Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Hunter's Campfire Why does everyone hate atheists?

Print Thread

Hop To

Re: Why does everyone hate atheists? byc #11470181 09/29/16
Joined: Nov 2013 Posts: 2,418 Shawangunkill River - NY C cooper57m Campfire Regular
cooper57m Campfire Regular C Joined: Nov 2013 Posts: 2,418 Shawangunkill River - NY	Originally Posted by byc I don't know any atheists. Leastwise, not that I know of. And again I don't hate anyone. Sounds like I would be pleased to meet you - - - and share a good bourbon. Last edited by cooper57m; 09/29/16.

Entire Thread
Title	Posted By	Posted
Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Deerwhacker444	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	bigfish9684	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RWE	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	okie	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Sharpsman	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RockyRaab	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	bigfish9684	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RufusG	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RufusG	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Mannlicher	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	DaveDaDeerslayer	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	PaulBarnard	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Deerwhacker444	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	sbhooper	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	ingwe	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Robert_White	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	DaveDaDeerslayer	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	barm	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	ltppowell	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Robert_White	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	urbaneruralite	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Snyper	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Barkoff	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Boogaloo	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Boogaloo	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	rem141r	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	bruinruin	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	OutlawPatriot	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Robert_White	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	gunner500	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	smokepole	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	gunner500	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	gunner500	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	add	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	byc	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	kingston	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	oldtrapper	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	kingston	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	kingston	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	simonkenton7	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	carbon12	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	HawkI	09/29/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	bigfish9684	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	dassa	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	toad	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	dassa	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Robert_White	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Snyper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	ConradCA	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	09/30/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	victoro	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	justin10mm	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	justin10mm	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	arkypete	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	toad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	toad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Scott F	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	hookeye	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antelope_sniper	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	hookeye	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	hookeye	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	hookeye	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	hookeye	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Dillonbuck	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Sauer200	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RickyD	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Sauer200	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	BarryC	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Sauer200	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RickyD	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/04/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/04/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Sharpsman	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/01/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Snyper	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/04/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	carbon12	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Talus_in_Arizona	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	APDDSN0864	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	TF49	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JGRaider	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	TF49	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	ingwe	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	TF49	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JamesJr	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	cooper57m	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	EdM	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	BFD	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/04/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	TF49	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	TF49	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	seal_billy	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	justin10mm	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/02/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RickyD	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	BarryC	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	AcesNeights	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	jaguartx	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/03/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	10/04/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	NeBassman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	justin10mm	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RickyD	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	carbon12	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JSTUART	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	JSTUART	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	RickyD	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MadMooner	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	bea175	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	antlers	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MikeReilly	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Ringman	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	persiandog	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	persiandog	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	efw	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	persiandog	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	R_H_Clark	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	persiandog	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	CCCC	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	curdog4570	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gus	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	MojoHand	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Jim_Conrad	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/05/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Steelhead	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	Gitsum	10/06/16
Re: Why does everyone hate atheists?	the_shootist	10/06/16

Moderated by RickBin

Link Copied to Clipboard

AX24

499 members (1beaver_shooter, 1badf350, 219DW, 1minute, 1lessdog, 06hunter59, 50 invisible), 2,266 guests, and 1,231 robots.

Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod

May
S	M	T	W	T	F	S
			1	2	3	4
5	6	7	8	9	10	11
12	13	14	15	16	17	18
19	20	21	22	23	24	25
26	27	28	29	30	31

Forum Statistics

Forums81

Topics1,193,283

Posts18,505,139

Members73,998

Most Online11,491
Jul 7th, 2023