The typical .45 Colt revolver (think SAA size) is just right for daily carry (in my hands) and will handle the mid-range loads I find to be so effective.
I agree and Colt-sized guns are my favorites for carry and general purpose use. Although I prefer the .44Spl in mid-sized guns such as my custom Old Model Blackhawk .44Spl. Along with several Colt's, USFA's and Uberti sixguns. But this discussion was more about, or became about, the maximum potential of the two options.
The original Ruger flat-top .44's were the same frame size and strength as the Super Blackhawk that eventually replaced it. What made the Super easier to handle was the longer, heavier, steel grip frame.
The only gun Keith ever "blew up" was a Colt .45 and that was just the loading gate.
The Keith 1200fps .44Spl load has been tested many times at 25-26,000psi.
