To me......
A "fair" camp is one where even the new guy is given to same access and courtesy as the "old" guys.
If he pays his dues, so what if he is lucky enough to kill the biggest buck the club has ever taken? If that happened the old guys should congratulate him.
Also, there is nothing worse than a club that has members paying the same dues, but are limited on what stands and locations they can hunt. Every member should be able to rotate and hunt the same fields and stands. There is noting worse than a club with members complaining about someone else cutting off deer or hunting "their" field or stand.
Rotate things to be fair and don't have designated areas. Designated areas only cause jealousy, resentment and destroy clubs. YMMV
