Originally Posted by Birdwatcher
Quote
i think he answered you BW... do you feel ike the flag shouldnt fly on statehouse grounds at a confederate monument?


I think it is ludicrous to suggest that people fly that grand old flag out of "racism". I think it is also ludicrous to suggest that flying that flag necessarily implies the owner wishes the South had actually won. That would be about like saying that everyone who wears a kilt and plays the pipes wishes the Celts still lived under the vicious and decidedly UNfree clan system.

OTOH I got a Black co-worker, a retired Military Officer, who says that the people who originally flew that flag enslaved his own ancestors and, more importantly, the ancestors of his children and grandchildren.

Hey, build a Confederate memorial on yer own property and fly what you want.

But on public property? A public referendum and vote is the only lawful way to settle it.

You and I would vote to keep the Stars and Bars in place, my friend would probably vote differently.

Birdwatcher


thank you for your answer

so then after the genocide on the american indian, old glory might offend current indians because their ancestors were butchered at wounded knee, or marched on the trail of tears eradicated from their land with genocide coming for the next 55 years after...should old glory fly since it is offensive as well??


"Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered."
― George Orwell, 1984