Originally Posted by Mad_Max
Originally Posted by jorgeI
Originally Posted by kellory
Curiosity, from those who have faced bears, why is a pump shotgun with solid slugs or 00buck, not the preferred close in bear weapon? Fast handling, close in devastation, and a bead sight for fast sighting. Why choose a long range rifle for a close in job?


Because a shotgun lacks penetration, even on the relatively thin skull of the big cats.

True. While bowhunting, a large caliber handgun, 357 on up, is best because of its deployability, maneuverability, power and weight. My preference when returning to one of my kills to pack out the remainder, whether rifle or bow season, is to carry my 45/70. I feel my Marlin Guide 45/70 is the ideal weapon for a close-in bear encounter. My 454 Ruger Alaskan is a close second. Luckily, I've never had to test my opinion or preference.

We are going to start carrying the 50 beowulf AR we have. Pretty good thumper really. Quick repeat shots.

That said I"m generally still comfortable with the G20 and if not either of the above its whatever is decent and handy.

Mostly if you pay attention and keep your head in the game you'll have much less risk. Regardless the risk is there, we are not top of the food chain and wife and I are ok with that.

We can keep Larry Root and all his idiotic blabber and user names on here, but we can't get Ralph back..... Whiskey Tango Foxtrot, over....