Originally Posted by smokepole


Miles, using words like "biochemical differences" doesn't make your argument any stronger. The effects of serum lead are most certainly different in adults than children, that much is beyond dispute. If that was not true there wouldn't be different standards for children and women of child-bearing age. There are a multitude of substances that affect developing brains differently than adult brains, not only lead but THC and others.

And to make the blanket statement that "any intake is harmful" is just incorrect. Intake does not equal lead in the blood. Any detectable levels of lead in the blood of children and women of child-bearing age is what has been deemed harmful.

Originally Posted by MILES58
Why would someone willingly put a toxic substance into their body?


You need to bone up on your toxicology if you're going to provide opinions on the subject. Everyone willingly puts toxic substances into their body on a daily basis. The most extreme example is water, which is toxic in excessive amounts. It causes hyponatremia, which can be fatal. Alcohol is another good example. A glass of red wine is harmless but a half gallon of vodka can kill you. Other substances like selenium are nutrients in small doses (sold as over-the-counter supplements) and toxic in high doses. The list goes on. To get a deleterious effect you have to consider not only the substance, but the dose.


No, it is not lead in the blood that s the problem. It's the lead replacing calcium in the tissue of the nervous system. Lead in the blood is only the clinical measurement that allows a diagnosis.

When you or anyone else can explain how lead acts differently in the tissues of children and adults you'll have my ear. The effects can be worse, but the action is identical.

re: the Hyponatremia straw man: I saw it coming " Lead is not like substances that can be toxic at high levels, it is quite toxic at extremely low levels.. Lead accumulates, and it is not readily excreted."

Lead is toxic. Lead is always toxic. There is no benefit period to lead ingestion.