Originally Posted by Blackheart
Originally Posted by Mule Deer
Blackheart,

No, I don't know more than anybody else. No human does. But I do have more experience than most hunters, so can appreciate (and learn) from other hunters' experience.

You, on the other hand, think YOUR experience is the ONLY experience that counts. This isn't unusual among humans, but most aren't as insistent about it. In fact, you're one of the perfect examples of what a good friend of mine calls "aggressive ignorance."

I'm trying to get an answer to whether there are or shoud be limits to what constitutes fair chase. We used to call certain things "unsporting" if they left little chance for survival to the game. Things like shotgunning birds on the ground or jacklighting deer were considerd not to be fair chase or sporting. Seems like anything goes now so long as something gets killed. If rangefinders and dialing scopes for 1000 yard shots is ok, why not just use spotlights and hunt at night ?


How fair is fair? How good a chance does the game need to have to get away? You like to brag about how you've killed deer every year since the Civil War and talk about how sparse they are where you hunt. If they really had a "fair chance" to get away you would've come up empty at least once.

We all stack the deck in our favor and you're no different.



A wise man is frequently humbled.