except i don't think he is totally correct on the revolver thing.
My LW Commander can hold 8+1...you have a revolver in a viable defensive cartridge that can hold more than that? And I'm assuming a non-apples to apples comparison. .45 vs .357.
If we went with the closer comparison of .38 Super vs .357 it would be 10+1 vs the 8 for the highest capacity revolver in a viable defensive cartridge I'm aware of.
read again, he was not talking about +1, but mag capacity.
s for the magazine capacity, a 1911 will always have more that a revolver. and 1911 is a generic term, he didn't say anything about a super.