Originally Posted by tjm10025

Originally Posted by gmoats
...hence the irrelevancy of anecdotal experiences. I don't know if you ever had the chance to meet and talk with Jim Cirillo ...


I'm just curious. Do you consider Jim Cirillo's experiences to be something other than anecdotal?

Because if you weren't there with him, they certainly weren't personal.

....missed my point completely....probably my fault.....Jim's experiences seem to be polar opposites of those related by Doc....and your .22 yielding Green Beret's experiences are antithetical to just about everyone's whose ever been in armed conflict. As Raisuli said, logic (as well as science and math) have to enter the argument somewhere because you'll ALWAYS be able to find some example to prove any point that you desire to make. David killed Goliath with a sling--sure enough someone, somewhere is going to argue the lethality of rocks as major caliber ammunition.

Last edited by gmoats; 10/20/11.

The blindness from subjectivity is indistinguishable from the darkness of ignorance.