For real highcountry, multi-day, backpack hunting (not the imaginary, cyber-version of same), a fixed is going to be more stout/reliable than a variable (same brand - brand), as well as being lighter.

Not all BG is the same size, but with a 6x I'm comfortable to 500+ yards on deer-sized game and 600+ on elk in field conditions.

But I'm not going to shoot ANY animal past 600 yards.

A 6X Fixed is KISS and highcountry backpack hunting and KISS go hand in glove. Murphy hates this sort of hunting above sitting in a deer stand, or wandering the wide open shooting coyotes.

That's not to say variables don't have their place, they certainly do. And the extra magnification in a variable is bad how?

Not all tools are intended for the same purpose, any more than an F22 can do the job of a 777... even though they're both airplanes.

One has to determine one's needs based on what and how something is hunted.

But rest assured, EVERY choice is a compromise in one way or the other. You just have to determine how you want to make YOUR compromise...


“Perfection is Achieved Not When There Is Nothing More to Add, But When There Is Nothing Left to Take Away” Antoine de Saint-Exupery