Here is that 500-gr/.458 CEB used in your 460 G&A:
The 500-gr HYDRO without feed cap is 1.525" long, with feed cap about 1.680", too long for my .458 preferences.
At the CEB site here is a 570-gr/.510 brass FN recovered from "elephant shoulder":
I am guessing it came from a .500 NE and probably had MV no more than 2200 fps and would lose about 100 fps for each 25 yards initially. 570-gr/.510 sectional density = 0.313 with greater meplat diameter 500-gr/.458 SD = 0.341 with smaller meplat, for greater "Penetration Index" at similar velocity. No wonder the .510 was recovered and the .458 was not, if we consider similar resistance from a .510 shoulder shot and your .458 head shot ... But if your bullet was impacting at higher velocity it had to overcome a higher initial resistance from the impact media ... Which it did.
Ron aka "Rip" for Riflecrank Internationale Permanente NRA Life Benefactor and Beneficiary .458 Winchester Magnum, Magnanimous in Victory THE WALKING DEAD does so remind me of Democrap voters. Donkeypox.