Originally Posted by Middlefork_Miner
Originally Posted by smokepole
Originally Posted by Middlefork_Miner
.......the fact remains that at one time, the hunter/client had a handgun and ended up throwing it towards somebody that was probably already incapable of using it...


Listen to what you're saying. You start out with "the fact remains" and you end up with "probably incapable of using it."

You have no idea whether the guide was incapable of using it, hell, he may have even asked the hunter to toss it to him. Shooting a bear while it's on top of a guy would seem to be a dicey proposition, have you ever done it?

The fact remains, you weren't there and you're guessing.

Guide is dead.....client ran for help....figure it out.



No, you figure it out, and make sure to give everyone your opinion on what happened and why. I don't play that game, not having been in that situation myself.

How about you, how many times have you been attacked by a grizzly bear? How did you handle it?


A wise man is frequently humbled.