I'd probably lose the metal-match thingy too and go with a 3rd see-thru lighter in a totally separate pocket if I was feeling truly paranoid. I had a ton of redundant fire-building gear for awhile too. Now that I've been into this more, it's all frivolous over-thinking, to me at least.
If 2 decent butane lighter go south at the same time, your luck already ran out before you stepped foot into the woods.
