible or was it all religion?

I remembered the verse from Proverbs that said, "Lean not on your own understanding, but in all your ways, acknowledge God, and He will direct your path."

Lean not on my own understanding? Alright, game on! I rejected anything and everything I "knew" about God. I wasn't going to use any of those means to approach Him. If He was real, then He would keep His word.

No more Bible reading, no more Church, no more praying, no nothin'! I was done.

I got to thinking, that if God was real, and knowable, and if His Bible was true, and we were made in His likeness, then we should be able to know Him just like we know each other.

So, I took it to a real juvenile level. I was mad that there was no relationship. I was mad that I was duped by a religion. I was mad at myself for being a fool, and if there was a God, then I was going to give Him a piece of my mind. I was going to prove He didn't exist once and for all to my satisfaction.

I glared toward the heavens and said, quite aloud actually, and none too politely, "If you're so real, and knowable, then you have likes and dislikes. So, what's your favorite color!?"

I knew I had this God thing cornered then. If He was to answer it, then He was real. Surely if he was real, and created everything and said everything was good, that He'd not have a favorite color. That would be ridiculous...

I wasn't prepared for what happened. It wasn't instantly. As a matter of fact I think it was a few days later, but I got an answer. An unmistakable answer, and it changed my life.

The picture you paint of meeting Jesus at a party or in a bar fits in line with my understanding of Him. He's real, and He enjoys life. Thanks for sharing, curdog.

Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
There's a couple of question that have been bothering me for some time which probably don't have answers, but somebody touched on one a few pages back so I thought I'd bring them up. See if anybody wanted to take a stab at em.

The Bible teaches that God is the Alpha and Omega. He knows all and is omnipotent. It states many times that we are his creation and he knows everything about us. And since the Angels were his creation, he must know everything about them as well. The following verses come to mind.


Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations. Jeremiah 1:5

But even the very hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not therefore: ye are of more value than many sparrows. Luke 12:7

If this is true, then God must also know what his creation's choices and actions will be thru time, which leads me to my questions.

1) Why was Lucifer and his followers created in the first place.? God had to know when he created them that they would turn out to be bad apples. It doesn't make sense that an all powerful being would intentionally create something that he would later prove to bite him in the ass, so to speak, especially since he knows they will NEVER turn from the Dark Side and will eventually end up in Hell anyway.

2) When God created man, he implemented the animal sacrifice system that was the gold standard for generations. But at some "time" (and I don't fully understand this either) God determined that animal sacrifices weren't cutting it any longer, so he sacrificed his Son for our sins as the ultimate sacrifice. If God knew this would happen, why didn't God cut to the chase generations earlier with Jesus, like before Abraham, instead of making man go thru the animal sacrifice bit for so long.?



Deerwhacker, I'd love the opportunity to address your questions, as they are stellar one's and one's that I too have had.

I have to run to class right now (World History from 1500 to Present) but when I return, I'll give it a shot, if you haven't received a satisfactory answer before then. smile
??? So what's his favorite color..?
wink
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
I see real clarity of direction all throughout the Bible. Your history isn't entirely accurate, though some of your points are valid.

Quote
All one has to do is to truly believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins. You could lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc...and you would share the same afterlife in Heaven with people like you that I consider very good people. Plus, there was no requirement to tithe.


There has always been a requirement for repentance. That is, stop sinning and start obeying God. You couldn't lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc and share the same afterlife in Heaven with any person. You always had to repent.

It never was a thing to change a sinful act into a non-issue. Even Moses, though he had a relationship of faith with God and was forgiven, had to face his sin. God told him that he could never enter the promised land that he was taking the Israelites to.

The Bible talks about those people that were wrongfully killed as getting their justice. It talks about Judgement day being a day of weeping and gnashing of teeth. What it DOESN'T say is that that weeping and gnashing will be done only by those condemned to hell.

I fully believe, and can support with the Bible, that even those of us that have been forgiven of our sins, will have a lot of answering to do.

You're right about Pope Gregory I and Purgatory. No argument from me there.

The Old Testament certainly had the requirement of tithing, and the Jewish people that lived the Old Testament traditions certainly tithed. The New Testament has several mentions of tithing, and tithing in action. I don't know where you get that there was no requirement to tithe....

The great news (Gospel) is that Jesus can redeem even the most wretched amongst us. That there is hope for us all, but make no mistake, there is Justice for us all as well.

Lawyers joke that Justice is blind and carries a sword. Well, God has a sword too, and is just. The law is the law and not even the King is above the law.


Once you repent doesn't mean you are no longer a sinner. Once a sinner always a sinner even if you are a repented sinner. Sinners still get into Heaven according to the New Testament once they accepted Jesus.

Tithing is not a requirement to get into Heaven.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Longbob
Paradise hmmm.... No one would have know about that section of Sheol if Jesus hadn't had brought it up to the thief beside him.

If you step back an look at what is happening then you may see how religion via the Bible (or book of your choosing) is the most vile and effective form of control that man has ever created. It is several levels worse than politics since it preys on a person's deepest most vulnerable fears.

The bipolar God of the Old Testament wasn't as effective in creating the followers so they got a little more clever and came up with a newer angle of more loving form of a higher power, Jesus. This did appeal to a far larger audience and still is today.

To keep that appeal going, the churches really have to downplay the BS, murder, genocide, slavery, sexism, and racism in the Bible and do their best to focus on the messages of good and eternal hope. Otherwise it would be difficult to extort the 10% tithing since most people can read and some even think for themselves.


It all comes down to a simple question. Is God as described in the Bible real or not? If you don't believe God is real then the only purpose for your theory is to try to either convince yourself or others that the Bible is all a hoax perpetrated by men. In doing so you free yourself from all moral values you don't like, which is a powerful motivation.

I'm not going to try to convince you that God is real and the Bible is His inspired word. What I will argue is that you can't know if the God of the Bible is real or not. As a Christian I readily admit that I believe the Bible on the basis of faith and faith alone. What I will argue is that what you or anyone else believes about God is also based on faith and faith alone.

If I'm wrong I am most miserable among men as the Apostle Paul teaches, but if you are wrong, well enjoy this life.


The God described in the Bible is petty and bipolar. I wouldn't doubt there is a higher being, but the Bible does a piss poor job in verifying that. There is as much missing in the Bible as there is bad stuff within.

Who said I need this line of thinking to relieve myself of moral values. It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion. It would be very non Christian like of you to think other wise.

I am enjoying my life as it stands and don't expect anything beyond what I do on this earth. Which could be viewed as a more moral and honest existence. If I believe this is it, the big show so to speak. Then I better not murder, steal, etc...because I am being judged now and must live with the consequences.

But if I murder, steal, etc... in this life and then find Christ in prison which turns out to be false. Which scenario is now the more moral?
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by krp
Concerning Indians, pygmies, monks in a cave, jews, muslims, hindus... ect

God, JC, Holy spirit have a bunch of names in just the bible... and a bunch more they will answer to throughout history.

If there's just one God then that's who everyone has believed in... they just don't believe in someone elses version.

I was once told I wasn't a believer because I didn't capitalize the C in christ... and so it goes.

Jesus is inclusionary, he was also KISS in his small part of the bible... if you have ever felt you are part of something bigger than just yourself... you recognized and named God...

See ya there.

Kent


That's a very liberal view of religion as in it doesn't matter what you believe, all are saved. Atheists would agree that it doesn't matter what you believe, all return to oblivion.

But the Bible teaches... "And there is salvation in no one else; for there is no other name under heaven that has been given among men by which we must be saved." -- Acts 4:12

People who were never "given" the name may be judged by another standard, but there's no one like that on this thread.


That's because I don't follow religion... I believe Jesus was a real person and who he said he was. I also believe he is all things to all people...

I believe he said what he wanted to when he was here... I can't describe who he is in his totality and neither can Paul or Paul by default through Luke. I could take Jesus literally but he never wrote anything down... obviously on purpose.

I don't believe he forgot some stuff and had to make addendum later through men.

I appreciate other's perpecive and inspiration... but one person or groups gospel isn't the end all to God.

Kent
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
I see real clarity of direction all throughout the Bible. Your history isn't entirely accurate, though some of your points are valid.

Quote
All one has to do is to truly believe that Jesus was the son of God and died for your sins. You could lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc...and you would share the same afterlife in Heaven with people like you that I consider very good people. Plus, there was no requirement to tithe.


There has always been a requirement for repentance. That is, stop sinning and start obeying God. You couldn't lie, cheat, steal, murder, etc and share the same afterlife in Heaven with any person. You always had to repent.

It never was a thing to change a sinful act into a non-issue. Even Moses, though he had a relationship of faith with God and was forgiven, had to face his sin. God told him that he could never enter the promised land that he was taking the Israelites to.

The Bible talks about those people that were wrongfully killed as getting their justice. It talks about Judgement day being a day of weeping and gnashing of teeth. What it DOESN'T say is that that weeping and gnashing will be done only by those condemned to hell.

I fully believe, and can support with the Bible, that even those of us that have been forgiven of our sins, will have a lot of answering to do.

You're right about Pope Gregory I and Purgatory. No argument from me there.

The Old Testament certainly had the requirement of tithing, and the Jewish people that lived the Old Testament traditions certainly tithed. The New Testament has several mentions of tithing, and tithing in action. I don't know where you get that there was no requirement to tithe....

The great news (Gospel) is that Jesus can redeem even the most wretched amongst us. That there is hope for us all, but make no mistake, there is Justice for us all as well.

Lawyers joke that Justice is blind and carries a sword. Well, God has a sword too, and is just. The law is the law and not even the King is above the law.


Once you repent doesn't mean you are no longer a sinner. Once a sinner always a sinner even if you are a repented sinner. Sinners still get into Heaven according to the New Testament once they accepted Jesus.

Tithing is not a requirement to get into Heaven.


That takes us to the "once saved always saved" debate. I'll get back to ya on this, as it's a good one, but I really gotta run.

You're right about tithing as it pertains to entrance to heaven!

Good discussion, Longbob!
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
??? So what's his favorite color..?
wink


I'll fill ya in in about 2 hours, after my class. Promise!
I am enjoying it too, Hug. Just a little clarity so I don't come across as some bitter Christian hater or something. I work with some of the finest people on the planet and they are all Christians. I will risk a guess that the Christians that have responded in this thread would be in that same category, IMO.

There have been several times that one of them has said "I am surprised you are not a Christian" based on my moral belief system. I have always taken that as a compliment based on the intent of the speaker. The counter of that comment that I could say is "I am surprised you are." But that would not be the appropriate comment nor how I feel.

Being moral does not make you a Christian nor does being a Christian make you moral.
Originally Posted by Longbob
I realize you don't see a problem there. That is a microcosm of the greater problems with the Bible.

I have zero problems with one having faith in a higher being for whatever reason you choose like coping or general peace. Faith actually fascinates me. I cannot say that I wouldn't turn to Christ or something similar if I lost one of my children. Not sure how I would cope with that. A very close friend of mine lost her son and did exactly that. She had to think that he was in a better place otherwise she would have lost her mind (her words).

What perplexes me is that someone will quote me passages from a book that they are basing their deepest beliefs, but ignore the vile parts simultaneously.


I'm only going to address the last paragraph because I've been perplexed by that as well. I honestly never encountered that behavior anywhere except this forum.

I wouldn't put up with a muslim trying to use the koran to "prove" the koran, and a christian who tries the same tactic has just lost his audience as far as I'm concerned.

The bible can't be literally true. The fact that there are so many translations compounds the problem for a man trying to "ground his faith" on the book.So...that never worked for me.

Fairly late in life, I realized that I had never been allowed to NOT believe in God [or Jesus]. My well meaning old aunt that raised me had drug me to a little "Holiness" church until I was big enough to escape.

I run across folks who have never "dared to not believe". I wonder how strong their faith is gonna be when the rubber [as it always must, at some point] hits the road. Mine sure as hell failed me.

I had to surrender to the "Creator of the Universe",who ever he was, leaving behind my "childhood Jesus."

Then, the REAL, LIVING, Jesus introduced Himself to me as both the "Creator of the Universe", and the "Jesus of the Gospels." He did it in a way that was personal to me and left no room for doubt.

I don't know that I've met the Jesus of Paul's letters yet. I may be too dumb for that.

I couldn't help recalling from the Bible how John the Baptist, who probably knew Jesus as a third cousin growing up, and Peter, who had been His companion for a couple or three years and "knew" Him well, BOTH were "introduced" to a Jesus different from the one they already knew.

Jesus told Peter that "Flesh and blood had not revealed it to him, but the Father had."

As far as I'm concerned, this ability of the Father to reveal Jesus to humans is actually what Jesus founded His "church" on.

Not Peter [as the Romans teach]

Not a statement of faith [as the Protestants teach]

I've found nothing in Scripture to contradict my view, but this forum is certainly the place I'd go if I wanted someone to play "devil's advocate".

Of course, my "view" leaves no place for priests or preachers, and places no premium on intelligence or reading comprehension.

Hell........ even a child can understand it ! grin
Nice post Curdog.
Posted By: TF49 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
From LongBob:

"The God described in the Bible is petty and bipolar. I wouldn't doubt there is a higher being, but the Bible does a piss poor job in verifying that. There is as much missing in the Bible as there is bad stuff within.

Who said I need this line of thinking to relieve myself of moral values. It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion."


The problem with this is that one is only "as good as he wants to be." This is a problem common to most, in fact I have it as an major issue. ONLY AS GOOD AS... I.... WANT TO BE. This way I only have to satisfy myself and not some external deity. If one's moral standard comes from within oneself, you don't know what you'll end up with. I suspect that most Muslim suicide bombers do truly believe and believe that their own "internal moral code" justifies their act.

I suspect that ALL of us struggle with this in some way.

All the best,

tf
Originally Posted by Longbob
The God described in the Bible is petty and bipolar. I wouldn't doubt there is a higher being, but the Bible does a piss poor job in verifying that. There is as much missing in the Bible as there is bad stuff within.


Being I answered the question that I do believe the God of the Bible exists and the Bible is His inspired word I have taken the time to do a bit of study.

The Old Testament was written in ancient Hebrew, which did not use vowels in the written form. It would be somewhat like reading and entire book written in abbreviations. The reader would get the correct meaning if they knew the subject, culture, and nomenclature well, but others would have a hard time figuring it out.

Add to that the fact that ancient Hebrew didn't have a distinction between causative and permissive verbs, and thus, a statement that "God caused some disaster" and the statement that "God permitted some disaster" would be written the same in ancient Hebrew. Much of the OT has been translated assuming the causative, but with the revelation of the NT, I believe it should have been translated assuming the permissive.

In human terms you might think badly of some parent who caused their child to fail, but cite tough love if you find that they permitted their child to fail.

What you think you know about God's character from the Old Testament is based on ignorance and much of it is not even your own.

Originally Posted by Longbob
Who said I need this line of thinking to relieve myself of moral values. It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion. It would be very non Christian like of you to think other wise.


Values you select or make up yourself may be some "code" you live by, but they are not moral values. If moral values were up to the individual then everyone is living a perfectly moral life. Moral values are imposed by one greater than yourself, which is God. Dismissing the Bible as a hoax frees you from judging yourself by God's values.

Originally Posted by Longbob
I am enjoying my life as it stands and don't expect anything beyond what I do on this earth. Which could be viewed as a more moral and honest existence. If I believe this is it, the big show so to speak. Then I better not murder, steal, etc...because I am being judged now and must live with the consequences.


You can believe what you want and you may be right or you may be wrong just I may be right or wrong. Pascal considered this. If I'm wrong and there is no God, then I've denied myself the freedom to do as I want in this life, but death is nothing more than peaceful oblivion. If you are wrong, then you are free to do as you want in this life, but death is not oblivion and you will stand judgment before the one you have call bipolar and without the benefit of what Jesus did for believers.

I am also being judged now by human law as all people are. The difference between human law and God's law is that with human law there is no penalty if you're not caught, which leads many to break human laws and end up in prison. For those who find Christ there it's the best thing that ever happened to them and they are far more likely to stay out of prison in the future. Is that not better than living a life of crime regardless of the truth about God?
Watchman Nee told of a Chinese tad who went to a pagan shrine with his mother. Looking at the carved, weathered, cracked wooden idol, he theorized "That thing's not a god!"

He stepped outside, looked up at the sky, and said something to the efffect that "If there's a god, he's up there somewhere. That's the god whom I want to know."

When Christian missionaries came along years later and told him about God in the Bible, he exclaimed "That's the god I know!"

He also told of another man on a small island where paper was almost as rare as Mars rovers. When the went brought a scrap of paper along the ground, he picked-up a fragment of a page from the New Testament and read part of the passage about the gifts of the Spirit. Healing caught his attention. "That's what I'd rather do. How � ?"

When Christian missionaries came along years later, he was quietly going around ministering healing � by the Holy Spirit, in the Name of Jesus.

By the sovereign work of the Holy Spirit � not by reading the Bible or by listening to preachers � both men had come to know God.
I'm obliged.
Originally Posted by TF49
From LongBob:

"The God described in the Bible is petty and bipolar. I wouldn't doubt there is a higher being, but the Bible does a piss poor job in verifying that. There is as much missing in the Bible as there is bad stuff within.

Who said I need this line of thinking to relieve myself of moral values. It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion."


The problem with this is that one is only "as good as he wants to be." This is a problem common to most, in fact I have it as an major issue. ONLY AS GOOD AS... I.... WANT TO BE. This way I only have to satisfy myself and not some external deity. If one's moral standard comes from within oneself, you don't know what you'll end up with. I suspect that most Muslim suicide bombers do truly believe and believe that their own "internal moral code" justifies their act.

I suspect that ALL of us struggle with this in some way.

All the best,

tf


You omitted and important paragraph from my quote which addresses your part about me being "ONLY AS GOOD AS... I.... WANT TO BE."

Here is the paragraph:

I am enjoying my life as it stands and don't expect anything beyond what I do on this earth. Which could be viewed as a more moral and honest existence. If I believe this is it, the big show so to speak. Then I better not murder, steal, etc...because I am being judged now and must live with the consequences.
Would it be fair to say that you answer to your own conscience?


I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, just wondering if there is more to your philosophy of life than that?
This one paragraph of yours says volumes at how you view me as a non Christian. It states that I cannot be moral unless I am a Christian. Keep thinking that.

"Values you select or make up yourself may be some "code" you live by, but they are not moral values. If moral values were up to the individual then everyone is living a perfectly moral life. Moral values are imposed by one greater than yourself, which is God. Dismissing the Bible as a hoax frees you from judging yourself by God's values. "
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Would it be fair to say that you answer to your own conscience?


I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, just wondering if there is more to your philosophy of life than that?


Yes, it would be fair to say that I answer to my own conscience, but not exclusively. I also answer to the ones around me in some form or fashion. And to a greater degree than a repentant murderer or thief, IMO.
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by tbear
American Indians, Eskimos, & many aboriginal people existed well before the birth of Christ. So thousands of years ago people with no knowledge of Christianity should have transported them selves where?


Odd that this came up. I asked a christian freind of mine that some years ago. He assured me that they all burnt in hell because they did not know Christ. Seemed happy with the answer too....


Same goes for those in foreign lands who have never been exposed to Christianity through no fault of their own...they are all going to hell too...


Uhhhhhhhhhhh......


People like that really tick me off. My Bible tells me about a loving God.

One guy like your friend does way more harm by their closed minded ass hole opinions than a thousand can do teaching a loving God.

Read Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John and you will fing the God I serve.
I'm an ordained Christian Pastor who wants more and more to head in the direction of missions. In 2003 I turned down a chance for missions in Zambia. Wasn't ready. Oh to have that chance back again. The Bible says to wait on the Lord and that is what I'll do. smile
Posted By: bea175 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Lets put it this way i don't go to Church, i don't live the Church Life Style, i cuss and swear, I have Carnival Knowledge about women on a daily basis and could kill anything that walks and not lose a min sleep over it. My question is, does this qualify me as a Christian or just a good ole country redneck boy?
I want to know more about this carnival knowledge of women. I think there is a double entendre there somewhere. laugh
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by amax155
Only thru Grace.

And obedience.



So true. You can't have one without the other.
Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by ColdBore
And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.


Interesting post..I am not a believer, but science still can't really explain complex life nor can it explain self awareness/consciousness in humans. That we have "something" that differentiates us from even high order animals such as [bleep] ect is undiniable.

Personally, I think that some point in the past, humans evolved this self awareness/consciousness and it resulted in them having a burning desire to learn about, and understand the world around them.

Initially, that resulted in things being explained in terms of superstitions and in what we would term the supernatural. Eventually as our understanding and knowledge grew, it evolved into two seperate areas of quest, one being religion and the other being science.

Some folks lean more to more than the other, while for others, they are both equally meaningful.

Generally though, in most society's, as science expands its knoweldge, religious beliefs dwindle..
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
There's a couple of question that have been bothering me for some time which probably don't have answers, but somebody touched on one a few pages back so I thought I'd bring them up. See if anybody wanted to take a stab at em.

The Bible teaches that God is the Alpha and Omega. He knows all and is omnipotent. It states many times that we are his creation and he knows everything about us. And since the Angels were his creation, he must know everything about them as well. The following verses come to mind.


Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations. Jeremiah 1:5

But even the very hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not therefore: ye are of more value than many sparrows. Luke 12:7

If this is true, then God must also know what his creation's choices and actions will be thru time, which leads me to my questions.

1) Why was Lucifer and his followers created in the first place.? God had to know when he created them that they would turn out to be bad apples. It doesn't make sense that an all powerful being would intentionally create something that he would later prove to bite him in the ass, so to speak, especially since he knows they will NEVER turn from the Dark Side and will eventually end up in Hell anyway.

2) When God created man, he implemented the animal sacrifice system that was the gold standard for generations. But at some "time" (and I don't fully understand this either) God determined that animal sacrifices weren't cutting it any longer, so he sacrificed his Son for our sins as the ultimate sacrifice. If God knew this would happen, why didn't God cut to the chase generations earlier with Jesus, like before Abraham, instead of making man go thru the animal sacrifice bit for so long.?



Lucifer and his fallen angels didn't "bite God in the ass" as God has full control over them and uses them to his own ends and he foreknew their fall. They are the opposing force necessary for God to test mankind with. If there were no evil there would be nothing to choose from. God only wants those by his side in eternity that have chosen him.



Animal sacrifice was to teach us that "without the shedding of innocent blood there can be no remission of sins". As the word says " The law was our schoolmaster to lead us to Christ". Animal sacrifices never did "cut it" but the correlation between the "lamb without blemish" and Jesus Christ being God's lamb were made understood. Without Christ no flesh was saved and before Christ there was "spiritual prison" the Word says and when Christ descended into hell he preached to those in spiritual prison offering them Heaven and eternal life.
That still doesn�t address the idea that an omnipotent, omnipresent god would know how it turned out and not need to test anybody. Reconciling preordination with free will has had folks doing back flips ever since the first time somebody actually thought about it.
YES
Originally Posted by billhilly
That still doesn�t address the idea that an omnipotent, omnipresent god would know how it turned out and not need to test anybody. Reconciling preordination with free will has had folks doing back flips ever since the first time somebody actually thought about it.



no one is preordained to heaven or hell. God tests us all even though he knows what our choice will be. The point is it will be our choice that puts us in heaven or hell.
Posted By: Firth Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by billhilly
That still doesn�t address the idea that an omnipotent, omnipresent god would know how it turned out and not need to test anybody. Reconciling preordination with free will has had folks doing back flips ever since the first time somebody actually thought about it.



no one is preordained to heaven or hell. God tests us all even though he knows what our choice will be. The point is it will be our choice that puts us in heaven or hell.


In addition, we learn from the testing. You can only learn so much without being put through the wringer.
God created us with the knowledge of what our choices would be though right? How is that different than preordination?
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by ColdBore
And medical science (which I can see, touch, and feel) teaches us that when the heart stops beating, and the lights go out, you're done. No more brain activity, no more "spirit", no more anything doing anything forever.

And your body rots. That, again, I can see and verify. And that pile of decomposing flesh isn't going on any trip to visit anybody or any being.

Show me a soul. What's it look like? I can show you a heart, and blood, and a brain. And I can show you what happens to them when you die. Not when you euphemistically "cease to exist in your current state on this planet", or some other flowery stuff. You die. And rot. And that's the cold hard reality of life and death.


Interesting post..I am not a believer, but science still can't really explain complex life nor can it explain self awareness/consciousness in humans. That we have "something" that differentiates us from even high order animals such as [bleep] ect is undiniable.

Personally, I think that some point in the past, humans evolved this self awareness/consciousness and it resulted in them having a burning desire to learn about, and understand the world around them.

Initially, that resulted in things being explained in terms of superstitions and in what we would term the supernatural. Eventually as our understanding and knowledge grew, it evolved into two seperate areas of quest, one being religion and the other being science.

Some folks lean more to more than the other, while for others, they are both equally meaningful.

Generally though, in most society's, as science expands its knoweldge, religious beliefs dwindle..

1 Cor 1:18 For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God. 19 For it is written:

�I will destroy the wisdom of the wise,
And bring to nothing the understanding of the prudent.�
20 Where is the wise? Where is the scribe? Where is the disputer of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of this world? 21 For since, in the wisdom of God, the world through wisdom did not know God, it pleased God through the foolishness of the message preached to save those who believe. 22 For Jews request a sign, and Greeks seek after wisdom; 23 but we preach Christ crucified, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the Greeks foolishness, 24 but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. 25 Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men.

Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by moosemike

no one is preordained to heaven or hell. God tests us all even though he knows what our choice will be. The point is it will be our choice that puts us in heaven or hell.


I have no faith. If God really did create me, why did he not create me with faith?

You can only have a *choice* between heaven and hell if you have faith and believe..If you believe in these things and then reject God, as say Satanists do, then it makes sense..Otherwise not..

Same for all the folk who since the start of time who have never heard of God, or who were born and died before Jesus came to earth and did his thing..They had no "choice"..

Ditto for babies and infants who die while still very young..The NT clearly states the criteria for going to Heaven in John 3:16 and similar verses concerning being "saved" as Christians term it..Little ones who die early in life simply can't be saved, so by default therefore go to Hell?

Th Bible and Religion are the creations of man and as such their logic and content are flawed..

Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Dons99

1 Cor 1:18 For the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing, but to us who are being saved it is the power of God. 19 For it is written:

�I will destroy the wisdom of the wise,
And bring to nothing the understanding of the prudent.�
20 Where is the wise? Where is the scribe? Where is the disputer of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of this world? 21 For since, in the wisdom of God, the world through wisdom did not know God, it pleased God through the foolishness of the message preached to save those who believe. 22 For Jews request a sign, and Greeks seek after wisdom; 23 but we preach Christ crucified, to the Jews a stumbling block and to the Greeks foolishness, 24 but to those who are called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. 25 Because the foolishness of God is wiser than men, and the weakness of God is stronger than men.


Just the writing of men..no more substance than any other work of fiction..
Flawed to the point of being absurd.
I'm not a very good one but I am one.
Interesting thread....I am not a church-going man, but I was born and raised a Roman Catholic. Which is pretty much the most strict of all christian religions.

I have a good friend....Rev. Larry Schwenk....The pastor of the Auburn Church of GOD. He and I have gotten into several theological discussions. He believes in God, I believe in Science. He believes in the Immaculate Conception...I do not. He believes that we will go to one of 3 places upon our demise......Heaven, Purgatory, or Hell depending upon our actions during life. I Know I am going 6 feet in the ground.

I have a Bible right here on my coffee table...I have read it. Several times. Interesting book.

It's not that I don't believe in God....It's just that I have to believe in what my senses tell me. The only way I can fully believe in God is to actually SEE him. And from everything I have read, both in the Bible and from other sources, I will only see him after I am dead.

So, If ever I see the man....I'll believe....But,I won't tell nobody....'cause I will be worm food at that point.
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by moosemike

no one is preordained to heaven or hell. God tests us all even though he knows what our choice will be. The point is it will be our choice that puts us in heaven or hell.


I have no faith. If God really did create me, why did he not create me with faith?

You can only have a *choice* between heaven and hell if you have faith and believe..If you believe in these things and then reject God, as say Satanists do, then it makes sense..Otherwise not..

Same for all the folk who since the start of time who have never heard of God, or who were born and died before Jesus came to earth and did his thing..They had no "choice"..

Ditto for babies and infants who die while still very young..The NT clearly states the criteria for going to Heaven in John 3:16 and similar verses concerning being "saved" as Christians term it..Little ones who die early in life simply can't be saved, so by default therefore go to Hell?

Th Bible and Religion are the creations of man and as such their logic and content are flawed..

Pete, give Him a try. You got nothing to loose.

"And you will seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart". Jeremiah 29:13

Originally Posted by Sykotik

It's not that I don't believe in God....It's just that I have to believe in what my senses tell me.


That's understandable.

How does your senses reconcile the fact that a swirling ball of gas, which later solidified into a rock called the planet earth, came to produce life,...which not only was able to replicate, but also became a self aware creature with the ability to harness the resources contained in that rock called Earth,..and form them into a machine which was able to carry those self aware, life bearing creatures to the moon?

To assume that human life just "happened",...you must be able to make a leap of faith tantamount to believing that a bunch of letters were thrown up into the air and formed a Collegiate Websters dictionary when they landed.

Discounting intelligent design is too far out there for me to imagine.

This body that I ride around in didn't just spontaneously happen.

It was caused.
Got evidence for that?
Evidence of a human being?

Yeah,...It's everywhere.
Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Dons99
Pete, give Him a try. You got nothing to loose.

"And you will seek Me and find Me, when you search for Me with all your heart". Jeremiah 29:13


You can't will yourself to believe something abstract...Now if I were to see a miracle or experience something like Paul did, maybe that would change me..

On the other hand, I have to question whether I would follow a God that repeated committed genocide on his creation simply because people choose to exercise the free will he gave them..

In more earthly circumstances, if a world leader ruled / acted like God of the OT, he'd be branded a dictator/tyrant along the lines of Stalin or Hitler..

In fact if you believe in the OT, God has killed more Jews over the years than Hitler did, and to cap it all, when Hitler did come along, God then allowed him to commit genocide against his so called "Chosen People"..
Originally Posted by Pete E
Now if I were to see a miracle


Take a breath,....view something with your eyes,...pick up something with your hand,...romance a woman,...

You're experiencing a miracle.

All of the above came from virtually nothing?,...a ball of gas?,.. a rock?

That's not a miracle?
Evolution.....It took a long time, and is still ongoing.
Posted By: TF49 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
LongBob - Yes, I omitted that paragraph but no I did not miss the point. You consider the consequences - perhaps only of society judging you. You decide what you can get away with and what you cannot. And decide to be as good as you want to be. You made my point.

TF
Evolution is by design.

A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.
Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
Originally Posted by Bristoe

You're experiencing a miracle.


Years ago, thunder and lightening were attributed to various gods.

Today science explains then for what they are.

Scenic can't explain everything, and sometimes gets it wrong, but just because our current level of knowledge falls short, doesn't mean the next logical explanation is religious mumbo jumbo ..

Religion is the human mined as a closed book..science is the ongoing quest for knowledge and the expansion of the human mind..
Originally Posted by TF49
LongBob - Yes, I omitted that paragraph but no I did not miss the point. You consider the consequences - perhaps only of society judging you. You decide what you can get away with and what you cannot. And decide to be as good as you want to be. You made my point.

TF


And you made my point that you can decide to be as evil or bad as you want just as long as you accept Jesus as your savior before you die then you get the ticket into Heaven. Pretty lame in my opinion.
This chunk of rock did not spontaneously evolve into a human being. However, Life did begin on this planet....Nobody knows how....But it did gain a foothold Billions of years ago. And started to evolve.

We, Homo Sapiens sapiens are just the current pinnacle of that evolution.
Originally Posted by Pete E
Originally Posted by Bristoe

You're experiencing a miracle.


Years ago, thunder and lightening were attributed to various gods.

Today science explains then for what they are.

Scenic can't explain everything, and sometimes gets it wrong, but just because our current level of knowledge falls short, doesn't mean the next logical explanation is religious mumbo jumbo ..

Religion is the human mined as a closed book..science is the ongoing quest for knowledge and the expansion of the human mind..


If you choose to believe that a chunk of rock became *you* with no help from intelligent design,...it's your option,...

,...but I'll never be able to put the pieces together in a fashion that satisfies me.

If I strain real hard,..I *may* be able to accept the fact that a single celled amoeba was spawned from that piece of rock,...but the life force that caused it to evolve into a self aware being was planned.

Human beings didn't just *happen*.

*Life*,...*any* life,...is an incredible thing,,....even a blade of grass is a miracle.

There's a lot more going on that you can conceptualize.

To assume that all of this just *happened* is a bug's perspective,....and even the fuggin' bug is a miracle.
Originally Posted by Sykotik
.Nobody knows how


And you won't.

Essentially,...you're a bug,...we're all bugs,..

A bug will never understand how he came to be a bug,...
Originally Posted by Bristoe
Originally Posted by Sykotik
.Nobody knows how


And you won't.

Essentially,...you're a bug,...we're all bugs,..

A bug will never understand how he came to be a bug,...


Exactly grin
Originally Posted by Bristoe
Evolution is by design.

A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.


Evolution is mans' explanation for what God did.
Originally Posted by Sykotik
This chunk of rock did not spontaneously evolve into a human being. However, Life did begin on this planet....Nobody knows how....But it did gain a foothold Billions of years ago. And started to evolve.

We, Homo Sapiens sapiens are just the current pinnacle of that evolution.


And what did you evolve from?
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd


And what did you evolve from?


Apes......just like you did.
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
There's a couple of question that have been bothering me for some time which probably don't have answers, but somebody touched on one a few pages back so I thought I'd bring them up. See if anybody wanted to take a stab at em.

The Bible teaches that God is the Alpha and Omega. He knows all and is omnipotent. It states many times that we are his creation and he knows everything about us. And since the Angels were his creation, he must know everything about them as well. The following verses come to mind.


Before I formed thee in the belly I knew thee; and before thou camest forth out of the womb I sanctified thee, and I ordained thee a prophet unto the nations. Jeremiah 1:5

But even the very hairs of your head are all numbered. Fear not therefore: ye are of more value than many sparrows. Luke 12:7

If this is true, then God must also know what his creation's choices and actions will be thru time, which leads me to my questions.

1) Why was Lucifer and his followers created in the first place.? God had to know when he created them that they would turn out to be bad apples. It doesn't make sense that an all powerful being would intentionally create something that he would later prove to bite him in the ass, so to speak, especially since he knows they will NEVER turn from the Dark Side and will eventually end up in Hell anyway.

2) When God created man, he implemented the animal sacrifice system that was the gold standard for generations. But at some "time" (and I don't fully understand this either) God determined that animal sacrifices weren't cutting it any longer, so he sacrificed his Son for our sins as the ultimate sacrifice. If God knew this would happen, why didn't God cut to the chase generations earlier with Jesus, like before Abraham, instead of making man go thru the animal sacrifice bit for so long.?



Okay, I'm back. Sorry for the long delay.

If you don't mind, I'd like to take a stab at your two questions by using two different posts. Allow me to predicate my words here with the fact that I don't speak for God. I don't presume to know His thoughts or reasons. The best that I can do is speculate based upon my relationship with Him, knowing His character, and what He left for us in Scripture.

I find that the best way to get to the bottom of such questions is to take them to Him directly.

I'd like to start at your second question first as that is by far the less complex one in my mind.

Originally Posted by DeerWhacker444
2) When God created man, he implemented the animal sacrifice system that was the gold standard for generations. But at some "time" (and I don't fully understand this either) God determined that animal sacrifices weren't cutting it any longer, so he sacrificed his Son for our sins as the ultimate sacrifice. If God knew this would happen, why didn't God cut to the chase generations earlier with Jesus, like before Abraham, instead of making man go thru the animal sacrifice bit for so long.?


It's my understanding that God doesn't work within the confines of time. I know that seems like a cop out, but in my mind it wouldn't make sense for a God to have to be confined by anything other than His own rules. That kind of comes with being all powerful. I say that, because if He broke His own rules then He wouldn't be just. He can't be Holy if He isn't just and He can't be God if He isn't Holy, therefore there would be no God.

This will probably seem a bit unorthodox but I find God communicates with me in a lot of different ways. I learn about Him through some of the most bizarre means. Enter, the Karate Kid. grin

I wish I could make this up, but I'm just weird I guess. God taught me something about the way He does things through watching that movie. Especially Mr. Miagi's training methods.

Wax on, wax off. The kid wanted to be like his teacher, that's why he followed him and obeyed him. In his mind, he was going to learn how to fight by applying what he knew about learning how to fight to this whole training concept. What he knew about learning how to fight didn't come from Mr. Miagi though, it came from old movies, tv shows, books, etc. Mr. Miagi had his own method.

The kid thought he was being used and exploited by doing all that work on the fence. He didn't realize that the training was in the work itself. He learned that Mr. Miagi's ways may seem unfair, abusive, and wrong, but in fact, his ways were above the kids ways. He knew what he was doing, even if the kid didn't, and he had no obligation to explain himself. The whole point was that the kid just needed to trust him.

I don't know why God's timing works the way it does. I just know that He's always working on us.

When He first created man, He didn't institute animal sacrifice. Adam is said to have walked with God in the cool of the day through the Garden. Imagine your hunting buddy at camp being none other than God Himself. The Bible tells us that sin is really nothing more than us doing things our way, rather than God's way....

Originally Posted by Isaiah 53:6
All of us like sheep have gone astray,
Each of us has turned to his own way;
But the LORD has caused the iniquity of us all
To fall on Him.


The Bible also tells us that sin, in effect, separates us from God...

Originally Posted by Isaiah 59
Behold, the LORD�S hand is not so short
That it cannot save;
Nor is His ear so dull
That it cannot hear.

2But your iniquities have made a separation between you and your God,


When Adam sinned, it separated him from God. Kind of like building a wall between the two. The same happens with us. Either we walk WITH God and do things His way, or we step away and separate ourselves from Him to do things our way.

God loves us, and doesn't want to be separated from us, so this wall, or chasm between us and Him is what He so detests. Think about being separated from your loved ones by a wall. You haven't stopped loving them, but that wall is really in the way and you HATE it.

The wall has to go, but since we put it there, it's up to us to give Him the permission to tear it down. He is a gentleman after all.

Ever since the Garden of Eden, God has been living with a lost love that breaks His heart continuously. He's longed for that intimacy He had with Adam in the Garden. Man, as a result of his free will, does his own thing, and by definition, sins. We cannot unsin, as Longbob pointed out, and Scripture agrees, that if we say that we are without sin, we make God a liar.

Man cannot get back to God through any of our works. We can't unsin. That was the lesson in the animal sacrifices. God said that without the shedding of blood, there can be no remission of sin. So, animal sacrifices were a band-aid, temporary act to atone for our sin. The wages of sin is death, the Bible says. Something has to die, and neither God, nor us wanted it to be us that had to die. So, critters paid the price for us...

We needed to learn that nothing short of God Himself could fix the rift sin has caused. So, animal sacrifice, and Old Testament Law were there to teach us that no matter what, we were too corrupt to be perfect. We couldn't be sinless, and we couldn't unsin.

The sacrifice of Jesus on the cross was the answer. The perfect, Holy Lamb of God, took the place of animals which had been taking the place of us, and He paid the wage of sin. Where animals were only a temporary payment (consider it interest due), the sacrifice of the Lamb of God, paid the price in full. He bought our sins. That's why animal sacrifice stopped. It was ineffectual and no longer needed.

Now, why did He wait as long as He did? Wax on, wax off, Daniel-san. Beats me, but I suspect it was so we could learn about ourselves, and about Him. He had a plan in place to redeem and rescue us all along. All of us...
Originally Posted by Longbob
This one paragraph of yours says volumes at how you view me as a non Christian. It states that I cannot be moral unless I am a Christian. Keep thinking that.

Originally Posted by MacLorry
"Values you select or make up yourself may be some "code" you live by, but they are not moral values. If moral values were up to the individual then everyone is living a perfectly moral life. Moral values are imposed by one greater than yourself, which is God. Dismissing the Bible as a hoax frees you from judging yourself by God's values."


What it says is that no individual can be moral if they cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.

Quote
Life did begin on this planet....Nobody knows how...
I do but if I told you you would not believe me!
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd
Originally Posted by Bristoe
Evolution is by design.

A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.


Evolution is mans' explanation for what God did.

A great way of putting it.
Try Me, I'm open to options.
I don't have anybody around to discuss religious stuff with, so I'm unloading on those following this thread who are interested...

A couple other questions that have bugged me for some time.

1) Is the Bible the "End All, Be All, Know it All" instruction manual sent from God?

Are we to obey only what is written in the Bible.?

Are there other books in existence that contain the words of God that weren't chosen by man(ironic) to be included in the Bible?

And if so, why are they deemed less important than those books in the Bible.?

2) What are the Nephilim that are talked about in Genesis.?

When men began to increase in number on the earth and daughters were born to them, the sons of God saw that the daughters of men were beautiful, and they married any of them they chose. Then the LORD said, "My Spirit will not contend with man forever, for he is mortal; his days will be a hundred and twenty years." The Nephilim were on the earth in those days--and also afterward--when the sons of God went to the daughters of men and had children by them. They were the heroes of old, men of renown. - Genesis 6:1-4

Some of the stuff in Genesis reads almost like Greek or Roman mythology. If the OT is to be taken literally, then there was some weird stuff going on in the days of old...not to mention how did animals from Australia get to the ark..?

cry

Thoughts.?
Dang, I got more posts today than in the last year and a half.

To all......God is Great, Beer is Good, People are Crazy.

God Bless smile
"Personally, I think that some point in the past, humans evolved this self awareness/consciousness and it resulted in them having a burning desire to learn about, and understand the world around them."

Evolution depends on chance mutations being superior in some way to the parents.

The first son of a bitch with a conscience would have been at a decided disadvantage to those without one.

So evolution can't explain why humans can have a sense of guilt, a sense of gratitude, or genuine love.

"Enlightened self interest" is the explanation I've heard most often in explaining it, but that doesn't get around the fact that the first "mutant" humans with a conscience would never have survived. The parents likely would have knocked it in the head.

Listening to the bible-thumpers attempt to explain away all the troublesome passages in the bible causes me to shake my head.

Listening to non-believers explain their lack of belief as being due to "scientific knowledge" causes me to shake my head and laugh my ass off.

No human can get his mind wrapped around a self-existent being which is beyond space and outside of time. Our minds are not equipped to comprehend that.

Yet some claim that if God wants to be believed in by them, He's gotta do it on their terms.Kinda arrogant, it seems to me.

They would be horrified if a congressman told Einstein that he would have to explain his theories a little more clearly so the committee could understand them, or his funding would be cut off.

But God DID dumb the deal down so a kid wouldn't miss the party. He came to earth in human form and basically said:

"If y'all follow my teachings down here, you can follow me to "over yonder" when you finish up here.

And if you need any help down here, I'm only a prayer away. But you might try helping one another first.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
??? So what's his favorite color..?
wink


Before I try to address question number one, I'll keep my promise to you and answer this! grin

Ok, brace yourself for a pathetically sappy response. My apologies, but we are talking about matters of the heart here... blush

I didn't hear some booming voice out of Heaven or anything of the sort. I don't ever get an auditory response from God, so it's a little hard for me to explain how I "hear" His voice. The best I can do is say that it's a feeling from deep within my being....

The answer I got was one of genuine, desperate, passionate love. He was longing for my heart and His was broken over losing it. I felt Him say...

"Mark, the color that I most appreciate is the color I see when your eyes look for, long for, and fall upon me."

He confirmed it here...

Originally Posted by Song of Solomon 4:9
...you have ravished my heart with one look of your eyes...


Originally Posted by Song of Solomon 4:8
... you have ravished my heart with one look of your eyes...


I was reminded of when I fell for my wife. Not only did I love her, but I lusted after her. I desired her to the core. Just the mere glance and acknowledgement of my existence from her would shake me. To have God say that He felt that way times 100 for me, has changed me to this day.

Men can come at me with their petty sciences and theories all they want, but I have a relationship that is unshakeable, with Jesus. I know Him, personally and as real as anyone can know another person. He is more real to me than anyone on the Campfire. That was all I needed....
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


Rape? I don't recall that passage. Help a man out here and reference it for me, if you don't mind...
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
HJA, that was fantastic! Well done.
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
I don't have anybody around to discuss religious stuff with, so I'm unloading on those following this thread who are interested...

A couple other questions that have bugged me for some time.

1) Is the Bible the "End All, Be All, Know it All" instruction manual sent from God?

Are we to obey only what is written in the Bible.?

Are there other books in existence that contain the words of God that weren't chosen by man(ironic) to be included in the Bible?

And if so, why are they deemed less important than those books in the Bible.?

2) What are the Nephilim that are talked about in Genesis.?

When men began to increase in number on the earth and daughters were born to them, the sons of God saw that the daughters of men were beautiful, and they married any of them they chose. Then the LORD said, "My Spirit will not contend with man forever, for he is mortal; his days will be a hundred and twenty years." The Nephilim were on the earth in those days--and also afterward--when the sons of God went to the daughters of men and had children by them. They were the heroes of old, men of renown. - Genesis 6:1-4

Some of the stuff in Genesis reads almost like Greek or Roman mythology. If the OT is to be taken literally, then there was some weird stuff going on in the days of old...not to mention how did animals from Australia get to the ark..?

cry

Thoughts.?


Dude!shockedlaugh

You are going to be a fun one to share a drink with and converse about this kind of thing, I can tell.

Unfortunately, there is no way that I can address all of your questions on here. I just don't have the time, or the manual dexterity (I type a whole freaking lot!) to do so.

If you want sometime, PM me, and I'll hook ya up with my phone number. If nothing else, it should be good for a few laughs...

You may just have to endure the sound of a crying infant in the background from time to time. My son sure likes to express his thoughts and they usually come in the form of "YOU SUCK DAD! Now change my diaper!" laugh
Bob, obviously we could talk for hours about this. Heck, we HAVE talked for hours about this! laugh

I'm having a hard time keeping up, via typing, but I'd love to carry on with these conversations. If you're up for it, PM me sometime and we can work through these at our own pace.

You make me think, and I appreciate that.
Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God."

All that O.T. stuff like the "cursing psalms" is easy to understand if you know that them old jews envisioned religion/government as all being the same.If it sounds like I'm saying some of 'em who claimed to be talking for god were really just politicians........... well, I am.

But not all of 'em were.

Later on, other politicians chose what would go in THEIR bible.

I asked Jesus about all that stuff once.

He answered;"What is THAT to you, follow thou me".[ or something close to that.grin ]
Originally Posted by Dons99
HJA, that was fantastic! Well done.


Thank you... blush

I'm surprised anyone read it actually. I get long winded and know that I wouldn't want to put the time in reading my crap! laugh

Honestly, as you well know, all the credit goes to God. He is the one that has revealed Himself to me in the manner He has done. All I am doing is sharing how He relates to me...

He's pretty freaking cool... cool
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God."

All that O.T. stuff like the "cursing psalms" is easy to understand if you know that them old jews envisioned religion/government as all being the same.If it sounds like I'm saying some of 'em who claimed to be talking for god were really just politicians........... well, I am.

But not all of 'em were.

Later on, other politicians chose what would go in THEIR bible.

I asked Jesus about all that stuff once.

He answered;"What is THAT to you, follow thou me".[ or something close to that.grin ]


laugh

I can totally see Him saying that!

He did the same thing in the Bible when He came upon two religious leader debating the Scriptures. He told them "You look in these for eternal life, but it's these that speak of me!!!
Posted By: Dons99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
AMEN to that!
Originally Posted by Longbob
Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


You've made the common error of assuming God doesn't have the right to be God.

If you or I pushed a button that nuked a city it would be mass murder or genocide because we are mere humans who can't know the consequences of our acts nor did the lives we took belong to us. If God destroys a city as in the OT, it's righteous judgment as all those lives belonged to Him, and even in their death God can judge them individually and show mercy to the innocent.

This life is temporary and the NT teaches clearly that many of those you consider at a disadvantage in this life will enter God's kingdom easily, while the rich and powerful find it hard to enter unless they humble themselves.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


Bible don't indicate that any of that was endorsed by God.
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


Rape? I don't recall that passage. Help a man out here and reference it for me, if you don't mind...


Deuteronomy 22:28-29 Outlines the laws of rape. Where a man that has raped a woman must pay her father a few sheckles and then marry her. That is insane to make the victim of a rape marry her attacker!

Deuteronomy 21:10-14 Here you can take a woman for your self if you have a hankering for her whether she wants to or not. Then you can send her on her way when you no longer have desires for her.

Judges 5:30 Of course we must have women as part of the spoils of war.

Here's a doozy. Nothing like having God on your side.... Zechariah 14:1-2 Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, women ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Longbob
Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


You've made the common error of assuming God doesn't have the right to be God.

If you or I pushed a button that nuked a city it would be mass murder or genocide because we are mere humans who can't know the consequences of our acts nor did the lives we took belong to us. If God destroys a city as in the OT, it's righteous judgment as all those lives belonged to Him, and even in their death God can judge them individually and show mercy to the innocent.

This life is temporary and the NT teaches clearly that many of those you consider at a disadvantage in this life will enter God's kingdom easily, while the rich and powerful find it hard to enter unless they humble themselves.


I never said God didn't have a right to be God. I just said he was a prick.
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


Bible don't indicate that any of that was endorsed by God.


Umm...from the above post.

Zechariah 14:1-2 Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, women ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Longbob
Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


You've made the common error of assuming God doesn't have the right to be God.

If you or I pushed a button that nuked a city it would be mass murder or genocide because we are mere humans who can't know the consequences of our acts nor did the lives we took belong to us. If God destroys a city as in the OT, it's righteous judgment as all those lives belonged to Him, and even in their death God can judge them individually and show mercy to the innocent.

This life is temporary and the NT teaches clearly that many of those you consider at a disadvantage in this life will enter God's kingdom easily, while the rich and powerful find it hard to enter unless they humble themselves.


I never said God didn't have a right to be God. I just said he was a prick.


Lots of guys when they were young thought their earthly fathers were pricks, but many grew up and realized their fathers disciplined them out of love and they themselves were the pricks, not their fathers.
Of course my father didn't order any genocides that I'm aware of................
Originally Posted by billhilly
Of course my father didn't order any genocides that I'm aware of................


Nor did God. All lives belong to God so Him taking them is not genocide, nor are the dead beyond His judgment. Don't judge God's actions as if He were a mere man.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by billhilly
Of course my father didn't order any genocides that I'm aware of................


Nor did God. All lives belong to God so Him taking them is not genocide, nor are the dead beyond His judgment. Don't judge God's actions as if He were a mere man.


He didn't only order it, he performed it.

And at midnight the LORD killed all the firstborn sons in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn son of Pharaoh, who sat on the throne, to the firstborn son of the captive in the dungeon. Even the firstborn of their livestock were killed. Pharaoh and his officials and all the people of Egypt woke up during the night, and loud wailing was heard throughout the land of Egypt. There was not a single house where someone had not died. Exodus 12:29-30 NLT
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/13/13
ol Yahweh was a pretty heartless God, especially after became a Sky-God, after having left the Earth, and having served as an Earth-based God.

Jesus, his Son changed all of that. they were very different from each other, or so it seems.
Originally Posted by billhilly
God created us with the knowledge of what our choices would be though right? How is that different than preordination?

Foreknowledge is knowing, before occurrence, what will occur.

Preordination is deciding, determining, directing, before occurrence, what will occur.

Knowing (or at least being pretty dadgum sure) that the sun'll come up into the easterly sky every morning next week
won't have any effect on whether it does.
Semi-good Catholic guy here.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
What it says is that no individual can be moral if the cherry pick or invent their own values. Anyone who judges themselves by their own values will always pass their own judgment and consider themselves "moral". That thinking has given us some of the worst despots in history.

Certainly you can be a law-abiding citizen in human society apart from Biblical moral values. In that regard you have accepted society's standards as your moral values.

Why many reject Biblical moral values is because they encompass sexual relationships and conduct. It's perfectly legal in our society to live with someone outside of marriage and even have kids together. In fact, there was this reality show called "All My Babies' Mamas" that almost made it to air where this guy has 11 kids by 10 different women. It's all perfectly legal as long as he provides for those kids. As a Christian I consider that immoral, but you may not.


Speaking of cherry picking, you are cherry picking your own Bible. You are ignoring the messages of slavery, sexism, genocide, murder, and rape exercised and/or endorsed by your God.


Bible don't indicate that any of that was endorsed by God.


Umm...from the above post.

Zechariah 14:1-2 Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, women ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city.


That's prophesy, not actual bible history.
Longbob, I'm sure you know that folks who have adopted the stance that the bible is without error and have it as a foundation of their faith have already satisfied themselves as to its apparent contradictions as to God's nature.Their answers only have to satisfy them as far as I'm concerned.

I take what I read, compare it to what I know, and if it don't fit what I know, I discard it.But............ adopting what is generally considered the meaning of a verse and discarding it 'cause it don't fit what I know is shortchanging myself.

A case in point is the "straight is the gate and narrow is the way that leads to eternal life........" teaching. I've always heard it preached as if we have to constantly be on guard, lest we stray.And the path is easily lost.

Now.. I've followed coonhounds through a briar thicket before. That deer trail thru the thicket is easy to follow 'cause it's narrow. And the walking is better.And the thorns don't scratch you.

This Christian life is the only easy life I've ever known.

The bible ain't wrong about the path, but preachers have been preaching it wrong in my opinion.
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd

That's prophesy, not actual bible history.


It was specific example of an endorsement by God.
Curdog,

Point taken and fair enough.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
Originally Posted by billhilly
God created us with the knowledge of what our choices would be though right? How is that different than preordination?

Foreknowledge is knowing, before occurrence, what will occur.

Preordination is deciding, determining, directing, before occurrence, what will occur.

Knowing (or at least being pretty dadgum sure) that the sun'll come up into the easterly sky every morning next week
won't have any effect on whether it does.


True but I didn't create the sun. If I had, I wouldn't expect it to buy into the notion that it had free will.
None of the so-called contradictions that I've investigated have turned-out to be contradictions at all.

Also, I have half a dozen or more first-century Greek New Testaments and found 'em free of significant variation (indeed, so far, free of any variation at all).

(So much for detractors' cherished allegations!)
You are one I had in mind when I wrote this:

Longbob, I'm sure you know that folks who have adopted the stance that the bible is without error and have it as a foundation of their faith have already satisfied themselves as to its apparent contradictions as to God's nature.Their answers only have to satisfy them as far as I'm concerned.

My wife has a book that Dr. James Kennedy wrote where he took the most common "claimed" contradictions and explained them away.She said the book helped her.

Applying the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" philosophy, I only glanced thru the book.I'm like the old colored man regarding the bible;

It's them parts I DO understand that give me fits!

That business about lovin' your neighbor is a rough one.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
None of the so-called contradictions that I've investigated have turned-out to be contradictions at all.

Also, I have half a dozen or more first-century Greek New Testaments and found 'em free of significant variation (indeed, so far, free of any variation at all).

(So much for detractors' cherished allegations!)


Who said anything about contradictions? I am quoting from the assumption that what is written in the Bible/s are consistent messages of bad behavior.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd

That's prophesy, not actual bible history.


It was specific example of an endorsement by God.


Not an endorsement, but a potential punishment as a result of judgement and punishment.
It is an endorsement if I ever saw one, plus I gave specific examples of God carrying out murder. Did you read the Egypt first born thingy?
I only read the initial post.

I am a Christian. I am not a perfect Christian; I may not even be a good Christian, but I am a Christian. I believe that the Lord Jesus Christ is my personal savior. I believe in Heaven and I believe in prayer I think that makes me a Christian.
Posted By: TF49 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Gee whiz longbob,you make it up as you go along. I never said anything like this:

"And you made my point that you can decide to be as evil or bad as you want just as long as you accept Jesus as your savior before you die then you get the ticket into Heaven."

This must have come out of your own misundertanding and ignorance. Oh, and perhaps your lack of scholarship.

Not only did I NOT say that, it is quite untrue.


TF

Originally Posted by curdog4570
� I'm like the old colored man regarding the bible �

A young Negro preacher's powerful sermons came to the attention of his bishop, who was appalled to learn that the young preacher's only source was the Bible. To remedy the "problem," he sent the young preacher a set of commentaries. On a visit some time later, he asked what the young fellow thought of the commentaries.

"Oh, them's good books! Good books! A li'l dim in places, but Scriptcha th'ows a lot o' light in there."

That young preacher is one of my heroes.
Posted By: PS1080 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
First century new testament? Are these scrolls, hand written books, or mass printed books from a somewhat later time frame. Whichever it was still written by men not some super being. I have to say people on this thread are knowledgeable about their chosen cult and its central work of fiction. The way you people have ruined the campfire makes me think you could make even a mythical place like heaven suck. A great example of I'd rather laugh with the sinners than cry with the saints. Count me as a hell no on the original question.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
None of the so-called contradictions that I've investigated have turned-out to be contradictions at all.

Also, I have half a dozen or more first-century Greek New Testaments and found 'em free of significant variation (indeed, so far, free of any variation at all).

(So much for detractors' cherished allegations!)



So, a fella who believes the bible is the straight up word of god "investigates the "alleged" contradictions and finds that there aren't any. I'm shocked.
Now there is a good question

What year did the Bible come to be, and I don't mean written, I mean put together.

Good detail here will contain information on which books where choosen and when a meeting occured to change that.

In a nutshell, the old testament shows Gods nature and absolute hate of sin. Thank God for Jesus and the new Covenant.
Originally Posted by TF49
Gee whiz longbob,you make it up as you go along. I never said anything like this:

"And you made my point that you can decide to be as evil or bad as you want just as long as you accept Jesus as your savior before you die then you get the ticket into Heaven."

This must have come out of your own misundertanding and ignorance. Oh, and perhaps your lack of scholarship.

Not only did I NOT say that, it is quite untrue.


TF



I realize that reading comprehension is not everyone's strong suit, but I said it was MY point and that you were helping to make it. What I wrote is a 100% true that you could commit those sins and still be accepted into Heaven by your Bible by accepting Jesus Christ as your savior that died for your sins.

These are your words.

Originally Posted by TF49



The problem with this is that one is only "as good as he wants to be." This is a problem common to most, in fact I have it as an major issue. ONLY AS GOOD AS... I.... WANT TO BE. This way I only have to satisfy myself and not some external deity. If one's moral standard comes from within oneself, you don't know what you'll end up with. I suspect that most Muslim suicide bombers do truly believe and believe that their own "internal moral code" justifies their act.

I suspect that ALL of us struggle with this in some way.

All the best,

tf


The way that you would answer to your deity is whether or not you accept Jesus Christ as your savior. I could care less what the God of the Bible requires of me. His own behavior that is written in the same books that you follow is not anyone I have respect for to lead me.

Maybe my standards are higher than yours. I dunno.
Originally Posted by Longbob
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by billhilly
Of course my father didn't order any genocides that I'm aware of................


Nor did God. All lives belong to God so Him taking them is not genocide, nor are the dead beyond His judgment. Don't judge God's actions as if He were a mere man.


He didn't only order it, he performed it.

And at midnight the LORD killed all the firstborn sons in the land of Egypt, from the firstborn son of Pharaoh, who sat on the throne, to the firstborn son of the captive in the dungeon. Even the firstborn of their livestock were killed. Pharaoh and his officials and all the people of Egypt woke up during the night, and loud wailing was heard throughout the land of Egypt. There was not a single house where someone had not died. Exodus 12:29-30 NLT


And what is "it" that he performed. It's not genocide as all lives belong to Him. Once again, you deny God the right to be God and view His actions as if He were just a man.

After the firstborn of Egypt were dead they were still in God's presence and subject to both His mercy and His judgment. Many, such as the young children, likely went to Paradise. God was working out His plan of salvation through that plague and their lives and deaths on Earth were part of that plan.
IF you came to believe that there was a CREATIVE FORCE behind "all there is", would you think it wise to attempt to establish communication with that Force?

Maybe you are the exception, but I find it strange that so many consider that the question of a "Deity" must be determined by establishing whether the bible is true, or not.

Some guys centuries ago wrote down stories of actions THEY attributed to God. They wrote down instructions THEY claimed came from God. Some of the stories are hard to believe. Some of them, if true, reveal a frightening God that slaughters innocents,and instructs His followers to commit all sorts of atrocities.

Now... to reject God on the basis of that requires that a man believe that those guys were right.If they were wrong, of course, you'd know no more about God than if you had never read what they wrote.

It just seems strange to me to reject the whole idea of a Creator based on such flimsy evidence.

I'd at least check out Scientology.grin
Curdog,

I never said I didn't believe that there wasn't a higher power behind our existence. I stated that I wasn't a Christian in my first post in answer to Ken's question.

I later posted several reasons why I didn't feel that the God of the Bible represented a legitimate higher power based on the passages of the same Bible. And those just scratched the surface.
MacLorry,

Murder is murder to the one that is getting killed. It makes no difference to them whether it was a God or a man. They are still dead.

And it makes no difference to the ones left behind for they grieve the loss of their loved ones.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Just a couple of loose thoughts...

I'm supposed to fear Satan and God... and I don't fear either, that's a negative way to live... whoever gets me will possibly regret the bargain.

Kumbaya, love, peace, salvation are all about Jesus... when someone tells me I'm going to hell, they quote Paul... wonder which one appeals to me.

Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit. A couple books in the New Testament cover it easily... the rest of the books are about religion... and everyone else is going to hell.

Though Jesus came to show the way from the old religion of 'everyone else is going to hell'.

And lastly... when more and more tribulations are stacked on and you finally are sick of it... think of Job and say... hey moutherphucker, that's enough...

Worked for me.

Kent
Quote
It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion.


This is one of the most foolish statement on this thread. How do you establish whose morals are the correct morals without Absolute Morality? Values are another thing. I value my freedom. So what?
Got it. Guess I misunderstood you or mixed up a post from someone else with yours.

Have a good evening.
Posted By: Darrel Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Jesus said: "No man cometh unto the Father but by me!"
Faith and faith alone, not works, not being 'good', NOTHING a mortal can do will get him/her into Heaven except Faith in Jesus Christ as their Lord & Saviour! "For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith�and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast. Eph 2:8-9." ALL of the 'good' a man might do is just a result of that faith! No faith, no belief, NO GOOD! At least you won't be cold!
Quote
but one person or groups gospel isn't the end all to God.


"I felt the necessity to write to you appealing tat you contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all delivered to the saints." Jude 3

According to God's Word the Bible is the end all to God.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion.


This is one of the most foolish statement on this thread. How do you establish whose morals are the correct morals without Absolute Morality? Values are another thing. I value my freedom. So what?


If you require an immoral God to teach you morals then you really do reveal a lot about your character.
I don't believe in; Tooth Fairy's
Boogeymen
Big foot
Loch Ness monsters
Iliamna lake Monster
Any So Called God
I think Jesus (if he did exist) was merely a Village Idiot at best!
Zombies
etc,etc,etc
Posted By: LBP Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Whats your thoughts?

Is baptism required for salvation?

Is tithing required for salvation?

Finally can you lose salvation or are you once saved always saved?

Thanks
Quote
Generally though, in most society's, as science expands its knoweldge, religious beliefs dwindle..


That because of peer pressure and the arrogance of man. I have met too many Ph.D. scientists to agree with your statement. I have challenged many people to tell me about two Ph.D creationists who have become evolutionists because of their studies and I will give you the names of two hundred Ph.D scientists who became creationists because of their studies. The scientific facts are hard on the objective honest scientist.
This post is currently at 45 pages & I've sat here & read through every one. It has been a very interesting read as I'm sure Ken intended it to be when threw such a loaded question to the hodge podge crowd that gathers here at the fire. Interesting to see & hear the differences of opinion of salvation between the mix. My father is a Southern Baptist pastor & I grew up in a devout Christian family. I make no claim to be anywhere near the man my earthly father is & take great shame in the face of my heavenly father in light of the life of a sinner I have lived. I accepted Christ as my Lord & Savior as a young man & know that my day of judgement will come & I will have to answer for my sins. I know that I am a sinner & know that I have no one to blame for my sins but myself. All I can do as a man is my best to obey God's word, spread God's word & live my life by God's word. I will make mistakes. I will make bad choices. I will never be perfect as a man. Each of us makes the choice of our religion. Most follow their family or friends to the church of their choice. Some decide to go their own direction. I've discussed my salvation with others & found many accepting & had many throw it back into my face or just plain want to fight over it. Discussions such as this one brings Joshua 24:15 to mind. "And if it seems evil unto you to serve the LORD, choose you this day whom ye will serve; whether the gods which your fathers served that were on the other side of the flood, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land ye dwell. But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD."

That's MY story & I'm sticking to it!

BTW... Thanks for the post Ken.
Originally Posted by Longbob
MacLorry,

Murder is murder to the one that is getting killed. It makes no difference to them whether it was a God or a man. They are still dead.

And it makes no difference to the ones left behind for they grieve the loss of their loved ones.


You still deny God the right to be God. God cannot murder anyone as everyone's life belongs to Him, and He set the number of your days before you were born.
Quote
That still doesn�t address the idea that an omnipotent, omnipresent god would know how it turned out and not need to test anybody. Reconciling preordination with free will has had folks doing back flips ever since the first time somebody actually thought about it.


God doesn't not have knowledge. He is omniscient. If you watched a moving and then watched it again you would know what is going to happen. And you didn't influence anything with your foreknowledge. This is a very poor illustration but it does show one can know what's going to happen without influencing it.
Originally Posted by Spotshooter
Now there is a good question

What year did the Bible come to be, and I don't mean written, I mean put together.

Good detail here will contain information on which books where choosen and when a meeting occured to change that.



There's a lot of history and myth about this, but Eusebius (A.D. 264 - 340), bishop of Caesarea under order of Constantine to produce fifty Bibles extensively researched what books were accepted by the churches and selected the 27 books that are now in our New Testament. The Council of Carthage (A.D. 397) ratified without change the 27 books selected by Eusebius.
Quote
You can only have a *choice* between heaven and hell if you have faith and believe..If you believe in these things and then reject God, as say Satanists do, then it makes sense..Otherwise not..


Both are exercising faith.

Quote
Ditto for babies and infants who die while still very young..The NT clearly states the criteria for going to Heaven in John 3:16 and similar verses concerning being "saved" as Christians term it..Little ones who die early in life simply can't be saved, so by default therefore go to Hell?

Th Bible and Religion are the creations of man and as such their logic and content are flawed..


God's Word does not start with the New Testament. If you want to address a topic you must study the Whole Book. God is a God of order not disorder. He has established an age of accountability. If you want to know send a PM and I will forward the age and explanation.
Quote
In fact if you believe in the OT, God has killed more Jews over the years than Hitler did, and to cap it all, when Hitler did come along, God then allowed him to commit genocide against his so called "Chosen People"..


Read the end of Deuteronomy. You will see that God promised if the Jews turned from Him he would crush them. He happened to use Hitler in the twentieth century.
Thanks - it's interesting how other books were considered for the cannon.
Different religions and churchs have different books as well.

Personally I'm a christian, but I fly alot lower than may others, and am genuinely turned off by any use of the word / truth for anything else but educatoin vs. competition, and taughting. I frankly also don't care what others think about me.

Regardless, truth has always existed even before someone wrote it down, or shoved in together into a book, especially when man decided which books where the real deal and which weren't. Therefore I don't take to arguing about what one thinks the book says, I've heard way to many views on the same passages for that.

Either way, you won't hear me saying I drew water from the Rock


Quote
Life did begin on this planet....Nobody knows how..


A fool makes a statement like this. You believe in miracles but don't want to believe in a Miracle Worker.
Originally Posted by LBP
Whats your thoughts?

Is baptism required for salvation?

Is tithing required for salvation?

Finally can you lose salvation or are you once saved always saved?

Thanks


No
No
No and yes

You questions indicate that you haven't read nor understood the bible.
Posted By: TF49 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Well longbob, you continue to attach your own meaning to my statements and then rally a point against your own interpretation. Oh well.

TF
Quote
This chunk of rock did not spontaneously evolve into a human being. However, Life did begin on this planet....Nobody knows how....But it did gain a foothold Billions of years ago. And started to evolve.

We, Homo Sapiens sapiens are just the current pinnacle of that evolution.


Your post sounds like you don't know how complex a living replicating cell is. Even the most simple living cell is more complex the the whole city of New York with all its communication systems, sewer systems, roadways and things I can't even think of.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
In fact if you believe in the OT, God has killed more Jews over the years than Hitler did, and to cap it all, when Hitler did come along, God then allowed him to commit genocide against his so called "Chosen People"..


Read the end of Deuteronomy. You will see that God promised if the Jews turned from Him he would crush them. He happened to use Hitler in the twentieth century.


Hitler was doing God's work? Why is Hitler vilified by most Christians now? Something ain't right.
This thread is showing me that in deference to those who read and respond to only the header of an opening post, I should've headed my opening post something like Who decides who's a Christian?

As I intended it and worded it, it was merely a statement of my own belief and intent, not meant to bait a trap or "loaded" to surreptitiously stir some steaming pot or other.

And I've already recognized for a long time the blatant Campfire tendencies to (a) "read" what isn't there and (b) to miss or to ignore what is there � often (c) both at the same time.

I'll try to do better in the future. (Hey, I'm learning! I'm learning!)
Originally Posted by waterrat
I don't believe in; Tooth Fairy's
Boogeymen
Big foot
Loch Ness monsters
Iliamna lake Monster
Any So Called God
I think Jesus (if he did exist) was merely a Village Idiot at best!
Zombies
etc,etc,etc


Certainly feel deep sorrow for you since all of our basic laws and tenets are based upon the 10 commandments.
Quote

Originally Posted By: AlabamaEd
Originally Posted By: Bristoe
Evolution is by design.

A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.


Evolution is mans' explanation for what God did.

A great way of putting it.


This is a compromise. Evolution is contrary to God's Word.
Yep, pretty great example of individuals who haven't read the bible or studied its words and meanings over a period of many years selecting its words to mean what they want them to mean.
Quote
"Personally, I think that some point in the past, humans evolved this self awareness/consciousness and it resulted in them having a burning desire to learn about, and understand the world around them."

Evolution depends on chance mutations being superior in some way to the parents.

The first son of a bitch with a conscience would have been at a decided disadvantage to those without one.

So evolution can't explain why humans can have a sense of guilt, a sense of gratitude, or genuine love.

"Enlightened self interest" is the explanation I've heard most often in explaining it, but that doesn't get around the fact that the first "mutant" humans with a conscience would never have survived. The parents likely would have knocked it in the head.

Listening to the bible-thumpers attempt to explain away all the troublesome passages in the bible causes me to shake my head.

Listening to non-believers explain their lack of belief as being due to "scientific knowledge" causes me to shake my head and laugh my ass off.

No human can get his mind wrapped around a self-existent being which is beyond space and outside of time. Our minds are not equipped to comprehend that.

Yet some claim that if God wants to be believed in by them, He's gotta do it on their terms.Kinda arrogant, it seems to me.

They would be horrified if a congressman told Einstein that he would have to explain his theories a little more clearly so the committee could understand them, or his funding would be cut off.

But God DID dumb the deal down so a kid wouldn't miss the party. He came to earth in human form and basically said:

"If y'all follow my teachings down here, you can follow me to "over yonder" when you finish up here.

And if you need any help down here, I'm only a prayer away. But you might try helping one another first.


Very fun post to read.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote

Originally Posted By: AlabamaEd
Originally Posted By: Bristoe
Evolution is by design.

A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.


Evolution is mans' explanation for what God did.

A great way of putting it.


This is a compromise. Evolution is contrary to God's Word.


Only if you choose to view it as such.

Nobody has been given the chronological path of creation,...and the Messiah plainly said that God's time isn't our time,..his ways aren't our ways.
Originally Posted by Bristoe
� A chunk of rock can't spontaneously evolve into a human being.

In one of his gag sequences (listing understandable ways to imagine how great a trillion is), Johnny Carson quipped that a trillion is how many years that it'd take a can of Alpo to evolve into Lorne Green.
Speaking of time,..I find it interesting that the Messiah spoke of time in a non static fashion long before Einstein had a chance to lay out his thoughts of relativity on the subject.
Men a great deal easier to understand than God is. (yes I left a word out)

Take for instance the natural result of a person reading half a message, or sending one for that matter. It's very human for anyone in this case to look for what they expect to be there, or to expect others to understand what their context was. This doesn't mean they are evil, it means they are men.

Also completely natural is a persons reaction to being judged, even if they think they are being judged or looked down upon.
Quote
It is an endorsement if I ever saw one, plus I gave specific examples of God carrying out murder. Did you read the Egypt first born thingy?


The God of the New Testament is the Same God as the God of the Old Testament. He was angry at the locals and displayed his power and indignation in such a way that no family went untouched. That Same God offered a Gift to us and will be infinitely angry with all who reject His Gift. God established that the wages of sin is death and our death will not suffice. He also established that His Gift of killing His Son would suffice for your sin. Those who reject His loving Gift will suffer infinitely. After all God's Word tells us four times God is a consuming fire and only two times God is love.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion.


This is one of the most foolish statement on this thread. How do you establish whose morals are the correct morals without Absolute Morality? Values are another thing. I value my freedom. So what?



You can take you PhD, appeal to authority fallacious BS and stick it up yer azz. Seriously, I'm sick of you types claiming that morality can't exist outside of your genocidal bronze age sky fairy. It is offensive to me and the rest of the people in the world who don't believe or believe differently. There were more than a few empires come and gone before anybody got around to inventing your particular god.

You're an embarrassment to most of the Christians on this forum and to humanity in general. You're the guy who thinks the speed of light slows down just enough to keep anything from being more than 6000 light years away so as not to contradict your YEC crap and yet are pretentious enough to lecture people on science.
Quote
I have to say people on this thread are knowledgeable about their chosen cult and its central work of fiction.


A few years ago Dr.Kindell debated a guy who stated unequivocally that Pilot never lived. And Jesus was never judged by him like the Bible talks about the flat pavement. The very next year archiologists discovered the pavement and a balcony with Pontious Pilot's name engraved in the edge.

So please tell us what parts are fiction that you know of. Any of them will work for this conversation.
Quote
Now there is a good question

What year did the Bible come to be, and I don't mean written, I mean put together.

Good detail here will contain information on which books where choosen and when a meeting occured to change that.


I think if you seriously research this you will discover the books of the Old Testament were canonized at least 285 years before Jesus. They were translated in another language at that time. The Books of the New Testament were already generally accepted until they were finally officially canonized around 300 AD.

While you're doing your study try to find any ancient manuscripts that come close to matching the closeness of the time to the writer's life and the quantity of manuscripts. You will discover there is no comparison.
And I bet that Pontious Pilot's name was "misspelled" Pontius Pilate. laugh
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
I have to say people on this thread are knowledgeable about their chosen cult and its central work of fiction.


A few years ago Dr.Kindell debated a guy who stated unequivocally that Pilot never lived. And Jesus was never judged by him like the Bible talks about the flat pavement. The very next year archiologists discovered the pavement and a balcony with Pontious Pilot's name engraved in the edge.

So please tell us what parts are fiction that you know of. Any of them will work for this conversation.


How about the part where you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews? Fact or fiction?
Quote
I'm supposed to fear Satan


Where did you learn that?

Quote
Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit.


Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.
Quote
If you require an immoral God to teach you morals then you really do reveal a lot about your character.


God has established Absolute Morality. Your judging of an Infinite Owner of all things is laughable.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
I'm supposed to fear Satan


Where did you learn that?

Quote
Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit.


Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.


Since you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews, it follows that the US military was actually fighting against God when they fought the Germans in WWII. Curious that with Hitler on the side of God, how in God's name was Hitler defeated?
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
If you require an immoral God to teach you morals then you really do reveal a lot about your character.


God has established Absolute Morality. Your judging of an Infinite Owner of all things is laughable.


Since you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews, and God is the Absolute Morality, the Americans fighting Hitler's Germans were actually immoral in your eyes. Yea or nay?
Quote
Nobody has been given the chronological path of creation,...and the Messiah plainly said that God's time isn't our time,..his ways aren't our ways.


The Highest Authority is God's Word. God wrote with His own finger on stone, "For in six days God created heaven and earth and the sea and all that is in them."

Jesus says, "From the beginning of creation God made them male and female."

If one does a time line we can discover according to God's Word creation week was about 6,000 years ago.
Quote
ou can take you PhD, appeal to authority fallacious BS and stick it up yer azz. Seriously, I'm sick of you types claiming that morality can't exist outside of your genocidal bronze age sky fairy. It is offensive to me and the rest of the people in the world who don't believe or believe differently. There were more than a few empires come and gone before anybody got around to inventing your particular god.

You're an embarrassment to most of the Christians on this forum and to humanity in general. You're the guy who thinks the speed of light slows down just enough to keep anything from being more than 6000 light years away so as not to contradict your YEC crap and yet are pretentious enough to lecture people on science.


Did I touch a nerve?

Now where have I suggested the speed of light slows down to accommodate the historical age of creation.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
Nobody has been given the chronological path of creation,...and the Messiah plainly said that God's time isn't our time,..his ways aren't our ways.


The Highest Authority is God's Word. God wrote with His own finger on stone, "For in six days God created heaven and earth and the sea and all that is in them."

Jesus says, "From the beginning of creation God made them male and female."

If one does a time line we can discover according to God's Word creation week was about 6,000 years ago.


You claim that (just about the time of your birth) 70 years ago, God (through Hitler) did state sponsored murder of approximately 6 million people and that it was Absolutely Moral. Do you think that such a claim enhances your credibility as a Christian apologist?
Originally Posted by Ringman

Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.


Quite right, Ringman. Jesus said some outrageous things, and here are a few others:

1. He talked like he was God.

2. He said that no one can approach God the father except through him.

3. He said that he is coming back to judge the world at the end of time.

4. He also said that he has the power to forgive sins, implying that he is the person most grievously wronged by sin. For example, lets say that John killed Bob. Jesus is implying that he is more grievously wronged by John's action than Bob is!

Jesus was either a liar, a lunatic, or he was exactly who he claimed to be. He most certainly was not merely a good person, or a good moral teacher.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
ou can take you PhD, appeal to authority fallacious BS and stick it up yer azz. Seriously, I'm sick of you types claiming that morality can't exist outside of your genocidal bronze age sky fairy. It is offensive to me and the rest of the people in the world who don't believe or believe differently. There were more than a few empires come and gone before anybody got around to inventing your particular god.

You're an embarrassment to most of the Christians on this forum and to humanity in general. You're the guy who thinks the speed of light slows down just enough to keep anything from being more than 6000 light years away so as not to contradict your YEC crap and yet are pretentious enough to lecture people on science.


Did I touch a nerve?

Now where have I suggested the speed of light slows down to accommodate the historical age of creation.



Just tired of hearing how the only morality comes from your barbaric book of campfire tales.

Quite some time back I asked you if the world was 6000 years old, how is it that there are objects we can see that are further than 6000 light years away. You responded with some crackpot idea about the speed of light no doubt from one of your revered Phd's.
Originally Posted by Bristoe
Speaking of time, I find it interesting that the Messiah spoke of time in a nonstatic fashion long before Einstein had a chance to lay out his thoughts of relativity on the subject.

While the inmates were out in the jail's exercise yard one day, an LEO friend of mine scribbled "E=MC�" on a wall of the big holding cell. Then he and the other cops enjoyed listening to the puzzled inmates' discussions about what it meant, where it came from, etc.

The next day, he had one of the lady cops write in very feminine handwriting "Correct, Albert. Next time, show your work."

laugh
BTT

Ringman,

Don't be shy. You got some explaining to do.

Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by Ringman


Read the end of Deuteronomy. You will see that God promised if the Jews turned from Him he would crush them. He happened to use Hitler in the twentieth century.


Hitler was doing God's work? Why is Hitler vilified by most Christians now? Something ain't right.
Posted By: FVA Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by carbon12
BTT

Ringman,

Don't be shy. You got some explaining to do.

Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by Ringman


Read the end of Deuteronomy. You will see that God promised if the Jews turned from Him he would crush them. He happened to use Hitler in the twentieth century.


Hitler was doing God's work? Why is Hitler vilified by most Christians now? Something ain't right.



Regarding God using evil to bring about judgement, or His will, the O.T. book Habakkuk is short,three chapters, and answers questions regarding such.
Getting it right from the horse's mouth so to speak isn't a bad way to go.
Don't know Hitler's place or purpose nor have a desire to speculate on such.
This isn't a discussion, this isn't even an argument, its a turkey shoot. There are christians on here trying to explain their beliefs to people who have absolutely no intent on listening or thoughtful consideration just insulting and trying to destroy what they believe. "Don't toss your pearls to pigs", was wise advice and I would suggest those that call themselves christians start to follow it. This thread is less than productive and pretty unhealthy.

God Bless,

MM
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
This thread is a true view of the bigotry and superstition in religion... it's the same thing a minister has to balance in his own congregation from the different elders, deacons and pew sitters...

Kent
Ken;
My Mother was born into a farming family in west central Oklahoma back in the 20s. Her mother was half Cherokee and her father was a Rock Ribbed Baptist dry land farmer.
Mom was a most practical lady who would keep her opinion to herself mostly. One of the ones that impressed me the most was 'Of all the people she knew that told her they were going to heaven convinced her that hell may be more appealing since there's a better class of folks there.'
At the age of 65 I can see the wisdom of that opinion.

Jim
People talk about God to learn about other people, not to learn about God.

Those on this thread who make fun of the bible are actually just making fun of the people who believe it is the inspired word of God.

Many of those defending the bible are actually just attacking the "mockers".

People are fun to watch.

Ask God, if you don't believe ME. grin

Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
You are not going to convince a Hindu, Muslim, Buddist, or anyone else from another dogma. To follow strangers to a place where everyone they know here, won't be.

Jesus came for everyone and I think bringing the Holy Spirit into the main stream consciousness was a huge gamechanger... but hasn't been utilized enough by religion in breaking bigotry.

Kent
Most "christians" are not bigoted............ unless there are a bunch of other "christians" watching them.

You can substitute most any "minority" for "christian" and still have a true statement.
Originally Posted by curdog4570
People talk about God to learn about other people, not to learn about God.

Those on this thread who make fun of the bible are actually just making fun of the people who believe it is the inspired word of God.

Many of those defending the bible are actually just attacking the "mockers".

People are fun to watch.

Ask God, if you don't believe ME. grin



Right on Mr. Curdog.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Two dudes are walking along, stop and one says...

see that cat...

no, but I see a dog...

cat...

dog...

A chick is watching and says... dumbasses, it's a parrot..

As they walk off arguing the, cow chews it's cud.

God looks at Satan and say's... three more for you...

Satan say's... hey wait a minute, they seem typically religious to me.

Kent
So attacking another person's belief system to ellicit a response so that you can be entertained. Some people around here call that trolling. Are you a troll then?
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
This isn't a discussion, this isn't even an argument, its a turkey shoot. There are christians on here trying to explain their beliefs to people who have absolutely no intent on listening or thoughtful consideration just insulting and trying to destroy what they believe. "Don't toss your pearls to pigs", was wise advice and I would suggest those that call themselves christians start to follow it. This thread is less than productive and pretty unhealthy.

God Bless,

MM


Jesus in his Sermon on the Mount warned that casting false pearls before swine will get the pearls trampled and the casters attacked. Swine are smart and a protected class. Don't eat them.
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
So attacking another person's belief system to ellicit a response so that you can be entertained. Some people around here call that trolling. Are you a troll then?


More a fisher of men.
Anybody turning down bacon is not to be trusted.
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
This isn't a discussion, this isn't even an argument, its a turkey shoot. There are christians on here trying to explain their beliefs to people who have absolutely no intent on listening or thoughtful consideration just insulting and trying to destroy what they believe. "Don't toss your pearls to pigs", was wise advice and I would suggest those that call themselves christians start to follow it. This thread is less than productive and pretty unhealthy.

God Bless,

MM


^This^. It has been my experience this it typically what happens. Most people who post questions regarding faith also know exactly what will happen. I learned a long time ago, not to wade into that swamp in internet forums.
I naively thought I was answering genuine questions regarding Christianity and my faith to those who may be interested, searching or have questions. I found that typically, it's all a ruse to start threads such as this.
I have on occasion, been able to discern someone participating in the thread that genuinely is seeking some answers and have PM'd them and offered to help if I could.

But for the most part, I avoid participation. This exception is to comment on MM's excellent comment above.

I will add, when I read these threads, I am reminded of the words, "total depravity". I typically end up greatly saddened and reminded of the total loss of mankind to "save themselves" as "themselves" are their own worst enemy. TRUTH as laid out in the Bible, specifically the purpose salvation through Christ and the necessity of His coming, becomes much clearer. What a great Gift God gave us and how many, sadly, prefer to clothe themselves in darkness.

I can speak with understanding about that "darkness". I know all about that darkness, I walked in it a long time before, by the grace of God, I walked into the Light and found Truth. Sadly, many will refuse to seek it and even close their eyes to it when it is revealed to them.

But that's just the way it is.
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Anybody turning down bacon is not to be trusted.


My sentiments exactly. The bit in Leviticus about having a cloven hoof but not chewing a cud being unclean has me bamboozled.
Guys, guys, I'zadope, c12 is a known and self outed troll (serious issues). Save your pearls.
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
So attacking another person's belief system to ellicit a response so that you can be entertained. Some people around here call that trolling. Are you a troll then?


More a fisher of men.


Classic irony, never saw that one coming. Do you burn ants with a magnifying glass in your spare time?
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
If you participate you will be attacked for your belief by others that also believe... Jesus himself told this.

It's nothing new, those that can't handle it need just stay out of it, that simple. There are always more listening and are silent, that one small message may start a spark.

Open argument is better than hiding the lamp under a basket.

Kent
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by mitchellmountain
So attacking another person's belief system to ellicit a response so that you can be entertained. Some people around here call that trolling. Are you a troll then?


More a fisher of men.


Classic irony, never saw that one coming. Do you burn ants with a magnifying glass in your spare time?


Not enough daylight in the day to both drown worms and mess with ants.

Correction: I do use big black foam ants on occasions when called for. Some of you guys are kinked that way.
Originally Posted by krp
If you participate you will be attacked for your belief by others that also believe... Jesus himself told this.

It's nothing new, those that can't handle it need just stay out of it, that simple. There are always more listening and are silent, that one small message may start a spark.

Open argument is better than hiding the lamp under a basket.

Kent


I completely agree, but after so many times of that individual trying to put out your lamp, consider your job done and if God wants him, he will have him. Otherwise don't let them drag you into their abyss. God can change a man's heart, of that I'm absolutely convinced, but speaking to deaf ears over and over is nothing but frustrating.
MM
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
I'm supposed to fear Satan


Where did you learn that?

Quote
Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit.


Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.


Since you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews, it follows that the US military was actually fighting against God when they fought the Germans in WWII. Curious that with Hitler on the side of God, how in God's name was Hitler defeated?


The nation of Israel ceased to exist by A.D. 73, yet Biblical prophecy requires the nation of Israel to exist before the return of Christ. No nation that ceased to exist in ancient times has ever been reestablished in modern times, accept for Israel on May 14, 1948.

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.

In WWI Hitler miraculously survived on the battlefield in such obvious fashion that he was convinced it was the work of divine providence. I believe he was right, but it wasn't for his benefit, but to ultimately fulfill prophecy. Hitler also miraculously survived more than 27 assassination attempts from 1934 to 1944. I believe God's plan was for Hitler to suffer such defeat and fear that he would take his own life.

During the invasion of Normandy the bad weather fooled the Nazis into letting their guard down so much so that many of the top leaders were away from the coast and Hitler was knocked out by sleeping pills with orders not to awaken him. Hitler's character, which had been instrumental in forming the Third Reich and in its early victories was a military disaster when on the defense, so much so that the allies communicated to the resistance that they did not want Hitler assassinated.

Many see all this as just coincidence, nevertheless, the result was ancient Biblical prophecy fulfilled in the lifetimes of some on this thread.
I got saved and baptized, but damn sure dont act like it.

Gunner
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
You can never win an argument or change the opponents view... but there are many watching that want answers. They can weigh the multiple sides and possibly get some enlightenment... just reading a theology written by a single source presents that one sources enlightenment.

Debate has it's place... even heated debate.

Kent
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
I'm supposed to fear Satan


Where did you learn that?

Quote
Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit.


Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.


Since you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews, it follows that the US military was actually fighting against God when they fought the Germans in WWII. Curious that with Hitler on the side of God, how in God's name was Hitler defeated?


The nation of Israel ceased to exist by A.D. 73, yet Biblical prophecy requires the nation of Israel to exist before the return of Christ. No nation that ceased to exist in ancient times has ever been reestablished in modern times, accept for Israel on May 14, 1948.

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.

In WWI Hitler miraculously survived on the battlefield in such obvious fashion that he was convinced it was the work of divine providence. I believe he was right, but it wasn't for his benefit, but to ultimately fulfill prophecy. Hitler also miraculously survived more than 27 assassination attempts from 1934 to 1944. I believe God's plan was for Hitler to suffer such defeat and fear that he would take his own life.

During the invasion of Normandy the bad weather fooled the Nazis into letting their guard down so much so that many of the top leaders were away from the coast and Hitler was knocked out by sleeping pills with orders not to awaken him. Hitler's character, which had been instrumental in forming the Third Reich and in its early victories was a military disaster when on the defense, so much so that the allies communicated to the resistance that they did not want Hitler assassinated.

Many see all this as just coincidence, nevertheless, the result was ancient Biblical prophecy fulfilled in the lifetimes of some on this thread.



So much for free will and the power of prayer. Biblical prophecy pretty much trumps all of that.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by MacLorry

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.



6 million lives sacrificed is hard for me to reconcile.

I can't reconcile that Job's children, individuals with their own soul and life/spiritual meaning... were just snuffed out as an uplifting example of Job's righteousness.

And replacing them later just wouldn't cut it as a father.

Some examples of man's parables of God's purpose I take with a grain of salt.

Kent
Originally Posted by krp
You can never win an argument or change the opponents view... but there are many watching that want answers. They can weigh the multiple sides and possibly get some enlightenment... just reading a theology written by a single source presents that one sources enlightenment.

Debate has it's place... even heated debate.

Kent


Good point.
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry
The nation of Israel ceased to exist by A.D. 73, yet Biblical prophecy requires the nation of Israel to exist before the return of Christ. No nation that ceased to exist in ancient times has ever been reestablished in modern times, accept for Israel on May 14, 1948.

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.

In WWI Hitler miraculously survived on the battlefield in such obvious fashion that he was convinced it was the work of divine providence. I believe he was right, but it wasn't for his benefit, but to ultimately fulfill prophecy. Hitler also miraculously survived more than 27 assassination attempts from 1934 to 1944. I believe God's plan was for Hitler to suffer such defeat and fear that he would take his own life.

During the invasion of Normandy the bad weather fooled the Nazis into letting their guard down so much so that many of the top leaders were away from the coast and Hitler was knocked out by sleeping pills with orders not to awaken him. Hitler's character, which had been instrumental in forming the Third Reich and in its early victories was a military disaster when on the defense, so much so that the allies communicated to the resistance that they did not want Hitler assassinated.

Many see all this as just coincidence, nevertheless, the result was ancient Biblical prophecy fulfilled in the lifetimes of some on this thread.



So much for free will and the power of prayer. Biblical prophecy pretty much trumps all of that.


Selecting someone God knows will embrace hate and megalomania for His purpose doesn't override that person's free will. Fulfillment of biblical prophecy assures us that the Bible is what it claims to be.
Originally Posted by krp
Originally Posted by MacLorry

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.



6 million lives sacrificed is hard for me to reconcile.

I can't reconcile that Job's children, individuals with their own soul and life/spiritual meaning... were just snuffed out as an uplifting example of Job's righteousness.

And replacing them later just wouldn't cut it as a father.

Some examples of man's parables of God's purpose I take with a grain of salt.

Kent


6 million lives sacrificed is hard for you to reconcile because you are just a man viewing the event through a man's eyes and understanding. Those 6 million Jews, though dead, are still alive in the presences of God and still subject to both His judgment and His mercy. God is working out the far greater plan of salvation. Stop judging God's actions as if He were just a man.

Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry
The nation of Israel ceased to exist by A.D. 73, yet Biblical prophecy requires the nation of Israel to exist before the return of Christ. No nation that ceased to exist in ancient times has ever been reestablished in modern times, accept for Israel on May 14, 1948.

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.

In WWI Hitler miraculously survived on the battlefield in such obvious fashion that he was convinced it was the work of divine providence. I believe he was right, but it wasn't for his benefit, but to ultimately fulfill prophecy. Hitler also miraculously survived more than 27 assassination attempts from 1934 to 1944. I believe God's plan was for Hitler to suffer such defeat and fear that he would take his own life.

During the invasion of Normandy the bad weather fooled the Nazis into letting their guard down so much so that many of the top leaders were away from the coast and Hitler was knocked out by sleeping pills with orders not to awaken him. Hitler's character, which had been instrumental in forming the Third Reich and in its early victories was a military disaster when on the defense, so much so that the allies communicated to the resistance that they did not want Hitler assassinated.

Many see all this as just coincidence, nevertheless, the result was ancient Biblical prophecy fulfilled in the lifetimes of some on this thread.



So much for free will and the power of prayer. Biblical prophecy pretty much trumps all of that.


Selecting someone God knows will embrace hate and megalomania for His purpose doesn't override that person's free will. Fulfillment of biblical prophecy assures us that the Bible is what it claims to be.


What about the free will of the 6 million that were murdered? Was it God's will that they perish in a most heinous way to fulfill prophecy? Did those that were murdered petition the lord with prayer for a different fate? What about their free will?


For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God have done something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?

Just some questions that a God given brain would ask.
I look at the Holocaust differently than Mclorry, I'm not sure it was in God's plan, but who am I to say really. I do think that through the course of eternity and in infinite intelligence God can turn the action of one evil man into something that fits God's purpose. We may never see his plan come to fruition, nor my children or theirs or theirs times 10 to the 12th. But, thats not important even though it would be gratifying. I'm in for the long haul, passed my last breath, if he'll have me.

GOd Bless,

MM
Originally Posted by carbon12
What about the free will of the 6 million that were murdered? Was it God's will that they perish in a most heinous way to fulfill prophecy? Did those that were murdered petition the lord with prayer for a different fate? What about their free will?


Many Jews saw the signs and used their free will to get out of Germany, however, the exercise of free will doesn't guarantee an outcome. As for prayer, a person's free will is not denied if they don't get the answer they want. A parent not letting their young child play with power tools doesn't deny that child their free will, only their free action.

As for this notion of murder, all lives belong to God and He sets the number of each person's days. By the definition of some on this thread, God setting the number of a person's days is murder. If so, that leads to the absurd notion that God has murdered everyone. You can't judge God's actions as if He were a man.

Originally Posted by carbon12
For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God do something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?


Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19

As for God doing "something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem", the answer is no. There is a perfectly coherent explanation for the mayhem, but you would have to apply your God given brain to long hours of study. What are the odds of that?
"For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God have done something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?

Just some questions that a God given brain would ask."

I confess to having always been to self-centered to spend much time being concerned about past events that I couldn't relate to my own self. That's a failing I'm aware of and have to constantly battle with.[ Since "self" can't defeat "self", I have to rely on a Higher Power for assistance]

But...... a similar question that I have struggled with is is the same one posed to Jesus regarding the suffering of children born with handicaps.

His answer in the bible was too enigmatic to satisfy me so I asked Him to dumb it down to my level of understanding. I'm not claiming a special enlightenment, but what I got is this:

All the things we see that seem to be in contradiction to the nature of a Creator that cares about His creatures, MUST NOT BE VERY IMPORTANT IN THE GRAND SCHEME OF THINGS, BUT WE ARE SUPPOSED TO ACT AS THOUGH THEY ARE.

That's when I discovered that a man's questions will never end.

We always wind up with,"WHY".
"Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19 "

BULLSCHITT!

I'm no bible scholar, but if you're gonna quote it, you should do it right.

The bibles I've read have the writer saying something like this:[from memory,so it's not word for word]

"We who were with Him on the mountain have the words of the prophets MADE MORE CERTAIN............ .

He was clearly saying that though they were aware of the prophecies concerning Jesus, and had seen Him in his Glory, they had even better evidence of His Deity, and it was available to all of us.

He could ONLY be referring to the work of the Holy Spirit DIRECTLY on a man's conscience.

What bible did you quote from?
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by MacLorry

6 million lives sacrificed is hard for you to reconcile because you are just a man viewing the event through a man's eyes and understanding. Those 6 million Jews, though dead, are still alive in the presences of God and still subject to both His judgment and His mercy. God is working out the far greater plan of salvation. Stop judging God's actions as if He were just a man.



I judge God through my life 's tribulations.

I should say I believe those things happened to the Jews and Job... and Job was righteous in his reaction and a good example.

But it reminds me of our current politicians that don't let a tragedy go to waste, thinking they could embellish it to give glory to God.

No one needs to tell me how chit can happen fast and my response may have not been the most righteous at the end... if God wanted glory he didn't get it... at first I abased myself as if it was all my fault... eventually it got so bad I told God to lay the [bleep] off of me and mine... the tribulations ceased, some things returned like with Job. Whether God figured I got some message or just abandoned me, I really don't care...

Each Jew and child of Job were not some statistic in a lesson or prophesy.

Kent

Well if I be, it is not anyone else's thoughts or opinions that matter, and if I be not, then it is only a concern of mine. I have grown tired of folks saying stuff like, "How can you call yourself a Christian and do ___________?" Fill in the blank with anything you like - I've heard it all.

I did what God said for me to do. I called on him to save me. I believed on His Son, and received His work on Calvary. I have trusted in the shed blood of a perfect man to cover my wickedness. If that be not enough, then I'll take my place in an eternal lake of fire while still trusting in the blood of Jesus Christ my Saviour. wink
I have no heroes, but after reading your posts for a number of years, I'll say that if preachers ain't barred from heaven on general principles,............. you'll make the cut. grin
Originally Posted by curdog4570
"Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19 "

BULLSCHITT!

I'm no bible scholar, but if you're gonna quote it, you should do it right.

The bibles I've read have the writer saying something like this:[from memory,so it's not word for word]

"We who were with Him on the mountain have the words of the prophets MADE MORE CERTAIN............ .

He was clearly saying that though they were aware of the prophecies concerning Jesus, and had seen Him in his Glory, they had even better evidence of His Deity, and it was available to all of us.

He could ONLY be referring to the work of the Holy Spirit DIRECTLY on a man's conscience.

What bible did you quote from?


I quoted 2 Peter 1:19 from the English Standard Version (�2001). Verse 18 reads "we ourselves heard this very voice borne from heaven, for we were with him on the holy mountain."

Here are some other translations of 2 Peter 1:18-19

New International Version (�1984)
"We ourselves heard this voice that came from heaven when we were with him on the sacred mountain. And we have the word of the prophets made more certain, and you will do well to pay attention to it, as to a light shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts."


King James Bible (Cambridge Ed.)
"And this voice which came from heaven we heard, when we were with him in the holy mount. We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day star arise in your hearts:"


Young's Literal Translation
"and this voice we -- we did hear, out of heaven borne, being with him in the holy mount. And we have more firm the prophetic word, to which we do well giving heed, as to a lamp shining in a dark place, till day may dawn, and a morning star may arise -- in your hearts;"
If one believes that you, the essential "you", come into being upon sucking that first breath of air outside your mother's womb (or at some indeterminate point in the womb before that), that you walk around for a while and then "you" disappear forever when electrical activity in the brain ceases, then the events that happen to these bodies while they walk around is of supreme importance. You will fight wars, kill people, hurt them, do everything you can to enhance this body, its pleasures and longevity.

If one believes that the essential you is "something" that existed long before your little body was a gleam in your father's eye, that ithis essential you is placed into this body for some reason that, quite literally, God only knows, and that the essential you survives after this body wastes away - which it is 100% guaranteed to do - then what happens while "you" walk around in this body might seem important at the time but in the course of eternity (a concept no human mind can really grasp) is really just a very tiny grain of sand on an endless beach.

My understanding of free will is that it is your free will to look at things from either point of view.

And to answer the OP, no, I'm not a card carrying Christian, at least I gather that most of the official Christians would say I am not because I couldn't care less about the dogma and believing what I am "required" to believe. I'm more a Taoist who really, really, really likes the words of a Jewish carpenter who lived just a little while ago (as eternity goes), and also thinks an Indian prince had some good things to say as well.
Originally Posted by the_shootist
Well if I be, it is not anyone else's thoughts or opinions that matter, and if I be not, then it is only a concern of mine. I have grown tired of folks saying stuff like, "How can you call yourself a Christian and do ___________?" Fill in the blank with anything you like - I've heard it all.

I did what God said for me to do. I called on him to save me. I believed on His Son, and received His work on Calvary. I have trusted in the shed blood of a perfect man to cover my wickedness. If that be not enough, then I'll take my place in an eternal lake of fire while still trusting in the blood of Jesus Christ my Saviour. wink


Always enjoy when you chime in on these posts. Clear and no nonsense. Kind of like a book I've read.

God Bless,

MM
This is no small matter.

Which is the "trump ace"; the words of prophets. or the "something" which makes his words more certain?

Which better fits the message of Jesus concerning the little children?

Which places a premium on intelligence and reading comprehension, and which opens the door to EVERYONE who will open his mind to Jesus and his heart to the Holy Spirit ?

Which lends itself to a "special cadre" of priests and teachers, and which makes a man his own "priest"?

As I said, it is no small thing.
Originally Posted by krp
Originally Posted by MacLorry

6 million lives sacrificed is hard for you to reconcile because you are just a man viewing the event through a man's eyes and understanding. Those 6 million Jews, though dead, are still alive in the presences of God and still subject to both His judgment and His mercy. God is working out the far greater plan of salvation. Stop judging God's actions as if He were just a man.



I judge God through my life 's tribulations.

I should say I believe those things happened to the Jews and Job... and Job was righteous in his reaction and a good example.

But it reminds me of our current politicians that don't let a tragedy go to waste, thinking they could embellish it to give glory to God.

No one needs to tell me how chit can happen fast and my response may have not been the most righteous at the end... if God wanted glory he didn't get it... at first I abased myself as if it was all my fault... eventually it got so bad I told God to lay the [bleep] off of me and mine... the tribulations ceased, some things returned like with Job. Whether God figured I got some message or just abandoned me, I really don't care...

Each Jew and child of Job were not some statistic in a lesson or prophesy.

Kent


God had been protecting Job and gave him great success in family and in material things way beyond what others received because God was pleased with Job even pointing him out to Satan. Satan thought he could make Job renounce God if God removed His special protection, which He did except for Job's life. Satan tormented Job but couldn't break him; it's what Satan does. God restored Job's family and material things.

Being Satan is still at large and his focus is on the saved its likely God had nothing to do with your tribulations. Maybe at the point of you nearly committing the unforgivable sin God chased Satan away from you, not wanting to lose you to Satan. God may have been waiting for you to use the Name that is above all names to bind Satan and chase him away yourself. Job didn't have that option as that Name had not yet been given among men. Put on the full armor of God and learn how to use the sword. Satan will look for easier prey.
Originally Posted by curdog4570
This is no small matter.

Which is the "trump ace"; the words of prophets. or the "something" which makes his words more certain?

Which better fits the message of Jesus concerning the little children?

Which places a premium on intelligence and reading comprehension, and which opens the door to EVERYONE who will open his mind to Jesus and his heart to the Holy Spirit ?

Which lends itself to a "special cadre" of priests and teachers, and which makes a man his own "priest"?

As I said, it is no small thing.


As Paul indicated he was all things to all men that he might save some. All that's needed for salvation is childlike faith that every human can do. However, pride in one's intellect or accomplishments prevents many from humbling themselves and accepting the foolishness of the message preached. God wanting to save all provides a means by which some of the proud can see how foolish their pride is so they accept the foolishness of the message preached as a child and be saved. Fulfilled prophesy plays it's part in opening the eyes of the proud.
Quote
You responded with some crackpot idea about the speed of light no doubt from one of your revered Phd's.


And who would you say your idea come from?
Thanks for the answer.

Since focusing on a light in a dark place requires our attention to be in ONE direction, that seems to me to be regulating all the various prophecies to a lesser role.

I agree that once the "morning star rises", that Morning Star may reveal things about prophecies not noticed before.

But I don't believe that Morning Star ever intended to play second fiddle to "ink stains dried upon some line", no matter how "inspired" the writer.

But........... I'm a "live and let live" type of guy.I just post what works for me.
Posted By: LBP Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by AlabamaEd
Originally Posted by LBP
Whats your thoughts?

Is baptism required for salvation?

Is tithing required for salvation?

Finally can you lose salvation or are you once saved always saved?

Thanks


No
No
No and yes

You questions indicate that you haven't read nor understood the bible.


Ed Thanks for the help I appreciate you taking the time the time to respond.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
You responded with some crackpot idea about the speed of light no doubt from one of your revered Phd's.


And who would you say your idea come from?





My ideas on physics come from all the evidence accumulated over the years. I know you can name a PhD who�ll back up your 6000 year old earth ideas but I�m sure I can find a few Jews who like bacon. That don�t make it kosher though.
Posted By: PS1080 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Religious people love taking cheap shots at science. The same science that makes it possible for them to mentally masturbate at their computer all day or that has saved their lives or a loved ones through modern medicine. They go on and on that something can't come from nothing. Yet this is how they explain the existence of their god. He just was. It's really pathetic to watch these people brag about choosing ignorance. Not to surprising considering their entire life they're read one book and completely missed it's main message. If Jesus was real he'd put a boot up there a$$ for being such aholes.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
I'm supposed to fear Satan


Where did you learn that?

Quote
Jesus's story is simple, inspirational, thought provoking and speaks to an inner spirit.


Jesus makes some claims that would get someone institutionalized today. He said, "Heaven and earth will pass away, but My Words will not." He said, "I am going to be killed and three days later I am going to come back to life." He said, referring to the God they believed in "If you have seen Me you have seen the Father."

If He was not Lord He was a lunatic. By the way the most documented fact of history prior to the printing press is the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus.


Since you claim that Hitler was doing God's work crushing the Jews, it follows that the US military was actually fighting against God when they fought the Germans in WWII. Curious that with Hitler on the side of God, how in God's name was Hitler defeated?


The nation of Israel ceased to exist by A.D. 73, yet Biblical prophecy requires the nation of Israel to exist before the return of Christ. No nation that ceased to exist in ancient times has ever been reestablished in modern times, accept for Israel on May 14, 1948.

I believe God used Hitler to reestablish Israel just as He had used the Pharaoh of Egypt to create the nation of Israel. It took Hitler's atrocities against Jews to motivate millions of them to say "Never Again" and to abandon their lives in nations around the world and pour into a war zone with the intent to live there or die there as Israelites.

In WWI Hitler miraculously survived on the battlefield in such obvious fashion that he was convinced it was the work of divine providence. I believe he was right, but it wasn't for his benefit, but to ultimately fulfill prophecy. Hitler also miraculously survived more than 27 assassination attempts from 1934 to 1944. I believe God's plan was for Hitler to suffer such defeat and fear that he would take his own life.

During the invasion of Normandy the bad weather fooled the Nazis into letting their guard down so much so that many of the top leaders were away from the coast and Hitler was knocked out by sleeping pills with orders not to awaken him. Hitler's character, which had been instrumental in forming the Third Reich and in its early victories was a military disaster when on the defense, so much so that the allies communicated to the resistance that they did not want Hitler assassinated.

Many see all this as just coincidence, nevertheless, the result was ancient Biblical prophecy fulfilled in the lifetimes of some on this thread.




Absolutely right. What the devil intends for evil God uses for good. If not for Hitler and the holocaust there would be no Israel today.

All in all this thread was what I expected it to be- A lot of chaff. But I was pleasantly surprised with how much wheat was here too. I especially enjoyed Dons99's timely scriptures.
Quote
But...... a similar question that I have struggled with is is the same one posed to Jesus regarding the suffering of children born with handicaps.


These handicap children are proof that mutations go the wrong way for evolution to be correct. We don't see things getting better in this world, but we can certainly see things getting worse.
Posted By: RickyD Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Quote
Some examples of man's parables of God's purpose I take with a grain of salt.

As did Lot's wife, it would seem. wink

Man thinks far too highly of himself. He exists for God's Glory, alone. We are but a wisp in the wind without Him.
Quote
My ideas on physics come from all the evidence accumulated over the years.


So then you earned a Ph.D in physics?
Quote
They go on and on that something can't come from nothing. Yet this is how they explain the existence of their god. He just was. It's really pathetic


You don't understand the Christian God of the Bible. God did not come from nothing. God IS. Past, present and future by our feeble reckoning. God is eternally existing.
Because scientists write their findings in a secret code known only to those with a PhD. Unless of course you happen to have one of those handicap mutations you mentioned earlier. Then you can read it.

Seriously, are you an atheist here under a false flag? It is really hard to believe you�re serious with some of he crap you come up with.


Posted By: 1B Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Who cares?
Originally Posted by PS1080
Religious people love taking cheap shots at science. The same science that makes it possible for them to mentally masturbate at their computer all day or that has saved their lives or a loved ones through modern medicine. They go on and on that something can't come from nothing. Yet this is how they explain the existence of their god. He just was. It's really pathetic to watch these people brag about choosing ignorance. Not to surprising considering their entire life they're read one book and completely missed it's main message. If Jesus was real he'd put a boot up there a$$ for being such aholes.


Damn........ you nailed us dead to rights. We are all just like you described.

I thought some of us hid it better than that.

My side is stuck with Ringman, but Carbon guy and the bassackwards Hillbilly have to count you among their ranks.

I'm waitin' on their "+ 1's".

grin
Posted By: PS1080 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Once you people quit quoting Scripture and start posting your own thoughts things go down hill for you in a hurry.
Quote
Seriously, are you an atheist here under a false flag? It is really hard to believe you�re serious with some of he crap you come up with.


I was an atheistic evolutionist. One day a guy showed me something in a magazine from a scientist which contradicted some of the evolutionary theories I was taught in school. Since evolution was my world view I was so shaken I consulted a psychiatrist. Eventually I decided there must be an infinite intelligent energy because I am not so philosophical as to believe everything is a figment of my imagination.

Within about five years I became a Christian. The change was so dramatic that at least one co-worker laughed in my face. I began to read God's Word and believed in creation. Subsequently I read some Ph.D. authors who used to be evolutionists who, because of their studies and field research, became creationists. Eventually I made a time line from the information in God's Word and decided creation happened about 6,000 years ago. Since then I have either read or met scientists who also believe the whole of creation is about 6,000 years old.

If you watch the movie "Expelled! No intelligence allowed." you can see just how scared the evolutionary community is of the scientific information. The last debate Dr. Kindell had he debated a Ph.D biologist. When it came time for rebuttal the opponent said, "There's nothing I can say to rebut Dr. Kindell." They became good friends.

Dr. Kindell was as ardent an evolutionist as you will ever find. He was also extremely antagonistic to Christianity. Year ago he told me, "Christians have two brains. One is lost and the other is out looking for it." Like me he could not resist the scientific facts and became a creationist who defends creation, not from God's Word, from science.
Posted By: Pete E Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by Ringman
One day a guy showed me something in a magazine from a scientist which contradicted some of the evolutionary theories I was taught in school. Since evolution was my world view I was so shaken I consulted a psychiatrist.


If a reading magazine article is enough to send you running traumatized to psychiatrist, I would suggest the internet is not a very healthy place for you!
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
by now, as this thread advances, i'm thinkin' ol Ra is up there and looking down on us and laughin' his arse off. i'm surprised he hasn't dispatched at least one double-quaternary angel from the center of the Sun to set things aright.

moreover, religion started the whole discussion going. science is an off-shoot of religion like Jesus is an off-shoot of Yahweh. ya know?

the truth is the extra-terrestrials when they came to Earth used bio-genetic engineering to create the modern human being.
without a consciousness where would we be?

with our consciousness the world is opened up, and we can discuss a lot things within the constructs that our consciousness allows. it seems like there's a "sort" going on. does anyone know for sure?
Originally Posted by Gus
. it seems like there's a "sort" going on. does anyone know for sure?


No,...but if they is,...your ass is liable not to be innit.

God'll be sayin',.."Well,...his heart seems to be in the right place,...but I gotta draw the line somewhere."
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
if that happens, and i'm not sayin' it can"t, my defense is going to be that the design was incomplete, biased, in error, and not yet perfected. i'll ask for a do-over, if that's ok?

Adam Kodman has already blown through several efforts at the generation of a perfect race, hasn't he?

so, while two-stranded DNA gains us considerable ground, and moves us forward think about a 4-stranded DNA construct. let's stretch our consciousness to the point of imagining a 12 stranded DNA construct. would it call for a Creator or an Evolutionist? i think it will call for an extra-terrestrial bio-geneticist with sufficent technology to pull it off.

when the Christos returns or the Messiah comes, hopefully they'll bring a cadre of experts with them for the do-over. grin
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by PS1080
Religious people love taking cheap shots at science. The same science that makes it possible for them to mentally masturbate at their computer all day or that has saved their lives or a loved ones through modern medicine. They go on and on that something can't come from nothing. Yet this is how they explain the existence of their god. He just was. It's really pathetic to watch these people brag about choosing ignorance. Not to surprising considering their entire life they're read one book and completely missed it's main message. If Jesus was real he'd put a boot up there a$$ for being such aholes.
Your post indicates that you just might be one of the minor tribulations that Christians sometimes must encounter. But, a person should avoid being judgmental on the basis of scant evidence. So, to help better understand your statements about -
- what one might love to do;
- one's choice for ignorance;
- one's choices in literature;
- the basis for your pathos; and,
- to help determine if one is that of which you speak - - and for openers - -

kindly give your definition of "Religious people".
Originally Posted by curdog4570
I have no heroes, but after reading your posts for a number of years, I'll say that if preachers ain't barred from heaven on general principles,............. you'll make the cut. grin


Thanks, Gene, but it's all about Him, not about me, preachers notwithstanding. laugh
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
the challenge for us humans down here on the Earth, is to figure out how to address those folks who wish for and create a God, versus those people who believe in the True God.

it's not a simple task, to that we can all agree. a Created God versus a Real God is no small dilemma. just look at the past, with all the gods that have been knocked in the head and rolled down to the bottom of a ditch on a dirt road somewheres?

if the Universe is alive, conscious, and ever expanding, we have a role to play, a responsibility to bear.
You have played the role well. You've borne your share of responsibility.

You may now ride off into the sunset.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by curdog4570
You have played the role well. You've borne your share of responsibility.

You may now ride off into the sunset.


i haven't received the "go' signal yet. and i have a ton of grandchildren coming on after me, trying to keep up with the "scent." grin

the Return of the Christos, and the Coming of the Messiah. is there any difference? i vote that there isn't.

ve humans are really limited in our abilities. it's almost scary. but, i wasn't sent here to be scared. i was sent here as an Agent of Omneity.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by RickyD
Quote
Some examples of man's parables of God's purpose I take with a grain of salt.

As did Lot's wife, it would seem. wink

Man thinks far too highly of himself. He exists for God's Glory, alone. We are but a wisp in the wind without Him.


Is that judgment or a play on words?... my quote is specific to Job and the many levels to be explored in just that one story.

A slave to God or a slave to Satan? that's the choice?

Kent
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Seems most agree it comes down the the acceptance/recognition/knowledge of the Holy Spirit that leads to salvation. If Christianity would stick to the story of Jesus and the Holy Spirit, it wouldn't take much preaching but would be received by many more.

Kent
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
well, yes. but we seem to have variated off the center-line for some amount.

first we had yahweh, then Jesus, then later came Mohammed, and the Allah fella.

it's like the hurricanes lined up off the west coast of Africa, one storm after another, or said another way, one God lined up after the Other. yahweh, jesus, allah...

folks we gotta get a grip on this thing, or it's going to cause our ruination. ya know?
I live a simple life and try to be a better man each day, not in a manner that I get up and preach to every person I see, but in that I make a conscious effort to be kinder, more accepting, respectful towards those that I interact with, and aspire to be a warmer soul and less angry at the world.

I say my prayers daily and ask for help, guidance and forgiveness, and work to implement those factors into all my interactions. I realize I am far from anything perfect and can only hope to be more aware of my shortcomings at the end of another day.

I work hard at rejecting the shell of my former life and growing a new skin, and within that skin hopefully a better person will live. I know that who I used to be and who I am are two different people, and sometimes I don't even recognize the old me...and for that, I am grateful. I came into the world a Taker and hope to go out, a Giver.
One way.....

No man cometh unto the Father but by me.....That's because Jesus is the Father.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by 219Zipper
I live a simple life and try to be a better man each day, not in a manner that I get up and preach to every person I see, but in that I make a conscious effort to be kinder, more accepting, respectful towards those that I interact with, and aspire to be a warmer soul and less angry at the world.

I say my prayers daily and ask for help, guidance and forgiveness, and work to implement those factors into all my interactions. I realize I am far from anything perfect and can only hope to be more aware of my shortcomings at the end of another day.

I work hard at rejecting the shell of my former life and growing a new skin, and within that skin hopefully a better person will live. I know that who I used to be and who I am are two different people, and sometimes I don't even recognize the old me...and for that, I am grateful. I came into the world a Taker and hope to go out, a Giver.


thank you for your most excellent explanation of who you are and where you are. the whole subject is very difficult to digest.

given a two-stranded DNA reality, we're limited to what we can know and what we can do. what we need is a four-stranded, or even 12 stranded DNA.

the world is quickly bouncing up against limits. we need an advancement in DNA capacity, then we'll add environmental consciousness to the Story. thank you for your comments. we gotta advance forward, from our own abilities, or in addition to the extra-terrestrial inputs. we're banging up against the limits of Consciousness, ya know?
Do you have a monkey and a tambourine ?

I know a street corner for rent.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Gus is like a pocket full of pebbles.

Kent
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Do you have a monkey and a tambourine ?

I know a street corner for rent.


ever corner my friend the Street Preacher engaged was for free, as per the local gov't enterprise. grin
Or a pocket (with a hole in it) formerly full of marbles? laugh

Like what I'd see if I still consulted (and insulted!) mirrors? frown
Posted By: DELGUE Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/14/13
I am.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Originally Posted by krp
Seems most agree it comes down the the acceptance/recognition/knowledge of the Holy Spirit that leads to salvation. If Christianity would stick to the story of Jesus and the Holy Spirit, it wouldn't take much preaching but would be received by many more. Kent

++ Amen, brother.
Originally Posted by CCCC
Originally Posted by krp
Seems most agree it comes down the the acceptance/recognition/knowledge of the Holy Spirit that leads to salvation. If Christianity would stick to the story of Jesus and the Holy Spirit, it wouldn't take much preaching but would be received by many more. Kent

++ Amen, brother.


Billy Graham kinda proved that.
To no one on particular, there are many presuppositions without which we can't even DO science. Here is a list I copied from the thinkingmatters.org website. There is a bunch of more stuff available on the web, just google presupposition & scientism. Anyway, here is that list:

(1) The existence of a theory-independant world

(2) the orderly nature of the external word

(3) the knowability of the external world.

(4) the existence of the truth

(5) the laws of logic

(6) the reliability of our cognitive and sensory faculties to serve as truth gatherers and as a source of justified beliefs in our intellectual environment

(7) the adequacy of language to describe the world

(8) the existence of values used in science (honesty)

(9) the uniformity of nature and induction

(10) the existence of numbers.

None of these things can be proved BY science, but all must be presupposed in order to DO science. So science is not the only source of truth.
Quote
If a reading magazine article is enough to send you running traumatized to psychiatrist, I would suggest the internet is not a very healthy place for you!


The problem for me was the photos and facts in the article were irrefutable and contrary to what was being taught in schools. It should not make a difference where we discovered truth. (There is a name for discovering something one is not looking for: Serendipity.) It is what we do with the truth once we have it in front of us. Most reject the truth whether the truth is about science or The Truth, Jesus.
Then they should publish that in a peer reviewed scietific journal so everybody can know. Unless of course it's all BS.
billhilly,

Maybe their peers will not let something be published that does not support the current scientific dogma.

Again, gentlemen, I suggest you who think the info would be published in normal peer reviewed publications need to educate yourselves by watching "Expelled! No intelligence allow."
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
What about the free will of the 6 million that were murdered? Was it God's will that they perish in a most heinous way to fulfill prophecy? Did those that were murdered petition the lord with prayer for a different fate? What about their free will?


Many Jews saw the signs and used their free will to get out of Germany, however, the exercise of free will doesn't guarantee an outcome. As for prayer, a person's free will is not denied if they don't get the answer they want. A parent not letting their young child play with power tools doesn't deny that child their free will, only their free action.

As for this notion of murder, all lives belong to God and He sets the number of each person's days. By the definition of some on this thread, God setting the number of a person's days is murder. If so, that leads to the absurd notion that God has murdered everyone. You can't judge God's actions as if He were a man.

Originally Posted by carbon12
For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God do something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?


Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19

As for God doing "something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem", the answer is no. There is a perfectly coherent explanation for the mayhem, but you would have to apply your God given brain to long hours of study. What are the odds of that?


All that verbiage and it boils down to this:

MacLorry argues that Hitler�s murder of 6 million people was a God mediated plan. The days of the murdered were already numbered. The murders were sanctioned by God from the beginning of the beginning.

If this is the case, shouldn�t Hitler get a free pass? Why should Hitler bear any responsibility for the Holocaust? Hitler was but an actor in a series of inevitable events for the recreation of Israel as Biblical prophesy demands.

Nazi apologist comes to mind.

MacLorry�s version of Man�s relationship to God resembles a liberal political philosophy.

Why should there be personal responsibility when a higher power is in charge?


I AM
Everything that happens is predestined but you don't get a free pass. Romans 8&9.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Everything that happens is predestined but you don't get a free pass. Romans 8&9.


A state of absurdity is the ultimate fate if one follows, eyes wide open, the framers of Biblical scriptures.

The word of God ain't words.
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
What about the free will of the 6 million that were murdered? Was it God's will that they perish in a most heinous way to fulfill prophecy? Did those that were murdered petition the lord with prayer for a different fate? What about their free will?


Many Jews saw the signs and used their free will to get out of Germany, however, the exercise of free will doesn't guarantee an outcome. As for prayer, a person's free will is not denied if they don't get the answer they want. A parent not letting their young child play with power tools doesn't deny that child their free will, only their free action.

As for this notion of murder, all lives belong to God and He sets the number of each person's days. By the definition of some on this thread, God setting the number of a person's days is murder. If so, that leads to the absurd notion that God has murdered everyone. You can't judge God's actions as if He were a man.

Originally Posted by carbon12
For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God do something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?


Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19

As for God doing "something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem", the answer is no. There is a perfectly coherent explanation for the mayhem, but you would have to apply your God given brain to long hours of study. What are the odds of that?


All that verbiage and it boils down to this:

MacLorry argues that Hitler�s murder of 6 million people was a God mediated plan. The days of the murdered were already numbered. The murders were sanctioned by God from the beginning of the beginning.

If this is the case, shouldn�t Hitler get a free pass? Why should Hitler bear any responsibility for the Holocaust? Hitler was but an actor in a series of inevitable events for the recreation of Israel as Biblical prophesy demands.

Nazi apologist comes to mind.

MacLorry�s version of Man�s relationship to God resembles a liberal political philosophy.

Why should there be personal responsibility when a higher power is in charge?


It's funny how you've gone into broadcast mode rather than addressing me in the first person. Maybe there's something to it, so I'll give it a try and see.

carbon12 argues spiritual questions like free will and destiny, but has an obvious lack of biblical knowledge and understanding. If that were not the case he would have realized that the Apostle Paul rhetorically posed and answered the vary question about someone getting a free pass if their actions were part of God's plan. If carbon12 were sincerely interested in gaining such understanding he would only have to read the Bible.

carbon12 greatly underestimates the wisdom, power, and love of God. Little does he realize that he too is part of God's plan. Specifically, God's plan is that the world through its wisdom cannot come to know God. To accomplish that God created the world in such as way that the intellectually proud would be fooled into thinking they found some natural mechanism that explains creation.

On the last day carbon12 and others will ask why they don't get a free pass being it was God's plan to set aside the wisdom of man by sending them on a wild goose chase. God may tell them "I gave you free will and it was My hope that you would use it to humble yourself and simply accept the Gospel message on faith. It's the one thing every person can do, so you are without excuse." Even Hitler could have turned from his ways and been saved in the end, such is the power of what Jesus did on the cross.
There is no such thing as free will.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
What about the free will of the 6 million that were murdered? Was it God's will that they perish in a most heinous way to fulfill prophecy? Did those that were murdered petition the lord with prayer for a different fate? What about their free will?


Many Jews saw the signs and used their free will to get out of Germany, however, the exercise of free will doesn't guarantee an outcome. As for prayer, a person's free will is not denied if they don't get the answer they want. A parent not letting their young child play with power tools doesn't deny that child their free will, only their free action.

As for this notion of murder, all lives belong to God and He sets the number of each person's days. By the definition of some on this thread, God setting the number of a person's days is murder. If so, that leads to the absurd notion that God has murdered everyone. You can't judge God's actions as if He were a man.

Originally Posted by carbon12
For who is Biblical prophecy for anyway? If for Man, couldn't a merciful God do something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem?


Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19

As for God doing "something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem", the answer is no. There is a perfectly coherent explanation for the mayhem, but you would have to apply your God given brain to long hours of study. What are the odds of that?


All that verbiage and it boils down to this:

MacLorry argues that Hitler�s murder of 6 million people was a God mediated plan. The days of the murdered were already numbered. The murders were sanctioned by God from the beginning of the beginning.

If this is the case, shouldn�t Hitler get a free pass? Why should Hitler bear any responsibility for the Holocaust? Hitler was but an actor in a series of inevitable events for the recreation of Israel as Biblical prophesy demands.

Nazi apologist comes to mind.

MacLorry�s version of Man�s relationship to God resembles a liberal political philosophy.

Why should there be personal responsibility when a higher power is in charge?


It's funny how you've gone into broadcast mode rather than addressing me in the first person. Maybe there's something to it, so I'll give it a try and see.

carbon12 argues spiritual questions like free will and destiny, but has an obvious lack of biblical knowledge and understanding. If that were not the case he would have realized that the Apostle Paul rhetorically posed and answered the vary question about someone getting a free pass if their actions were part of God's plan. If carbon12 were sincerely interested in gaining such understanding he would only have to read the Bible.

carbon12 greatly underestimates the wisdom, power, and love of God. Little does he realize that he too is part of God's plan. Specifically, God's plan is that the world through its wisdom cannot come to know God. To accomplish that God created the world in such as way that the intellectually proud would be fooled into thinking they found some natural mechanism that explains creation.

On the last day carbon12 and others will ask why they don't get a free pass being it was God's plan to set aside the wisdom of man by sending them on a wild goose chase. God may tell them "I gave you free will and it was My hope that you would use it to humble yourself and simply accept the Gospel message on faith. It's the one thing every person can do, so you are without excuse." Even Hitler could have turned from his ways and been saved in the end, such is the power of what Jesus did on the cross.


According to you, God made me do it. Have fun with that.
God made you to do it before the foundation of the world. Since we are neither saved nor lost by works it's a moot point.
Posted By: EdM Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
I'm perfectly content to let Jesus decide � not all the "I am" claimants nor any of the self-appointed "you ain't" judgers.

How many ways into the kingdom of God are there? Here too, I'm perfectly content to let only Him decide. I'm pretty sure that others' opinions don't overrule His decrees regarding the matter.

I don't recall that He was ever reticent about either matter, either.

But those are just a couple of my opinions.


For some, including a number here that will never advertise it, it simply does not matter...
Posted By: 5sdad Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


I know that there at least is such a thing as a "free-will offering" because the Ks of C have one in conjunction with their pancake breakfast.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Then it was foreordained before the foundation of the earth that I would call you an idiot, so it cannot be wrong.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Then there is no such thing as sin. crazy


You should look up how many times the words "choose", "chose", and "choice" are used throughout Scripture.

You can't have a choice, without free will.
"The word of God ain't words."

I MIGHT agree with you on that if I was sure what you meant.

Care to expand on your statement?
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Then there is no such thing as sin. crazy


You should look up how many times the words "choose", "chose", and "choice" are used throughout Scripture.

You can't have a choice, without free will.


You should read the entire Bible as I have many times. Read Romans 8&9 and Matthew 13. There is no such thing as free will. If there were, then we'd be God and God would be nothing. Sin is a moot point. The original sin is why we are where we are. God doesn't care about our sins. You're either predestined to Heaven or predestined to hell and nothing can change that. Does God know everything? Can he be mistaken? He knew where you were going and what you'd do be fore you were born.I rest my case.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Then there is no such thing as sin. crazy


You should look up how many times the words "choose", "chose", and "choice" are used throughout Scripture.

You can't have a choice, without free will.


You should read the entire Bible as I have many times. Read Romans 8&9 and Matthew 13. There is no such thing as free will. If there were, then we'd be God and God would be nothing. Sin is a moot point. The original sin is why we are where we are. God doesn't care about our sins. You're either predestined to Heaven or predestined to hell and nothing can change that. Does God know everything? Can he be mistaken? He knew where you were going and what you'd do be fore you were born.I rest my case.


I have read it, many times, and I still read it daily. It was my major in college....

If you read Romans 8&9 in context with the whole book of Romans, you'd see how everything you are saying is absolutely wrong...

Furthermore, if you pay attention to what is written in those two chapters, even in Romans 8 portion that addresses "predestination," you'll see that it's not saying what Calvinist want it to say....

Free will doesn't make us God in the least. If anything, it makes God all that more God.

You tell others to read the Bible, but your own comprehension comes into question when you say that "Sin is a moot point." The Bible is chalked full of verses that say otherwise...

Does God know everything? Yep.

Can he be mistaken? Nope.

I knew that you were going to say this stuff, that doesn't mean that you didn't have a choice...
It's easy to make the argument even that if predestination were true, as Calvinist believe, then there is no God...
Christians believe in predestination as the Bible teaches, churchist don't believe. Free will is taught by the church as a means of control since that's the reason churches exist.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by krp
Originally Posted by MacLorry

6 million lives sacrificed is hard for you to reconcile because you are just a man viewing the event through a man's eyes and understanding. Those 6 million Jews, though dead, are still alive in the presences of God and still subject to both His judgment and His mercy. God is working out the far greater plan of salvation. Stop judging God's actions as if He were just a man.



I judge God through my life 's tribulations.

I should say I believe those things happened to the Jews and Job... and Job was righteous in his reaction and a good example.

But it reminds me of our current politicians that don't let a tragedy go to waste, thinking they could embellish it to give glory to God.

No one needs to tell me how chit can happen fast and my response may have not been the most righteous at the end... if God wanted glory he didn't get it... at first I abased myself as if it was all my fault... eventually it got so bad I told God to lay the [bleep] off of me and mine... the tribulations ceased, some things returned like with Job. Whether God figured I got some message or just abandoned me, I really don't care...

Each Jew and child of Job were not some statistic in a lesson or prophesy.

Kent


God had been protecting Job and gave him great success in family and in material things way beyond what others received because God was pleased with Job even pointing him out to Satan. Satan thought he could make Job renounce God if God removed His special protection, which He did except for Job's life. Satan tormented Job but couldn't break him; it's what Satan does. God restored Job's family and material things.

Being Satan is still at large and his focus is on the saved its likely God had nothing to do with your tribulations. Maybe at the point of you nearly committing the unforgivable sin God chased Satan away from you, not wanting to lose you to Satan. God may have been waiting for you to use the Name that is above all names to bind Satan and chase him away yourself. Job didn't have that option as that Name had not yet been given among men. Put on the full armor of God and learn how to use the sword. Satan will look for easier prey.


God was responsible for Hitler and the 6 million Jews... but Satan, not God for me or Job?... if the story of Job isn't a parable and 100% true, God was ultimately responsible by giving permission with parameters.

A contradiction.

As far as my own salvation... The Holy spirit isn't responsible because of it's nature and Christ my brother isn't either. There was no danger of me breaking.

Sometimes you have to make a stand... God probably gets sick of caterwauling, wailing, begging, false praise, rote... A heartfelt 'FU that's enough', could be refreshing I guess.

Kent

Would those "churchists" be the same thing as the "neocons" that one of our OTHER IDIOTS is always blathering about?
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Would those "churchists" be the same thing as the "neocons" that one of our OTHER IDIOTS is always blathering about?


Be nice...he has no choice.
Nope, Churchist are you that attend a brick and mortar. God isn't there and connot be there.
Me neither...... the Devil made me do it........ the first time, second time, I done it on my own...... .

Thank God for Billy Joe Shaver. grin
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Christians believe in predestination as the Bible teaches, churchist don't believe. Free will is taught by the church as a means of control since that's the reason churches exist.


The Bible doesn't teach predestination as you and the Calvinist subscribe to. Your history is greatly inaccurate. Predestination is a new concept, and a man made one.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Nope, Churchist are you that attend a brick and mortar. God isn't there and connot be there.


Psalm 139 disagrees.

Where can I go from Your Spirit?
Or where can I flee from Your presence?

8If I ascend to heaven, You are there;
If I make my bed in Sheol, behold, You are there.

9If I take the wings of the dawn,
If I dwell in the remotest part of the sea,


God is everywhere...
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by carbon12
Originally Posted by MacLorry

Many Jews saw the signs and used their free will to get out of Germany, however, the exercise of free will doesn't guarantee an outcome. As for prayer, a person's free will is not denied if they don't get the answer they want. A parent not letting their young child play with power tools doesn't deny that child their free will, only their free action.

As for this notion of murder, all lives belong to God and He sets the number of each person's days. By the definition of some on this thread, God setting the number of a person's days is murder. If so, that leads to the absurd notion that God has murdered everyone. You can't judge God's actions as if He were a man.


Fulfillment of Biblical prophecy demonstrates the authenticity of scripture being the word of God. The fulfillment of many OT prophecies by Jesus demonstrates His authenticity as the Christ. "And we have something more sure, the prophetic word, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts," -- 2 Peter 1:19

As for God doing "something else to achieve the same effect with a lot less mayhem", the answer is no. There is a perfectly coherent explanation for the mayhem, but you would have to apply your God given brain to long hours of study. What are the odds of that?


All that verbiage and it boils down to this:

MacLorry argues that Hitler�s murder of 6 million people was a God mediated plan. The days of the murdered were already numbered. The murders were sanctioned by God from the beginning of the beginning.

If this is the case, shouldn�t Hitler get a free pass? Why should Hitler bear any responsibility for the Holocaust? Hitler was but an actor in a series of inevitable events for the recreation of Israel as Biblical prophesy demands.

Nazi apologist comes to mind.

MacLorry�s version of Man�s relationship to God resembles a liberal political philosophy.

Why should there be personal responsibility when a higher power is in charge?


It's funny how you've gone into broadcast mode rather than addressing me in the first person. Maybe there's something to it, so I'll give it a try and see.

carbon12 argues spiritual questions like free will and destiny, but has an obvious lack of biblical knowledge and understanding. If that were not the case he would have realized that the Apostle Paul rhetorically posed and answered the vary question about someone getting a free pass if their actions were part of God's plan. If carbon12 were sincerely interested in gaining such understanding he would only have to read the Bible.

carbon12 greatly underestimates the wisdom, power, and love of God. Little does he realize that he too is part of God's plan. Specifically, God's plan is that the world through its wisdom cannot come to know God. To accomplish that God created the world in such as way that the intellectually proud would be fooled into thinking they found some natural mechanism that explains creation.

On the last day carbon12 and others will ask why they don't get a free pass being it was God's plan to set aside the wisdom of man by sending them on a wild goose chase. God may tell them "I gave you free will and it was My hope that you would use it to humble yourself and simply accept the Gospel message on faith. It's the one thing every person can do, so you are without excuse." Even Hitler could have turned from his ways and been saved in the end, such is the power of what Jesus did on the cross.


According to you, God made me do it. Have fun with that.


Not at all. God just started things in the middle. It's the intellectually proud who rule out God as a starting assumption and then work backward to find how it all started. God doesn't need to do anything but allow human nature to run its course. The blind leading the blind and you're all patting yourselves on the back as to what great intellects you are.

If you were a little smarter you would realize you can't disprove the Biblical story of creation because God is not bound by natural laws, He created them. If you can't disprove the Biblical story of creation then you can't prove any alternative. The simple conclusion is that what you believe about God or even his non-existence you believe on faith and faith alone. You're in the same boat as us Christians, so what do you have to be proud of?
Well said MacLorry. Very well said. You know what the good book says about fools, right? smile
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


That's the Calvinist position and it's based on the idea that God is sovereign, so there can be no free will, because if there were, God wouldn't be sovereign.

The problem with that logic is that if God is sovereign then He can choose to make man in His Own image, and being God has free will, so must his children or they wouldn't be made in His Own image. The Calvinist is thus reduced to telling God He can't do that, which violates his own logic.

Being sovereign God can choose to not know something and not control something (there are biblical examples). Who is man to tell God He can't do that?
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Life, the Bible, and God are all about freewill. God gave man freewill. And Jesus is not the Father but he and the Father are one. The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.
Oh boy...here we go... eek
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Then there is no such thing as sin. crazy


You should look up how many times the words "choose", "chose", and "choice" are used throughout Scripture.

You can't have a choice, without free will.


You should read the entire Bible as I have many times. Read Romans 8&9 and Matthew 13. There is no such thing as free will. If there were, then we'd be God and God would be nothing. Sin is a moot point. The original sin is why we are where we are. God doesn't care about our sins. You're either predestined to Heaven or predestined to hell and nothing can change that. Does God know everything? Can he be mistaken? He knew where you were going and what you'd do be fore you were born.I rest my case.



You're misunderstanding predestination. Many do. God in his omniscience and sovereignty knows exactly what we'll do and what choices we will make. He knows who will get in and who won't. But he doesn't send anyone to hell. Our individual choices do that. He just knows what those choices will be before we even make them.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Christians believe in predestination as the Bible teaches, churchist don't believe. Free will is taught by the church as a means of control since that's the reason churches exist.



You know just enough to get yourself into trouble.
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


That's the Calvinist position and it's based on the idea that God is sovereign, so there can be no free will, because if there were, God wouldn't be sovereign.

The problem with that logic is that if God is sovereign then He can choose to make man in His Own image, and being God has free will, so must his children or they wouldn't be made in His Own image. The Calvinist is thus reduced to telling God He can't do that, which violates his own logic.

Being sovereign God can choose to not know something and not control something (there are biblical examples). Who is man to tell God He can't do that?



Very well said.
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Life, the Bible, and God are all about freewill. God gave man freewill. And Jesus is not the Father but he and the Father are one. The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.


In a similar way that I am a father, I am a son, and I am a Husband. Three different persons in one at the same exact time.
God is so all knowing that he even knows what is going to happen, if, what is going to happen doesn't happen. wink
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


Life, the Bible, and God are all about freewill. God gave man freewill. And Jesus is not the Father but he and the Father are one. The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.


In a similar way that I am a father, I am a son, and I am a Husband. Three different persons in one at the same exact time.



No, they are indeed three separate persons. Else who did Christ spend all that time praying to? And remember Christ said, "why callest me good? There is only one good and that is the Father". Who would it have been that turned his back as Jesus was dying on the cross if he was God himself?
Originally Posted by moosemike

No, they are indeed three separate persons. Else who did Christ spend all that time praying to? And remember Christ said, "why callest me good? There is only one good and that is the Father". Who would it have been that turned his back as Jesus was dying on the cross if he was God himself?


Who raised Jesus from the dead?

God raised Jesus from the dead: "...that if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved." (Romans 10:9).

"In Him you were also circumcised with the circumcision made without hands...by the circumcision of Christ, buried with Him in baptism, in which you also were raised with Him through faith in the working of God, who raised Him from the dead. (Colossians 2:11-12)

"He indeed was foreordained before the foundation of the world, but was manifest in these last times for you who through Him believe in God, who raised Him from the dead and gave Him glory, so that your faith and hope are in God." (1 Peter 1:20-21)

"And God both raised up the Lord and will also raise us up by His power." (1 Corinthians 6:14)

"Him, being delivered by the determined purpose and foreknowledge of God, you have taken by lawless hands, have crucified, and put to death; whom God raised up, having loosed the pains of death, because it was not possible that He should be held by it." (Acts 2:23-24)

"But you denied the Holy One and the Just, and asked for a murderer to be granted to you, and killed the Prince of life, whom God raised from the dead, of which we are witnesses." (Acts 3:14-15)

"But God raised Him from the dead. He was seen for many days by those who came up with Him from Galilee to Jerusalem, who are His witnesses to the people. And we declare to you glad tidings -- that promise which was made to the fathers. God has fulfilled this for us their children, in that He has raised up Jesus...And that He raised Him from the dead, no more to return to corruption, He has spoken thus: 'I will give you the sure mercies of David.'...For David, after he had served his own generation by the will of God, fell asleep, was buried with his fathers, and saw corruption; but He whom God raised up saw no corruption." (Acts 13:30-37)

"Now may the God of peace who brought up our Lord Jesus from the dead, that great Shepherd of the sheep, through the blood of the everlasting covenant, make you complete in every good work to do His will..." (Hebrews 13:20-21)

To wit, the Father of glory:

"Therefore I also...do not cease to give thanks for you, making mention of you in my prayers: that the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory, may give to you the spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of Him...according to the working of His mighty power which He worked in Christ when He raised Him from the dead and seated Him at His right hand in the heavenly places..." (Ephesians 1:15-20).

"Therefore we were buried with Him through baptism into death, that just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life." (Romans 6:4)

"Paul, an apostle (not from men nor through man, but through Jesus Christ and God the Father who raised Him from the dead)..." (Galatians 1:1)

"For they themselves declare concerning us what manner of entry we had to you, and how you turned to God from idols to serve the living and true God, and to wait for His Son from heaven, whom He raised from the dead, even Jesus who delivers us from the wrath to come." (1 Thessalonians 1:9-10).

But wait, God the Son raised Himself from the dead:

"Jesus answered and said to them, 'Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.' Then the Jews said, 'It has taken forty-six years to build this temple, and will You raise it up in three days?' But He was speaking of the temple of His body. Therefore, when He had risen from the dead, His disciples remembered that He had said this to them; and they believed the Scripture and the word which Jesus had said." (John 2:19-22)

"Therefore My Father loves Me, because I lay down My life that I may take it again. No one takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself. I have power to lay it down, and I have power to take it again. This command I have received from My Father." (John 10:17-18)

Not to be left out, the Holy Spirit raised Jesus from the dead:

"But if the Spirit of Him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, He who raised Christ from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through His Spirit who dwells in you." (Romans 8:11)

"For Christ also suffered once for sins, the just for the unjust, that He might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive by the Spirit..." (1 Peter 3:18)

So what Biblical conclusion can be reached from these facts? That God has authored confusion? Or that the one God who raised Jesus from the dead is Father, Son and Holy Spirit?






Now, I could keep going but I am sure people are tired of this already...
You Alone are Holy

Who alone is Holy? Only One, in the fullest sense: the Lord God Almighty: "Great and marvelous are Your works, Lord God Almighty! Just and true are Your ways, O King of the saints! Who shall not fear You, O Lord, and glorify Your name? For You alone are Holy..." (Revelation 15:4).

"No one is holy like the LORD, For there is none besides You, Nor is there any rock like our God." (1 Samuel 2:2).

Or Jesus?, "The God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, the God of our fathers, glorified His Servant Jesus, whom you delivered up and denied in the presence of Pilate, when he was determined to let Him go. But you denied the Holy One and the Just, and asked for a murderer to be granted to you, and killed the Prince of life, whom God raised from the dead, of which we are witnesses." (Acts 3:13-15).

"For you will not leave my soul in Sheol, Nor will You allow Your Holy One to see corruption." (Psalm 16:10).

The Holy Spirit: "But you have an anointing from the Holy One, and you know all things." (1 John 2:20).

Not to mention the Father: "Now I am no longer in the world, but these are in the world, and I come to You. Holy Father, keep through Your name those whom You have given Me, that they may be one as We are." (John 17:11).

The One God, worshipped and adored, is alone Holy:
Who was Jesus praying to when he asked if this cup could be removed from him? Who was he referring to when he said " not my will Father but thine"? His will and the Fathers weren't lining up at that moment (until he came around to God's way of thinking) so how could he be the exact same person as God the Father? Is God schizophrenic?
Who Sanctifies Believers?

God the Father sanctifies believers: "Jude, a bondservant of Jesus Christ, and brother of James, To those who are called, sanctified by God the Father, and preserved in Jesus Christ: Mercy, peace, and love be multiplied to you." (Jude 1:1-2).

The Holy Spirit: "Peter, an apostle of Jesus Christ, To the pilgrims of the Dispersion in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, in sanctification of the Spirit, for obedience and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ: Grace to you and peace be multiplied." (1 Peter 1:1-2).

"But we are bound to give thanks to God always for you, brethren beloved of the Lord, because God from the beginning chose you for salvation through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth, to which He called you by our gospel, for the obtaining of the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ." (2 Thessalonians 2:13-14).

The Son: "For both He who sanctifies and those who are being sanctified are all of one, for which reason He is not ashamed to call them brethren, saying: 'I will declare Your name to My brethren; in the midst of the assembly I will sing praise to You.'" (Hebrews 2:11-12).

"By that will we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all...For by one offering He has perfected forever those who are being sanctified." (Hebrews 10:10-14).

"Husbands, love your wives, just as Christ also loved the church and gave Himself for her, that He might sanctify and cleanse her with the washing of water by the word, that He might present her to Himself a glorious church, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but that she should be holy and without blemish." (Ephesians 5:25-27).

To sum up, the One God who is Father, Son and Holy Spirit sanctifies His people:

"Speak also to the children of Israel, saying: 'Surely My Sabbaths you shall keep, for it is a sign between Me and you throughout your generations, that you may know that I am the LORD who sanctifies you.'" (Exodus 31:13, Leviticus 20:8);

Now may the God of peace Himself sanctify you completely; and may your whole spirit, soul, and body be preserved blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ." (1 Thessalonians 5:23).
What you're not understanding is the three work together as one and can often be used interchangably. You're picking at nits.
Billy Graham said of the Trinity;" Explain it, I cannot, but I know it exists in a form we cannot know."

I guess it's good that some of y'all are more gifted than Billy.
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by MacLorry
Originally Posted by Swampman700
There is no such thing as free will.


That's the Calvinist position and it's based on the idea that God is sovereign, so there can be no free will, because if there were, God wouldn't be sovereign.

The problem with that logic is that if God is sovereign then He can choose to make man in His Own image, and being God has free will, so must his children or they wouldn't be made in His Own image. The Calvinist is thus reduced to telling God He can't do that, which violates his own logic.

Being sovereign God can choose to not know something and not control something (there are biblical examples). Who is man to tell God He can't do that?



Very well said.


Take this concept and apply it to your questions about three separate beings....

You're telling God that He can't be One. Applying the limitations of man to God, when Scripture is full of proof that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are one being, one person, one God...
Originally Posted by moosemike
Who was Jesus praying to when he asked if this cup could be removed from him? Who was he referring to when he said " not my will Father but thine"? His will and the Fathers weren't lining up at that moment (until he came around to God's way of thinking) so how could he be the exact same person as God the Father? Is God schizophrenic?



Again I ask?
Originally Posted by curdog4570
Billy Graham said of the Trinity;" Explain it, I cannot, but I know it exists in a form we cannot know."

I guess it's good that some of y'all are more gifted than Billy.


Billy Graham put his shoes on the same way the rest of us do. He was a great preacher but I won't set him on a pedestal above anyone else who does the will of the Father.
Originally Posted by moosemike
What you're not understanding is the three work together as one and can often be used interchangably. You're picking at nits.


No, I understand what you're trying to say. It just doesn't hold up to Scripture is all. Here is more...

Who Gives Eternal Life?

The Son: "And I give them eternal life, and they shall never perish; neither shall anyone snatch them out of My hand." (John 10:28).

"Jesus said to her, 'I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in Me, though he may die, he shall live.'" (John 11:25).

God the Father: "For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord." (Romans 6:23).

"For as the Father has life in Himself, so He has granted the Son to have life in Himself..." (John 5:26).

The Spirit: "For he who sows to his flesh will of the flesh reap corruption, but he who sows to the Spirit will of the Spirit reap everlasting life." (Galatians 6:8).

"For the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus has made me free from the law of sin and death." (Romans 8:2).

The living God: "Now see that I, even I, am He, And there is no God besides Me; I kill and I make alive; I wound and I heal; Nor is there any who can deliver from My hand." (Deuteronomy 32:39) - namely, "But you, beloved, building yourselves up on your most holy faith, praying in the Holy Spirit, keep yourselves in the love of God, looking for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ unto eternal life." (Jude 1:20-21).

"'Then you shall know that I am the LORD, when I have opened your graves, O My people, and brought you up from your graves. I will put My Spirit in you, and you shall live, and I will place you in your own land. Then you shall know that I, the LORD, have spoken it and performed it,' says the LORD." (Ezekiel 37:13-14).



Like I said, I can keep going.... The Bible is overwhelmingly clear... It's one person.
Originally Posted by moosemike
Who was Jesus praying to when he asked if this cup could be removed from him? Who was he referring to when he said " not my will Father but thine"? His will and the Fathers weren't lining up at that moment (until he came around to God's way of thinking) so how could he be the exact same person as God the Father? Is God schizophrenic?
This thread makes me think that I'm listening to Hottentots diagnosing the gastro-intestinal problems of unicorns or mermaids.
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by moosemike
Who was Jesus praying to when he asked if this cup could be removed from him? Who was he referring to when he said " not my will Father but thine"? His will and the Fathers weren't lining up at that moment (until he came around to God's way of thinking) so how could he be the exact same person as God the Father? Is God schizophrenic?



Again I ask?


Again I reply...

Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by MacLorry

That's the Calvinist position and it's based on the idea that God is sovereign, so there can be no free will, because if there were, God wouldn't be sovereign.

The problem with that logic is that if God is sovereign then He can choose to make man in His Own image, and being God has free will, so must his children or they wouldn't be made in His Own image. The Calvinist is thus reduced to telling God He can't do that, which violates his own logic.

Being sovereign God can choose to not know something and not control something (there are biblical examples). Who is man to tell God He can't do that?



Very well said.


Originally Posted by Hugajackass
Take this concept and apply it to your questions about three separate beings....

You're telling God that He can't be One. Applying the limitations of man to God, when Scripture is full of proof that God, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit are one being, one person, one God...
Originally Posted by moosemike
Originally Posted by moosemike
Who was Jesus praying to when he asked if this cup could be removed from him? Who was he referring to when he said " not my will Father but thine"? His will and the Fathers weren't lining up at that moment (until he came around to God's way of thinking) so how could he be the exact same person as God the Father? Is God schizophrenic?


I've answered it twice, not going to bother doing it again. Obviously, in spite of overwhelming evidence, you've made up your mind. You're not even looking at, nor considering the Scriptures that I've brought into this conversation...
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
This thread makes me think that I'm listening to Hottentots diagnosing the gastro-intestinal problems of unicorns or mermaids.


You're so wrong! Mermaids don't have gastro-intestinal problems. They fart love... grin
You haven't answered it even once. You've artfully dodged it. You a politician? If not you missed a heck of a chance at it.
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
This thread makes me think that I'm listening to Hottentots diagnosing the gastro-intestinal problems of unicorns or mermaids.


It weren't this way until the "christians" took over the conversation.grin
Originally Posted by moosemike
You haven't answered it even once. You've artfully dodged it. You a politician? If not you missed a heck of a chance at it.


You can't have it both ways. If that's a dodge, then your comment on predestination was a dodge...

At least we both agree on that topic! grin


Meanwhile, you've not once addressed any of the myriads of Scripture I've put up there.....and I can keep going.... there are a ton more cases where it's clear, "Hear O' Israel, the LORD, your God, is One."
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
This thread makes me think that I'm listening to Hottentots diagnosing the gastro-intestinal problems of unicorns or mermaids.


You're so wrong! Mermaids don't have gastro-intestinal problems. They fart love... grin

DeFlave AND Mermaids fart love...?

Man, Theology is confusing... frown
Pastoral Supply

Who supplies pastors to the church? The living God, of course: "And I will give you shepherds according to My heart, who will feed you with knowledge and understanding." (Jeremiah 3:15).

"And you shall say to them, 'Thus says the LORD: "If you will not listen to Me, to walk in My law which I have set before you, to heed the words of My servants the prophets whom I sent to you, both rising up early and sending them (but you have not heeded), then I will make this house like Shiloh, and will make this city a curse to all the nations of the earth."'" (Jeremiah 26:4-6).

That is, the Father: "So He said to them, 'You will indeed drink My cup, and be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with; but to sit on My right hand and on My left is not Mine to give, but it is for those for whom it is prepared by My Father.'" (Matthew 20:23).

The ascended One, the Christ: "And He Himself gave some to be apostles, some prophets, some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints for the work of ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ..." (Ephesians 4:11-12).

"These twelve Jesus sent out and commanded them, saying: 'Do not go into the way of the Gentiles, and do not enter a city of the Samaritans.'" (Matthew 10:5).

"This He spoke, signifying by what death he would glorify God. And when He had spoken this, He said to him, 'Follow Me.'" (John 21:19).

"And I thank Christ Jesus our Lord who has enabled me, because He counted me faithful, putting me into the ministry..." (1 Timothy 1:12).

The Holy Spirit: "Therefore take heed to yourselves and to all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the church of God which He purchased with His own blood." (Acts 20:28).

"As they ministered to the Lord and fasted, the Holy Spirit said, 'Now separate to Me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them.'" (Acts 13:2).

In summary: the One God who is Father, Son and Holy Spirit!


Who Draws Believers?

The Father: "No one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him; and I will raise him up at the last day." (John 6:44).

"And He said, 'Therefore I have said to you that no one can come to Me unless it has been granted to him by My Father.'" (John 6:65).

The Son: "And I, if I am lifted up from the earth, will draw all peoples to Myself." (John 12:32).

The Holy Spirit, who convicts us of sin: "And when He has come, He will convict the world of sin, and of righteousness, and of judgment..." (John 16:8).


Who Regenerates Believers?

Whose special work is the act of regeneration, the 'second birth?' God the Father:

"Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, which according to his abundant mercy hath begotten us again unto a lively hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead. . ." (1 Peter 1:3).

Christ (He who will appear "at his coming"):

"And now, little children, abide in him; that, when he shall appear, we may have confidence, and not be ashamed before him at his coming. If ye know that he is righteous, ye know that every one that doeth righteousness is born of him." (1 John 2:28-29).

"Being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, by the word of God, which liveth and abideth for ever." (1 Peter 1:23).

Or the Spirit:

"But after that the kindness and love of God our Saviour toward man appeared, Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us, by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost; Which he shed on us abundantly through Jesus Christ our Saviour; That being justified by his grace, we should be made heirs according to the hope of eternal life." (Titus 3:4-7).

"Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.
That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit.
Marvel not that I said unto thee, Ye must be born again.
The wind bloweth where it listeth, and thou hearest the sound thereof, but canst not tell whence it cometh, and whither it goeth: so is every one that is born of the Spirit." (John 3:5-8).

That is to say, we are born again of God:

"But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name: Which were born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of man, but of God." (John 1:12-13).

The Comforter

Who is the believer's comforter? Who stands besides and pleads for us? That's easy, the Holy Spirit:

"And I will pray the Father, and he shall give you another Comforter, that he may abide with you for ever; Even the Spirit of truth; whom the world cannot receive, because it seeth him not, neither knoweth him: but ye know him; for he dwelleth with you, and shall be in you. I will not leave you comfortless: I will come to you." (John 14:16-18).

But as "another" already implies, Jesus, speaking in John 14:16, is Himself a comforter:

"My little children, these things write I unto you, that ye sin not. And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous:. . ." (1 John 2:1).

The Rabbis who wrote the Talmud knew that the Messiah was a Comforter: "Others say: His name is Menahem the son of Hezekiah, for it is written, 'Because Menahem ['the comforter'], that would relieve my soul, is far.' [Lam. I, 16.]" (Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Sanhedrin, 98b).

Or, it may be, the Father:

"Blessed be God, even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of mercies, and the God of all comfort; Who comforteth us in all our tribulation, that we may be able to comfort them which are in any trouble, by the comfort wherewith we ourselves are comforted of God." (2 Corinthians 1:3-4).

Tempting in the Wilderness

God the Father blames the the Israel of Isaiah's day as rebellious children: "Hear, O heavens, and give ear, O earth: for the LORD hath spoken, I have nourished and brought up children, and they have rebelled against me." (Isaiah 1:2).

To get down to cases, whom did Israel tempt in the wilderness? The living God:

"Wherefore the people did chide with Moses, and said, Give us water that we may drink. And Moses said unto them, Why chide ye with me? wherefore do ye tempt the LORD? And the people thirsted there for water; and the people murmured against Moses, and said, Wherefore is this that thou hast brought us up out of Egypt, to kill us and our children and our cattle with thirst? . .And he called the name of the place Massah, and Meribah, because of the chiding of the children of Israel, and because they tempted the LORD, saying, Is the LORD among us, or not?" (Exodus 17:1-7).

Moses, looking back on these various rebellions, sees the injured party as Israel's "father:" "They have corrupted themselves, their spot is not the spot of his children: they are a perverse and crooked generation. Do ye thus requite the LORD, O foolish people and unwise? is not he thy father that hath bought thee? hath he not made thee, and established thee?" (Deuteronomy 32:5-6). Moses delivered a harsh verdict: "Ye have been rebellious against the LORD from the day that I knew you." (Deuteronomy 9:24).

In one specific incident, God sent fiery serpents against Israel when they rebelled:

"And the people spake against God, and against Moses, Wherefore have ye brought us up out of Egypt to die in the wilderness? for there is no bread, neither is there any water; and our soul loatheth this light bread. And the LORD sent fiery serpents among the people, and they bit the people; and much people of Israel died. Therefore the people came to Moses, and said, We have sinned, for we have spoken against the LORD, and against thee; pray unto the LORD, that he take away the serpents from us. And Moses prayed for the people." (Numbers 21:5-7).

As remembered in the Psalms, they tempted God:

"They soon forgat his works; they waited not for his counsel: But lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert." (Psalm 106:13-14).

"And they sinned yet more against him by provoking the most High in the wilderness. And they tempted God in their heart by asking meat for their lust. Yea, they spake against God; they said, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?. . . How oft did they provoke him in the wilderness, and grieve him in the desert! Yea, they turned back and tempted God, and limited the Holy One of Israel." (Psalm 78:18-41).

Those destroyed by serpents in the wilderness had tempted Christ, says Paul:

"Neither let us tempt Christ, as some of them also tempted, and were destroyed of serpents." (1 Corinthians 10:9).

Psalm 95 retells the story of the wilderness failures:

"For he is our God; and we are the people of his pasture, and the sheep of his hand. To day if ye will hear his voice, Harden not your heart, as in the provocation, and as in the day of temptation in the wilderness: When your fathers tempted me, proved me, and saw my work." (Psalm 95:7-9)

Who is the speaker who says "To day if you will hear his voice?" The Holy Spirit:

"Wherefore (as the Holy Ghost saith, To day if ye will hear his voice, Harden not your hearts, as in the provocation, in the day of temptation in the wilderness: When your fathers tempted me, proved me, and saw my works forty years.)" (Hebrews 3:7-9).

Another scripture that recalls the Holy Spirit as the victimized party is Isaiah 63:10, "But they rebelled, and vexed his holy Spirit: therefore he was turned to be their enemy, and he fought against them."

Who did Israel tempt in the wilderness? The one God who is Father, Son and Holy Spirit.






and on.....and on.....and on....
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
This thread makes me think that I'm listening to Hottentots diagnosing the gastro-intestinal problems of unicorns or mermaids.


You're so wrong! Mermaids don't have gastro-intestinal problems. They fart love... grin

DeFlave AND Mermaids fart love...?

Man, Theology is confusing... frown


They fart different kinds of love you see... grin

Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Man defining God just confuses man and makes him bigoted toward other man.

Kent
"No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father." - Mark 13:32


Doesn't this verse mean that they are indeed 3 separate individuals.?
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
"No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father." - Mark 13:32


Doesn't this verse mean that they are indeed 3 separate individuals.?



Yes. but HAJA is one of those individuals who is determined to have the last word so I quit arguing with him even though I could. Otherwise that would be all I would get done today and the thread would grow by 27 pages today. grin
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
"No one knows about that day or hour, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father." - Mark 13:32


Doesn't this verse mean that they are indeed 3 separate individuals.?


Nope. The cool thing about Jesus is that He was fully God and fully man at the same time. Restricting Himself to being a man He had limitations.

Originally Posted by Colossians 1:9-18
Preeminence of Christ

9 For this reason we also, since the day we heard it, do not cease to pray for you, and to ask that you may be filled with the knowledge of His will in all wisdom and spiritual understanding; 10 that you may walk worthy of the Lord, fully pleasing Him, being fruitful in every good work and increasing in the knowledge of God; 11 strengthened with all might, according to His glorious power, for all patience and longsuffering with joy; 12 giving thanks to the Father who has qualified us to be partakers of the inheritance of the saints in the light. 13 He has delivered us from the power of darkness and conveyed us into the kingdom of the Son of His love, 14 in whom we have redemption through His blood,[c] the forgiveness of sins.

15 He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn over all creation. 16 For by Him all things were created that are in heaven and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers. All things were created through Him and for Him. 17 And He is before all things, and in Him all things consist. 18 And He is the head of the body, the church, who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead, that in all things He may have the preeminence.


and again...

"For in Him all the fullness of Deity dwells in bodily form." - Colossians 2:9
So while he was man nobody was God since you say he "had restrictions". We all know God doesn't have restrictions as to what he can know.

Some peoples learning curves look just like circles. grin
And stupidity ain't just skin deep for some.

Didn't you own up to being a preacher on another thread awhile back?
I'm still betting they're 3 individuals, even though Mermaids do Fart love and Unicorn eat a steady diet of Bacon...

"But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you." John 14:26 (KJV)

IMO, This verse shows 3 separate individuals.

You have the "Comforter"(Holy Ghost,..not Space Ghost), the "Father"(God), and "my name"(Jesus).

If they were all the same person, the verse would read something like,...Jesus: "Guys, wait here, I'm going out to the phone booth to change into the Holy Spirit, then we can hang out and I'll give you guys guidance for the rest of your life."

Jesus has to go away before the Holy Spirit is sent. Acts 1:4 clearly tells the disciples to wait for the HS to show up. It it were all the same "individual" they wouldn't have to wait.....



"So then after the Lord had spoken unto them, he was received up into heaven, and sat on the right hand of God." - Mark 16:19

Christ is sitting at the right hand of God,..they're not sharing the same chair. Unless it's a Gigantic Holy Bean Bag chair, then all bets are off.....

Quote
The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.


Kinda like I am a husband, a dad and an employee. Only Sue knows me as a husband. My kids know me in a different way. The boss knows me as though I am merely a worker. I guess that's three different people.
Jesus said, "Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, 20 teaching them to observe all that I commanded you; and lo, I am with you [f]always, even to the end of the age."

So, is He with us or is He at a physical location, at the right hand of the Father? Is He the one with us, or is it another person, namely the Holy Spirit? The answer is both are true because they are both the same person. smile

Just like we are flesh, spirit, and soul, so was Jesus. His Spirit is the Holy Spirit...
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.


Kinda like I am a husband, a dad and an employee. Only Sue knows me as a husband. My kids know me in a different way. The boss knows me as though I am merely a worker. I guess that's three different people.


I said almost the same thing...

I'm a father, son, and husband...
Originally Posted by Deerwhacker444
I'm still betting they're 3 individuals, even though Mermaids do Fart love and Unicorn eat a steady diet of Bacon...

"But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you." John 14:26 (KJV)

IMO, This verse shows 3 separate individuals.

You have the "Comforter"(Holy Ghost,..not Space Ghost), the "Father"(God), and "my name"(Jesus).

If they were all the same person, the verse would read something like,...Jesus: "Guys, wait here, I'm going out to the phone booth to change into the Holy Spirit, then we can hang out and I'll give you guys guidance for the rest of your life."

Jesus has to go away before the Holy Spirit is sent. Acts 1:4 clearly tells the disciples to wait for the HS to show up. It it were all the same "individual" they wouldn't have to wait.....



"So then after the Lord had spoken unto them, he was received up into heaven, and sat on the right hand of God." - Mark 16:19

Christ is sitting at the right hand of God,..they're not sharing the same chair. Unless it's a Gigantic Holy Bean Bag chair, then all bets are off.....



In the same chapter you quote, Acts 1, Jesus says "You will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes upon you, and you shall be witnesses to ME..."

Are they going to witness the Holy Spirit working or witness Jesus working?

Both, it's the same person winksmile
Jesus was indeed received up in Heaven and he sat upon the throne. Then, He came in Spirit form as the Holy Spirit....

The disciples had no problem recognizing that Jesus was in fact God, Himself...

Thomas answered and said to Him, �My Lord and my God!� John 20:28
You've already mentioned that God is "outside the box". Our rules don't apply. No Problem, I'll buy that. In that same line of thought, it doesn't bother me to think of 3 separate entities that have separate functions, but are the same or equal.

I know that it's an over simplification and I'll get flamed, but in my mind the Godhead resembles a 3 headed Hydra. Take a Hydra and cut it into 3 pieces, they're all alive and have the same DNA but they're separate individuals that all came from the same initial being. Same idea except on a spiritual level...
Quote
I said almost the same thing...

I'm a father, son, and husband...


You beat me to it. But I am not in your league for spouting Scripture. Keep it up!
No flame from me, man.

We can disagree without flaming each other. In this case, we do. I can live with that. smile


BTW, I love Space Ghost Coast to Coast, so your reference totally cracked me up... laugh

Oh, if you're interested you can scroll back a few pages, you'll see where I showed that the Comforter isn't just the Holy Spirit. All three were called that throughout Scripture. smile
Yeah,..we'll see when we get up there.

I'll play a game of Bridge with the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.

Best you'll be able to do with your GodHead will be Tic/Tac/Toe.... wink

Yeah,...several billion years ago this gas clustered together in the void of space.

After several billion more years, if kinda swarmed together and turned into a rock.

Billions upon billions of more years passed, and Don Ross appeared on the rock, composed and performed Tight, Trite, Night on a box with some strings on it.

*shrugg*,...it just kinda happened,...nobody did it.

Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Recent haggling - getting BORING !!

[Linked Image]
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/15/13
Originally Posted by CCCC
Originally Posted by PS1080
Religious people love taking cheap shots at science. The same science that makes it possible for them to mentally masturbate at their computer all day or that has saved their lives or a loved ones through modern medicine. They go on and on that something can't come from nothing. Yet this is how they explain the existence of their god. He just was. It's really pathetic to watch these people brag about choosing ignorance. Not to surprising considering their entire life they're read one book and completely missed it's main message. If Jesus was real he'd put a boot up there a$$ for being such aholes.
Your post indicates that you just might be one of the minor tribulations that Christians sometimes must encounter. But, a person should avoid being judgmental on the basis of scant evidence. So, to help better understand your statements about -
- what one might love to do;
- one's choice for ignorance;
- one's choices in literature;
- the basis for your pathos; and,
- to help determine if one is that of which you speak - - and for openers - -

kindly give your definition of "Religious people".

PS 1080 - still waiting !
He's busy........... building another "strawman".

That's easier than answering questions in a debate with a live person.
I'd as soon get in a fist fight with some of these guys than to "argue" scripture, but fighting a battle of wits ? ? ? ? ? ? Fergit it! laugh
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
curdog4570, you can be a jewel when you feel like it.
It's pretty clear none of you know anything about the Bible. You should read it sometime.
Posted By: 1B Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Ken,

You stirred up all the baboons to show their blue asses and then bailed on the scene?

You have more depth to you than I thought.

1B
Then don't show your's.
Originally Posted by HugAJackass
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
The Holy Trinity is three separate entities that work together in unity as one.


Kinda like I am a husband, a dad and an employee. Only Sue knows me as a husband. My kids know me in a different way. The boss knows me as though I am merely a worker. I guess that's three different people.


I said almost the same thing...

I'm a father, son, and husband...


There is no Trinity. Constantine dreamed that up in 325AD. Polytheism is paganism.
Originally Posted by Swampman700
It's pretty clear none of you know anything about the Bible. You should read it sometime.

Originally Posted by Swampman700

There is no Trinity. Constantine dreamed that up in 325AD. Polytheism is paganism.



[Linked Image]
Insults is all you got because I'm right.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Insults is all you got because I'm right.
You fail. No insult intended, but no sensible person would bother to be insulted by foolish words from one who seems not sound of mind and with little control over what emanates from his mouth - or keyboard..
Originally Posted by Swampman700
Insults is all you got because I'm right.


Often wrong............. never in doubt. That would be you, whether the topic be guns, or the Bible.
Never wrong and never in doubt....about both.
By grace alone, through faith alone, to God alone be the glory. I belong to Jesus.
Quote
By grace alone, to God alone be the glory.


Amen!

Quote
through faith alone,


What happened to,
"Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead itself. But someone will say, 'You have faith, and I have works; show me your faith without the works, and I will show you my faith by my works.' You believe that God is One. You do well; the demons also believe, and shudder. But are you willing to recognize, you foolish fellow, that faith without works is useless?"
Posted By: PS1080 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
CCCC & Curdog
Sorry I didn't realize you guy were still stroking each other over this lame topic. I haven't been busy building a straw man I'm pig hunting in the Texas panhandle. Which is way more fun than any church. So for now I'll have to leave you guys to discuss mermaids , unicorns, Jesus, the Bible or whatever make believe stuff you choose. I'm sorta busy having fun here in in the real world. Hope you guys get to visit it some day it's awesome!
Very lame, PS.
Originally Posted by Ringman
Quote
By grace alone, to God alone be the glory.


Amen!

Quote
through faith alone,


What happened to,
"Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead itself. But someone will say, 'You have faith, and I have works; show me your faith without the works, and I will show you my faith by my works.' You believe that God is One. You do well; the demons also believe, and shudder. But are you willing to recognize, you foolish fellow, that faith without works is useless?"




It has been my experience that faith in God and love of your neighbor will ALWAYS result in a person doing good works. Faith alone is an empty shell. Faith with works is a beautiful thing ... indeed, it is the Meaning of Life.

God Bless,

Steve


Ephesians 2:8 and following has always been a favorite passage of mine. It tells that faith was given to man by God's grace alone.

James was suggesting that men of faith naturally do works pleasing to God out of love for what God (Jesus) did for man. These men of faith accept/ed what God had said was truth and, knowing they shouldn't be given any grace at all (only by the Holy Spirit working through the gospel could they/we learn this) were all the more thankful for it!

It is therefore not the works that save, but rather the faith in what God has said in the gospel about Jesus that does. The Holy Spirit sees to it that works will naturally flow out of this love (faith) for Jesus' accomplishments.

I am with Ken on this; I too trust in Jesus' decisions. He was most definately vocal about making His truths known and never did He "beat around the bush." I accept as truth that when He said "I am the way and the truth and the life" and then "No one comes to the Father except through Me" He meant it! (I'm reasonably certain that this is one "I AM" statement Dr. Ken will approve of wink )

To some here I say peace!

I am not certain why God chose man to be His message bringers to spread His Gospel. I do believe that He would be happier if those words we spoke were somewhat more edifying to the hearers. I also know that when I personally stepped in and tried to supplant the Holy Spirit from His work..."my" work never worked at all wink

peace to you all,

bhtr
Originally Posted by CCCC
curdog4570, you can be a jewel when you feel like it.


Thanks,,,,,,,,, but an old chunk of coal is probably more apt. grin
Quote
Ephesians 2:8 and following has always been a favorite passage of mine. It tells that faith was given to man by God's grace alone.


James tells us all good things come from God.

Quote
James was suggesting that men of faith naturally do works pleasing to God out of love for what God (Jesus) did for man.


Was that in the James quote above? I missed it. What I have seen are people claiming to be saved by faith but display absolutely no difference in their lives and professed atheist.

Originally Posted by PS1080
CCCC & Curdog
Sorry I didn't realize you guy were still stroking each other over this lame topic. I haven't been busy building a straw man I'm pig hunting in the Texas panhandle. Which is way more fun than any church. So for now I'll have to leave you guys to discuss mermaids , unicorns, Jesus, the Bible or whatever make believe stuff you choose. I'm sorta busy having fun here in in the real world. Hope you guys get to visit it some day it's awesome!


If you look to the left of any of my posts, you'll see that I don't have to buy a non-resident license. And I went to school in Mc Lean and Pampa, worked from Dumas South, and as far as hog hunting, I've killed my share.

I wouldn't have bothered to make this post just to point all that out. I just want to point THIS out:

When I embarked on the spiritual [not religious] life, It was suggested to me that I not go anyplace where God won't fit, or do anything I couldn't do in a "spiritual fashion".

Rather than restricting my "freedom", I discovered that the spiritual approach added to my enjoyment in the REAL world, as you call it.

When those Indian ancestors of mine prayed to the Great Spirit, they were praying to Jesus. Since there is only one God, an earnest prayer can't be directed elsewhere.

Nowhere that I've found in Scripture does it state that the supplicant has to KNOW that he is praying to the Jesus that was crucified for his sins. In fact, if any of the Apostles heard me pronounce the name,"Jesus", they would not recognize it.

Now, I don't ask God for a successful hunt. My prayer is really pretty simple; "It is enough just to be here, I ask for nothing more".

I can say that same prayer at a crap table.

And have.

We have folks posting on this thread, and CCCC may be one, who disagree with my way of "being a christian".

So............ you establishing your "religious people" strawman does nothing but condemn you to eternal ignorance of the various ways we Christians can come to THE WAY, THE TRUTH, And THE LIFE.

I'm goin' fishin' shortly........ you have a good day.
To all whom this may apply �

Whatever you, I, CCCC, or Curdog may opine about whether he's a Christian acceptable unto God, the final say in the matter is God's decision alone.

It's between him and God.

Why can't we all just leave it at that?

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =

By the way, a bit of "trivia" that ain't trivial

Note, mull, and remember the fact that the WRITERS and their READERS in the New Testament were all CHRISTIANS. Might make a difference in how you understand what's written there.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
because people just won't quit asking silly questions, and others feel obliged to offer their version of the answer?
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Gus is like a torpid waterfall...

Kent
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Originally Posted by krp
Gus is like a torpid waterfall...

Kent


....apples of gold in pictures of silver. grin
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
And a pocket full of pebbles...

Kent
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
a lot of campfire constituents flow like dark, thick molasses on a hot, buttered biscuit. grin
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Twice once, thrice twice, he bellied up and eight.

Kent
Quote
By the way, a bit of "trivia" that ain't trivial �

Note, mull, and remember the fact that the WRITERS and their READERS in the New Testament were all CHRISTIANS. Might make a difference in how you understand what's written there.


Fun words there, Ken.
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
i like legalism. who first created all those laws to begin with?

could a human exist down here on this plane, without a "law" to abide by?
You pack of butt blasting fools! My God is a forgiving God! See ALL of you on the other side...whether I want to or not!
Sonofabitch!
Posted By: Gus Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
carry on troop. you offer much sincere opinion. and we all are thankful you can express it here on the internet without risk of the gestapo busting your door down at 4am with a no-knock warrant.

you are certainly free to speak. share with us all what you think, as the rest of us will, also.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/16/13
Spect you're right... when I arrive there'll be some exclamations followed by 'sorry God'... and a pile of shekels being lost... wonder what the pool is up to now?

Kent
� and here, you won't hafta think before you speak. Some do � some can't. Yet we all get along � more or less.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/17/13
Originally Posted by Ken Howell
To all whom this may apply � Whatever you, I, CCCC, or Curdog may opine about whether he's a Christian acceptable unto God, the final say in the matter is God's decision alone. It's between him and God. Why can't we all just leave it at that? By the way, a bit of "trivia" that ain't trivial
Note, mull, and remember the fact that the WRITERS and their READERS in the New Testament were all CHRISTIANS. Might make a difference in how you understand what's written there.
Ken, I cannot understand your aim there with your words "whether he's a Christian acceptable unto God". I can't tell who "he" is supposed to be. And, in view of what has been posted, I can't understand why you think your declaration is necessary, particularly in my case (in that you cite me) with regard to God being the sole decision-maker about the acceptability of anyone. Never thought or said anything to the contrary.

Get this straight, now and furthermore (and search all of my posts if you do not believe this to be true). I have no interest in opining, let alone trying to decide, whether or not another person is a Christian, or acceptable unto God. I adhere to the fact that such is well beyond my role or ability. Do not make a mistake about that in my case.

Now, that does not mean that I will not strongly debate what people state (Christians and non-belivers both) and I will challenge them to provide definitions, hard facts and logical explanations to prove their statements. And, if they are so bold as to declare something disagreeable then and so ignorant or cowardly as to refuse to offer proof for what they say, I will tell them that they are behaving as a fool, or coward, or whatever their behavior indicates. That IS within my role and ability. And, I am still waiting for a couple of those types to respond as challenged.

Some would tell me that such belligerence is not Christian behavior. Well, I love the idea of "turn the other cheek" and probably should do so much more frequently - actually feels good sometimes when I manage to do so. But, even with all of the things that God has helped me to do, I have not been very good at cheek-turning.

If a person gets on a thread about Christianity and attacks Christians without cause or basis, or lies, or distorts, or mis-characterizes, or whatever - toward the end of deriding my faith and those who believe likewise - there will be a counterpunch. It does not matter if that person is a Christian or a non-believer - and my posts NEVER are based on opinions or attempted decisions about whether or not that person is a Christian acceptable unto God. If nothing else, get that part straight.
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/17/13
Originally Posted by PS1080
CCCC & Curdog
Sorry I didn't realize you guy were still stroking each other over this lame topic. I haven't been busy building a straw man I'm pig hunting in the Texas panhandle. Which is way more fun than any church. So for now I'll have to leave you guys to discuss mermaids , unicorns, Jesus, the Bible or whatever make believe stuff you choose. I'm sorta busy having fun here in in the real world. Hope you guys get to visit it some day it's awesome!
PS1080, you further demonstrate that your posts are worthless to anyone possessed of good sense and fairness, and that your behavior here is cowardly. Just cast your suspect pearls before those Panhandle swine.
I believe in god and read the bible, as a matter of fact my family bible that has been in the family since the late 1800s site on my night stand i often open it to try and make sense of a Ruth night. I will admit to not going to church to often. I was just brought up to believe that you didn't have to go to a church to worship the God and Jesus.

Jesus is my shepherd and I know that he walks with me everytime I have to face evil. I also know that if he calls me home to his kingdom then he has a reason for that. And when he does i know that I will have things to answer for. But I truly believe that if we weren't meant toile mistakes and sin then we would not be given the chance to do such. I also feel in my heart that our redemption to God comes from acknowledging those mistakes. I hope god and I can sit down over a good single malt and have a grand discussion.
FWIW....... I only mentioned CCCC because the smartass I was replying to had lumped us together.

I don't understand Ken's post, but that's no big deal.

As far as the "trivia"........ it's significance probably is over my head.That's OK, too.
Originally Posted by CCCC
� Ken, I cannot understand your aim there with your words "whether he's a Christian acceptable unto God". I can't tell who "he" is supposed to be. And, in view of what has been posted, I can't understand why you think your declaration is necessary, particularly in my case (in that you cite me) with regard to God being the sole decision-maker about the acceptability of anyone. Never thought or said anything to the contrary. �

1. I did not cite you, Brother Paul � tried, in fact, to indicate clearly that my post was independent of any other post. I'm surprised that you'd think that I did aim my comment at you.
2. Any general comment posted in the first blank space after a post always gets the re: in its header, totally irrespective of the intended focus of that comment.
3. My general address "To all whom this may apply" was specifically intended to eliminate the implication that this inevitable re: was focused on anyone in particular.
4. Jesus specifically said that He won't accept everybody who considers himself acceptable unto Him. On the basis of this and for other Biblical reasons, I understand that the final cut is His decision, not the claimants'.
5. The word you in my post is plural and refers to the carefully unfocused general "To all whom this may apply."
6. The word he in my post is the simpler and handier English equivalent of the words any of the above.
7. The comment that "the final say in the matter is God's decision alone" was only a comment, not meant to lead into a learned or opinionated theological discussion (much less a personal "mine's bigger'n yours" comparison behind the outhouse).
Bellicosity (pugnacity, feistiness) is not a suitable mind set for discussing Christ, Christianity, Christians, or matters of the Spirit. 'Sno basis for peace and good will. laugh

If I appear thus, I apologize herewith (but decline to hammer anyone with a detailed apologia).
When I have something to say on a thread that's not directed at anyone in particular I just reply to my last post. I see I'm not the only one who does that.

Some find these kinds of threads pointless, useless, or even offensive and take the time to leave a comment to that point, but I expect most who feel that way just ignore such threads.

However, I find such discussions useful in gaining understanding of what I consider the most important topic in my life; my relationship with God. If any of my posts have benefited anyone--God be praised. If any of my posts have offended anyone I apologize and admit I have yet a lot to learn of God's Kingdome.
Originally Posted by Gus
i like legalism. who first created all those laws to begin with?

could a human exist down here on this plane, without a "law" to abide by?



"Legalism has its origin in self-worship. If people are justified through their obedience to the law, then they merit praise, honor and glory. Legalism, in other words, means the glory goes to people rather than to God. The true gospel, however, teaches that all human beings are fundamentally flawed by sin, and thus salvation is only available by relying on and trusting in God, who has sent Jesus Christ to atone for sins. God receives the glory and praise in this gospel because in his mercy he saves helpless sinners through the work of Jesus Christ on the cross�The desire to obey the law, though it appears commendable, is actually an insidious way to try to gain recognition before God." - Dr. Tom Schreiner
Posted By: norm99 Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/17/13
Originally Posted by TF49
From LongBob:

"The God described in the Bible is petty and bipolar. I wouldn't doubt there is a higher being, but the Bible does a piss poor job in verifying that. There is as much missing in the Bible as there is bad stuff within.

Who said I need this line of thinking to relieve myself of moral values. It is possible to have morals and values without the need to rely on a Bible or religion."

!!!!!
The problem with this is that one is only "as good as he wants to be." This is a problem common to most, in fact I have it as an major issue. ONLY AS GOOD AS... I.... WANT TO BE. This way I only have to satisfy myself and not some external deity. If one's moral standard comes from within oneself, you don't know what you'll end up with. I suspect that most Muslim suicide bombers do truly believe and believe that their own "internal moral code" justifies their act.

I suspect that ALL of us struggle with this in some way. !!!!


All the best,

tf



the problem with this [and our current culture] is that there are to many horisons .as children need a code of conduct to be instructed in [line in the sand]we also NEED, REQUIRE a horision, absolute truth to follow a path that leads us out of our sinful nature.
AS has been stated we can create gods ,none of which will be greater than ourselves,but can rule over us.[greed of power ,money ,sex, drugs ,cars .toys ,guns,art works .All of these things can take our focus off of a goal that should be Christ [the one Who gave His life that we may live eternally

norm
Charles Stanley had a good sermon this morning titled [b][color:#3333FF]Direction Without Doubt,[/color][/b] if anybody is interested.

I found it helpful...
Posted By: CCCC Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 02/18/13
Thanks, Deerwhacker444.
Charles Stanley had a good sermon this morning asking, [b][color:#3333FF]Are You are Prepared to Die?[/color][/b]

If anybody didn't make it to church this morn. and is needing some Bible study, his message might make you think....good preaching straight from the scripture...
Charles Stanley is on the radio every morning at 5:30 AM during my drive to work.

Listening to him is my daily ritual.
Posted By: krp Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 03/24/13
Most folks are afraid to die... doubt fuels fear which fuels doubt... a never ending circle for some.

Much of the currency of religion is doubt and fear of this life and death...

Instead of the grace and glory as we shed this life of trials.

Kent
"I like your Christ; I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ." - Gandhi
Yup, it's called sin.
Originally Posted by antlers
"I like your Christ; I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ." - Gandhi


This is absolutely correct and it rears its head over and over.

Since Catholics ARE Christians, I guess I am. Do I go? It depends on what side of bed I wake up on. The fact that many of the Christian religions are "guilt" and "fire and brimstone" based can make them a drag. It's really easier to live life without having to wonder if every time you pick your nose you are sinning, and rely on the fact that you are more "good" than "bad" with regard to an afterlife ... which NO ONE knows what that entails.
Posted By: 700LH Re: Who's Christian? Who isn't? - 03/24/13
Originally Posted by antlers
"I like your Christ; I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ." - Gandhi


Yep, once man began to tell other men how he should worship the whole concept is basically ruined
Charles Stanley had a Great message this morning about [b][color:#3333FF]Overcoming Discouragement[/color][/b] if anybody is interested or didn't make it to service this morn...
© 24hourcampfire