That will work for a plinker. FortuneCookie45LC used a soft-cast, PC painted and lubed 340-grainer sized to .458" as a barely supersonic plinker from his .458 WM, using 16 grains of Unique and no filler. The Berry's plated bullet should work as well or better.
AA-5744 might do even better (no filler needed), and don't forget to try H4198 and H4895 with filler. Speaking of H4895, here is an abbreviated re-run of "No Name Handloader's" work:
H4895 can be used for just about anything good, bad or ugly in the .458 WinMag.
The 56 grain load gives 4761 foot pounds of energy I calculate.