I win the lottery. Did God say I'm deserving or was it a statistical fluke? How would you know?
That's easy. There's no evidence of God's involvement, so that means you're just one lucky SOB.
There was plenty of opportunity for God's involvement "evidence" notwithstanding. So again how would you know He didn't put a thumb on the scale and it's lost in the statistical noise that is probability?
If there are other explanations, reasonable ecplanations that account tor the evidence, it is not reasonable to be convinced that you have evidence for the existence of God. Evolution, for example, does not need a God as an explanation for how it works.
