i have killed deer with both cartridges ,both are good cartridges and so are many others. i don`t use either of these cartridges anymore just because i wanted just one cartridge for family to hunt with at deer camp with less recoil so i went with 257 Roberts for all 3 ladies , myself and my 2 grandkids . this way there will be no confusion on who has what ammo anymore , believe me different size cartridges and keeping track of who has what can be even dangerous.
