Originally Posted by WSM_Shooter
Originally Posted by EddyBo
While your generating NUMBERS run us some with the 105 A-max and some 115 D-Tacs. Your last comparisons is like comparing being clubbed in the head with a baseball bat versus a claw hammer because I would not slum either for longrange.


Eddybo, I am sure you are smart enough to know that the formula I used is to compare apples to apples and does not take bullet type into consideration. As for Point Blank Range, again I kept it for the loads quoted for the TKO example.

I compared the calibers in question on an equal field. Plain and simple. Anything past that feel free to run numbers to prove the point you want to make. Like I said in my opinion the type bullet used is more the question needed to be asked opposed to what of the two calibers to choose.


Read the BOLD type above, bullets are way more important than headstamps. Your analysis has no relation to real life if you do not consider bullets it is nothing more than mental masturbation.